Active Users:323 Time:15/05/2024 10:17:59 AM
Just playing devil's advocate here ... Shishka Send a noteboard - 12/10/2010 10:58:40 PM
Min also says that Rand will die, in her Alivia viewing. Nicola sees Rand as the one who is dead yet lives, and the Wise Ones recognize that body as Rand.


Which fits with the Aelfinn interpretation. That is, Rand's body dies, so it's Rand who dies. That satisfies Min's Alivia viewing (assuming she helped Rand's body die), Nicola's foretelling, and the WOs dream.

The "confused" part is Min's viewing of the merger and her interpretation of it. In that case, Rand's body dies, but Rand is the one who ultimately continues to exist (to Min, the one who lives), and Moridin the one who ultimately ceases to exist (to Min, the one who dies). In this case, the death of Rand's body is irrelevant to the who dies and who lives part of the viewing. It's only relevant to how the merger ultimately completes (and to Min's viewing of Alivia).

Also, if the Aelfinn are aware of the circumstances by which Rand must die in order to live, then it seems unlikely they would be confused on the matter.


As I said above, the idea is that it's Min's viewing of the merger that is "confused", not the Aelfinn interpretation.

And finally, IMO it cheapens the sacrifice that Rand must make if he does not actually die. I realize there is little difference in the end, but...


I don't see that it cheapens the sacrifice, since he'd still be dying without having any idea what would happen next, but I understand what you mean. The main problem I have with it is if Rand's soul ends up in Moridin's body, it's akin to Transmigration (event though the DO wouldn't be involved in what I suggested) - i.e. a soul taking over someone else's body. That's been portrayed as an evil thing the DO does to resurrect his minions, and therefore doesn't seem an appropriate fate for one of the good guys. Then again, Rand has murdered his share of the Forsaken, and murder is an evil thing the Shadow does, too. So maybe Rand taking over a Forsaken's body in particular shouldn't be considered "evil". Except, Moridin got that body from a captured non-DF, presumably, so Rand would end up getting a body that once belonged to a fellow "good guy", which is "evil". So, depends on how you want to look at it.

Whereas the rip-from-TAR idea has no such thematic problems.
Rise and fall, turn the Wheel,
'cause all life is
is really just a circle.

-BHT&tM
Reply to message
attn: Etzel re: theories on the fulfillment of Rand's death prophecies - 12/10/2010 12:35:42 AM 1422 Views
You never noticed the Noteboard feature, did you? - 12/10/2010 03:37:53 AM 670 Views
Actually, I made it a survey. - 12/10/2010 03:42:16 AM 601 Views
Horn Double Death - 12/10/2010 05:30:47 AM 859 Views
If he dies when called by the Horn... - 12/10/2010 05:34:56 AM 540 Views
Re: If he dies when called by the Horn... - 12/10/2010 05:53:53 AM 563 Views
Re: If he dies when called by the Horn... - 12/10/2010 05:55:28 AM 571 Views
I just don't see that as Nynaeve's "area of expertise" - 13/10/2010 10:09:39 PM 615 Views
Nynaeve was the one who witnessed the weave, not Egwene. - 14/10/2010 12:38:14 AM 592 Views
Another Variation on the Horn - 13/10/2010 04:28:38 AM 560 Views
There's also the "ripped from TAR after death" theory, ala Birgitte (re how Rand lives again). - 12/10/2010 04:37:26 PM 682 Views
That be my theory - 12/10/2010 04:45:55 PM 692 Views
and from all other people - 12/10/2010 05:33:45 PM 790 Views
And your point is? *NM* - 12/10/2010 05:35:35 PM 293 Views
It's not specifically your theory. or a theory that you thought of first..... *NM* - 13/10/2010 04:32:48 PM 287 Views
Nobody said I thought of it first. - 13/10/2010 04:36:45 PM 529 Views
Re: Nobody said I thought of it first. - 13/10/2010 06:27:29 PM 623 Views
It's the truth. - 13/10/2010 06:29:56 PM 547 Views
Think of it this way, Emma... - 13/10/2010 06:00:11 PM 640 Views
Re: Think of it this way, Emma... *NM* - 13/10/2010 06:26:09 PM 350 Views
You could at least try not to contradict yourself. - 13/10/2010 06:29:11 PM 513 Views
Me being childish? - 13/10/2010 06:52:24 PM 569 Views
Some more thoughts ... - 12/10/2010 05:03:58 PM 695 Views
I don't think it is necessary that Rand be a public figure as Elayne's husband. - 12/10/2010 05:08:10 PM 569 Views
It's not that I think it's necessary, per se ... - 12/10/2010 05:44:03 PM 683 Views
On that particular point... - 12/10/2010 06:05:59 PM 671 Views
That's reasonable speculation, I think ... - 12/10/2010 07:58:23 PM 591 Views
I don't know that Egwene's lack of recognition necessarily means anything... - 12/10/2010 08:07:11 PM 513 Views
Yep, I agree ... - 12/10/2010 09:18:57 PM 620 Views
By the way ... - 12/10/2010 10:07:49 PM 520 Views
But that is not the only prophecy of Rand's death. - 12/10/2010 10:13:50 PM 516 Views
Just playing devil's advocate here ... - 12/10/2010 10:58:40 PM 672 Views
That raises an interesting question: - 13/10/2010 04:01:17 PM 603 Views
Re: That raises an interesting question: - 13/10/2010 05:57:39 PM 629 Views
IIRC... - 12/10/2010 07:58:39 PM 703 Views
That is unfortunate. - 12/10/2010 08:02:18 PM 607 Views
Switching bodies with Logain is mine. *NM* - 13/10/2010 05:03:43 AM 321 Views
Are we doing that now? I call dibs on Be'laim. - 14/10/2010 04:32:59 PM 647 Views
Body swap or Nynaeve heal seem the best bets to me. - 14/10/2010 04:42:16 PM 590 Views

Reply to Message