Active Users:275 Time:03/05/2024 06:43:41 PM
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules
I'm going to make one last attempt before giving up Deadsy Send a noteboard - 20/09/2010 10:03:54 PM
Min actually states that the only viewing she ever got wrong was that Rand could not succeed without a woman dead and gone. IIRC she never once thinks about Thom and Moiraine.


"Rand will die without Moiraine."


This viewing CANNOT fail. It isn't possible. If Moiraine dies, then the viewing comes true. If she lives, the viewing comes true. It's just a statement. He'll die if Moiraine dies. It's 100% impossible for this viewing to fail. It's like saying "The grass will grow if it rains." If it rains it will grow, if it doesn't rain it won't grow. It can't fail. It's correct no matter what happens. Therefore, this is not the viewing that Min is thinking of.

What failed is a viewing Min had about Moiraine doing something that she hasn't done yet, which is impossible to do if she's gone. There's nothing about the dead and gone viewing which is impossible. As far as Min knows the viewing is still accurate. Moiraine is dead, Rand will fail, the viewing is correct.
This message last edited by Deadsy on 20/09/2010 at 10:05:02 PM
Reply to message
moiraine's three questions Foxhead - 18/09/2010 12:21:52 AM 1526 Views
She knew he'd survive because Min told Moiraine they end up together, and they weren't a couple yet. TaskmasterJack - 18/09/2010 12:56:09 AM 668 Views
Can that really be right? ursidae - 18/09/2010 06:44:40 PM 806 Views
That is her "thimble of hope" that she mentions twice *NM* Deadsy - 18/09/2010 07:41:23 PM 313 Views
Re: That is her "thimble of hope" that she mentions twice darius_sedai - 18/09/2010 08:19:03 PM 683 Views
She needs to have known that she would see Thom again Deadsy - 18/09/2010 08:25:37 PM 623 Views
Re: She needs to have known that she would see Thom again darius_sedai - 18/09/2010 09:26:26 PM 653 Views
It doesn't change your point, but I know she hadn't entered the doorway yet. It was in this chapter Deadsy - 18/09/2010 11:58:53 PM 541 Views
I'll take your word for it darius_sedai - 19/09/2010 06:10:43 AM 599 Views
You're misinterpreting which viewing is the one which Min believes turned out wrong. TaskmasterJack - 19/09/2010 03:33:04 AM 538 Views
???? darius_sedai - 19/09/2010 06:08:11 AM 674 Views
Wrong, she never specifies WHICH viewing was the wrong one. Cannoli - 19/09/2010 07:28:21 AM 797 Views
It's something that you have to work out for yourself, it's not thrown in your face. TaskmasterJack - 19/09/2010 06:35:43 PM 564 Views
I see your logic trail, I just don't think Min would have told something like that to Moiraine darius_sedai - 20/09/2010 09:46:01 PM 625 Views
What on earth gave you that idea? Min has always liked Moiraine. Deadsy - 20/09/2010 09:59:09 PM 538 Views
Dude. She tells Moiraine about it immediately upon first seeing Thom in Baerlon. TaskmasterJack - 21/09/2010 12:13:58 AM 566 Views
No, you're the one who's wrong. DomA - 19/09/2010 07:54:02 PM 579 Views
*shrugs* ... as I stated before I see the logic you are all pointing too ... it just doesn't seem darius_sedai - 20/09/2010 09:48:02 PM 700 Views
Are you forgetting EOTW? It was crystal clear that Min told Moiraine about all of her viewings Deadsy - 20/09/2010 09:56:36 PM 685 Views
She doesn't have any reason to think that's wrong yet, though. Sareitha Sedai - 20/09/2010 06:02:37 PM 718 Views
I'm going to make one last attempt before giving up Deadsy - 20/09/2010 10:03:54 PM 627 Views
Yes, you're right newyorkersedai - 21/09/2010 12:20:47 AM 535 Views
another interpretation (albeit, irrelevant to this discussion ) LadyLorraine - 21/09/2010 04:55:30 AM 642 Views
If that fulfilled the viewing Min would never have said Deadsy - 21/09/2010 05:07:34 AM 571 Views
it's likely Jim - 18/09/2010 07:53:30 PM 731 Views
And she said the husband comment before going to the Aelfinn, and believed his survival back in EotW Cannoli - 19/09/2010 12:15:26 AM 648 Views
Re: And she said the husband comment before going to the Aelfinn... DomA - 19/09/2010 08:20:29 PM 726 Views
EotW p568 Cannoli - 21/09/2010 05:22:23 PM 651 Views
She probably asked how to best guide and protect Rand Cannoli - 19/09/2010 12:20:56 AM 756 Views
I tend to agree DomA - 19/09/2010 07:08:50 PM 731 Views
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules

Reply to Message

Block Quote Paragraph Quote
Formatting
Smiley Codes