I wouldn't go so far as to say TOTALLY, but I was not satisfied.
HyogaRott Send a noteboard - 14/01/2013 06:04:30 PM
It seemed as though the book spent too much time on WHAT people were doing and not enough on WHY.
For most of the series the reader received a thorough (maybe too much) explanation on why people did things and then a brief display of them doing it (often we were not shown them doing it). In the final book we got very little of the why explained, most of them were revealed by showing what someone else was doing. The result was a book that definitely felt like it was written by someone other than Robert Jordan.
Net result is that certain characters completely lost their payoff. An excellent example is Min who for at least 5 books was built up as the person who would solve the problem of the bore, then NOTHING. If she did, then it happened completely off screen and Rand never gives her any credit. Her entire purpose in the series is suddenly reduced to being Rand's girlfriend and a foreshadowing provider. You can completely delete her character, and for that matter Aviendha, as they no longer serve any useful purpose (they don’t even get to be pregnant with Rand’s kids).
It is the same with many of the secondary characters. Moirane was supposed to be essential to Rand winning, but all she did was place a pause into an argument with Egwene that anyone could have provided. For all we saw in the book, she could have just stayed dead. Other than walking into the bore, she did absolutely NOTHING. Thom would have guarded the bore without her. The bore solution probably came from Min and her but we never saw it. Instead we get chapter after chapter of trolloc killing and Slayer chasing...
The last book fell flat for me. It ended the series, but it was not a grand conclusion.
For most of the series the reader received a thorough (maybe too much) explanation on why people did things and then a brief display of them doing it (often we were not shown them doing it). In the final book we got very little of the why explained, most of them were revealed by showing what someone else was doing. The result was a book that definitely felt like it was written by someone other than Robert Jordan.
Net result is that certain characters completely lost their payoff. An excellent example is Min who for at least 5 books was built up as the person who would solve the problem of the bore, then NOTHING. If she did, then it happened completely off screen and Rand never gives her any credit. Her entire purpose in the series is suddenly reduced to being Rand's girlfriend and a foreshadowing provider. You can completely delete her character, and for that matter Aviendha, as they no longer serve any useful purpose (they don’t even get to be pregnant with Rand’s kids).
It is the same with many of the secondary characters. Moirane was supposed to be essential to Rand winning, but all she did was place a pause into an argument with Egwene that anyone could have provided. For all we saw in the book, she could have just stayed dead. Other than walking into the bore, she did absolutely NOTHING. Thom would have guarded the bore without her. The bore solution probably came from Min and her but we never saw it. Instead we get chapter after chapter of trolloc killing and Slayer chasing...
The last book fell flat for me. It ended the series, but it was not a grand conclusion.
Anyone else totally unimpressed?
09/01/2013 04:58:39 AM
- 2212 Views
I couldn't disagree more
09/01/2013 05:32:41 AM
- 1178 Views
I enjoyed the book as entertainment
09/01/2013 05:47:22 AM
- 1112 Views
I found the ongoing Trolloc killing a bit tedious.
09/01/2013 06:14:25 AM
- 971 Views
Re: I found the ongoing Trolloc killing a bit tedious.
29/01/2013 11:01:11 AM
- 848 Views
I had extremely low expectations, which I guess were sort of met.
09/01/2013 06:12:05 AM
- 1206 Views
Mine weren't, even with the low expectations
09/01/2013 05:04:07 PM
- 1334 Views
I don't remember you being such an arrogant prick years ago on WoTmania
11/01/2013 05:28:07 AM
- 1008 Views
Pardon, but I don't even recall who you are *NM*
11/01/2013 08:39:54 AM
- 521 Views
You are a...
18/01/2013 08:21:54 AM
- 974 Views
Uh...
18/01/2013 12:19:13 PM
- 987 Views
Rather...
18/01/2013 09:11:11 PM
- 966 Views
Why does any of this matter to you?
18/01/2013 10:35:18 PM
- 1047 Views
Oh sure...
19/01/2013 06:43:19 AM
- 851 Views
No, not quite
19/01/2013 08:57:47 AM
- 901 Views
LoL @ Larry
19/01/2013 09:21:13 PM
- 838 Views
Ummm....
19/01/2013 10:05:30 PM
- 897 Views
That was a dodge.
20/01/2013 01:40:59 AM
- 893 Views
Nah, more like me cutting this short.
20/01/2013 02:30:28 AM
- 895 Views
I thought it was fantastic
09/01/2013 07:46:16 AM
- 1098 Views
I'm surprised you are so happy with it. It was action packed, but sloppy. Usually you dislike that
20/01/2013 01:55:17 AM
- 916 Views
I wouldn't go so far as to say TOTALLY, but I was not satisfied.
14/01/2013 06:04:30 PM
- 938 Views
I will say that the battle was well constructed in certain places
14/01/2013 06:10:54 PM
- 915 Views