Active Users:932 Time:05/07/2025 08:42:22 AM
Oh my. Camilla Send a noteboard - 19/09/2011 08:48:40 PM
I haven't been able to look to confirm this, but apparently the house that the Doctor gives to Amy and Rory, dropping them off there at the end of this episode, is the same house they're in at the start of The Impossible Astronaut. Which ... what?

We've been assuming that the story has been a linear progression from Amy and Rory's point of view, but what if it hasn't? I can't even properly wrap my head around the idea. It would mean that from their point of view right now, The Impossible Astronaut hasn't happened yet. The Doctor dropped them off and left them, then a couple months later they get the blue envelope inviting them to America. But I don't even know if that works. I don't know where the break could be, where we stopped seeing their progression and started seeing older episodes. The idea makes no sense. There was definitely a progression of Amy saying she was pregnant, getting replaced by a flesh duplicate, having her baby, getting her baby taken away, trying to get the Doctor to find her baby, learning Mels is her daughter, and now here in this episode she asks the Doctor to tell her daughter to come visit sometime. There's a clear progression there, yet they end up with a new house that is exactly the same as the house they started in?

And it must have been a new house. The Doctor gives them door keys, and before he does Amy makes a crack about how it's not a real house, not giving any indication she recognizes it or views it as home. But if it really is the same house as at the start of the season, I just don't know what to think.


That is very weird. Wait. No. Never mind. There isn't any time where they could have switched. Unless it was in America, and that makes absolutely no sense, because. Damn you. Now I won't sleep tonight because my brain will want to make sense of this. And I don't have time to watch through the season again.
*MySmiley*
structured procrastinator
Reply to message
Doctor Who - New Mysteries and Mad Theories - 19/09/2011 05:10:20 PM 5581 Views
Also, the Doctor's room. - 19/09/2011 05:22:08 PM 618 Views
Agreed - 19/09/2011 08:45:02 PM 615 Views
Of course, it occurs to me ... - 19/09/2011 06:13:55 PM 532 Views
Re: Of course, it occurs to me ... - 19/09/2011 09:01:40 PM 606 Views
That's true. (Rampant ganger speculation within) - 19/09/2011 09:12:28 PM 615 Views
Oooh. This I could get behind - 19/09/2011 09:16:02 PM 608 Views
The more I think about it, the more I like it. - 19/09/2011 09:31:24 PM 697 Views
Re: The more I think about it, the more I like it. - 19/09/2011 09:35:15 PM 715 Views
New information fries Nate's brain. - 19/09/2011 06:30:48 PM 847 Views
Oh my. - 19/09/2011 08:48:40 PM 676 Views
I'll look through them tonight and see if it really is the same. *NM* - 19/09/2011 08:55:41 PM 270 Views
I can confirm that it's not the same house. - 19/09/2011 11:52:22 PM 507 Views
Re: I can confirm that it's not the same house. - 20/09/2011 06:43:00 AM 526 Views
More on nesting aliens theory - 20/09/2011 06:44:25 AM 531 Views
Interesting theory. - 20/09/2011 02:03:57 PM 573 Views
You spelt 'gangster' wrong. - 21/09/2011 02:20:51 PM 644 Views
Piqued is a word *NM* - 23/09/2011 09:59:42 AM 285 Views
Article: Has Doctor Who Got Too Complicated? - 21/09/2011 04:28:41 PM 672 Views
Poppycock - 23/09/2011 10:01:31 AM 617 Views
I 100% noticed the apple. - 22/09/2011 07:30:52 PM 580 Views
Promo pictures for The Wedding of River Song - 23/09/2011 12:51:27 AM 748 Views
Wow. - 23/09/2011 01:12:08 AM 603 Views
Re: Wow. - 23/09/2011 10:03:13 AM 696 Views
Oh, that's a good theory. - 23/09/2011 01:33:39 PM 544 Views
Re: Oh, that's a good theory. - 23/09/2011 02:05:54 PM 504 Views
Oh my GOD - 23/09/2011 10:02:40 AM 543 Views
Oh, the caps are justified. - 23/09/2011 01:31:59 PM 564 Views
Definitely justified. - 23/09/2011 02:25:14 PM 476 Views
In related news, Season Seven air date info. - 23/09/2011 09:44:21 PM 793 Views

Reply to Message