Active Users:378 Time:16/06/2025 08:55:13 PM
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules
No, I do. You probably read my tangent about my disagreement with Lucas about Vader's redemption. TaskmasterJack Send a noteboard - 10/06/2012 12:41:36 AM

It didn't directly have anything to do with the balance discussion, just one other thing I disagree with Lucas on that pertained to Anakin.

What I mean is that, according to this view of the prophecy, all his actions prior to the end of RotJ are, well, completely left out of the balance, so to speak. It's not a matter of a comparatively small thing supposedly balancing out a ton of crimes. Rather, it's a matter of the prophecy having far less relevancy than people assumed, and predicting one specific action while overlooking everything else.

So the only thing that is a "balance achievement" is the moment when Anakin/Vader takes out the Sith Lord.


Yes, as I've said, I see the path of Lucas' train of thought. I just disagree with the track his train was riding on.
Reply to message
"..the one to bring balance to the force" dacole - 08/06/2012 08:42:49 PM 1561 Views
I was under the impression it was widely accepted that Anakin brought balance to the force... Legolas - 08/06/2012 09:36:55 PM 1236 Views
Actually, the most recent book revealed a solid answer to the prophecy. Kotagg - 08/06/2012 10:48:43 PM 1299 Views
Is that really as canon as the movies? chandra - 09/06/2012 01:29:49 AM 1182 Views
As canon as Han saying the Death Star was too big to be a space station... TaskmasterJack - 09/06/2012 03:21:12 PM 1064 Views
Re: As canon as Han saying the Death Star was too big to be a space station... dacole - 10/06/2012 06:24:16 AM 1056 Views
The books are entirely canon. Kotagg - 11/06/2012 06:46:23 AM 1149 Views
Re: The books are entirely canon. dacole - 11/06/2012 04:43:47 PM 1144 Views
There are certainly some inconsistencies, but very few outright contradictions. Kotagg - 11/06/2012 07:47:25 PM 1129 Views
"Balance to the Force" is a numbers game. The key is in a comment by Yoda at the end of Ep. 1. TaskmasterJack - 08/06/2012 11:04:03 PM 1148 Views
Re: "Balance to the Force" is a numbers game. The key is in a comment by Yoda at the end of Ep. 1. dacole - 09/06/2012 06:04:39 AM 1102 Views
This. *NM* Rebekah - 09/06/2012 06:06:16 AM 579 Views
But Obi Wan said Anakin was prophecied to destroy the Sith "not join them!" And he did. Eventually. *NM* Cannoli - 11/06/2012 04:38:42 PM 644 Views
Technically, going strictly by the films, that could have been supposition rather than quotation. *NM* TaskmasterJack - 11/06/2012 10:01:16 PM 554 Views
I figured he did it by clearing the deck snoopcester - 08/06/2012 11:33:03 PM 1044 Views
If things are going well, then balance is the last thing you want A Deathwatch Guard - 09/06/2012 04:46:37 AM 1025 Views
Are you saying there are plot holes in Star Wars? Never! *NM* Rebekah - 09/06/2012 06:09:59 AM 693 Views
Re: If things are going well, then balance is the last thing you want dacole - 09/06/2012 06:17:44 AM 1092 Views
I still think the bringing balance refers to what happens AFTER ROTJ ironclad - 09/06/2012 10:19:01 AM 1099 Views
Re: I still think the bringing balance refers to what happens AFTER ROTJ DomA - 09/06/2012 11:42:32 AM 1112 Views
Re: I still think the bringing balance refers to what happens AFTER ROTJ dacole - 11/06/2012 04:49:06 PM 1015 Views
This will sound offensive, sorry, but that sounds incredibly dumb. TaskmasterJack - 09/06/2012 03:09:20 PM 1134 Views
I don't see how it's dumb ironclad - 09/06/2012 04:26:43 PM 1101 Views
Re: I don't see how it's dumb TaskmasterJack - 09/06/2012 06:18:17 PM 1009 Views
I don't like your analogy - organisation vs nationality snoopcester - 09/06/2012 07:06:44 PM 1050 Views
What if I had said Christians instead of Americans? Then you'd have the comparison you favor. *NM* TaskmasterJack - 09/06/2012 08:44:21 PM 566 Views
No I wouldn't, I'm frankly confused as to why you think I would favour that more snoopcester - 09/06/2012 09:03:28 PM 1118 Views
Not ideal maybe, but more an organization of people than a nation of people. TaskmasterJack - 10/06/2012 12:11:51 AM 977 Views
Even at best you are takling of a multitude of organisations snoopcester - 10/06/2012 08:23:28 AM 1033 Views
What you seem to be overlooking... Legolas - 09/06/2012 08:50:30 PM 1162 Views
Precisely *NM* ironclad - 09/06/2012 10:17:18 PM 586 Views
I'm not overlooking it. I just don't view the moment as one of "balance achievement". TaskmasterJack - 10/06/2012 12:09:45 AM 1084 Views
Your other posts don't sound as if you see what I'm getting at here... Legolas - 10/06/2012 12:22:02 AM 994 Views
No, I do. You probably read my tangent about my disagreement with Lucas about Vader's redemption. TaskmasterJack - 10/06/2012 12:41:36 AM 1150 Views
Also... TaskmasterJack - 10/06/2012 12:18:11 AM 1112 Views
Another thing. TaskmasterJack - 09/06/2012 03:13:43 PM 983 Views
The concept of evil in SW (like in WOT) is Zoroastrian, not Taoist DomA - 09/06/2012 12:26:20 PM 1056 Views
*Like* *NM* Stephen - 09/06/2012 02:13:15 PM 580 Views
Re: The concept of evil in SW (like in WOT) is Zoroastrian, not Taoist dacole - 11/06/2012 05:05:31 PM 1143 Views
The problem with Star Wars is that smart people analyze it, but... it's pretty simplistic beetnemesis - 10/06/2012 03:34:13 AM 1155 Views
Re: The problem with Star Wars is that smart people analyze it, but... it's pretty simplistic dacole - 11/06/2012 05:06:54 PM 1146 Views
I always saw it as... j-whitt987 - 16/06/2012 04:40:00 AM 1234 Views
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules

Reply to Message

Block Quote Paragraph Quote
Formatting
Smiley Codes