Active Users:275 Time:04/05/2024 07:18:27 AM
Tarmon Gaidon ended up being a series of skirmishes RugbyPlayingAshaman Send a noteboard - 25/10/2013 05:33:01 PM

I agree that the battle felt small. After all of the knowledge we've accumulated in regards to the use of the One Power in battle, all we get are both sides standing across a field and massive, uncoordinated weaving and a throwaway line from Galad that the power of all those channelers was incredible?

There are wards, counter-wards, reversing weaves, direct weaves, indirect weaves, elemental weaves, gateways, etc., yet the channelers conveniently stood on one side of the battlefield for the most part, and didn't use a tenth of the tricks we've seen in smaller battles throughout the series.

I can't blame Sanderson; I have my own imagination to fill in the blanks, but the lack of specificity regarding numbers and the lack of creative strategies was underwhelming.

Heck, I'm even willing to buy that Androl/Pevara's mutual link was in RJ's notes, but this is precisely the type of knowledge that should have been used in the last and most decisive hour of fighting in defense of reality. If Egwene had Bonded Logain after blasting Taim, then proceeded to blast Demandred to oblivion or better yet, Shield him for trial, I would have been happy. Icing on the cake would have been the White Tower delivering Moghedien to the Seanchan as a punishment. There were just so many ways to make multiple scenarios escalate so that the resolution was at a crescendo in the story, but yet the payoffs were just so bland.

Ah well. I don't mind Cadsuane, but I do think it would have been fitting if something came of her resolution with the Wise Ones that Graendal needed to be taken down, even if it was Aviendha who ultimately did it. The scene had gravitas, but the energy was allowed to disperse.

For a book with so many battle scenes, it was particularly unsatisfying to me.

I'm not even getting into the numbers issue. I'm a channeler fan, so I particularly have been keeping track of the comparative strengths of each force, but some of the vagueness was just ridiculous. So in the battle for all reality, during which victory was hanging by a mere thread and the integrity of space/time itself was unfolding...you leave a sizable number of trained Yellow Ajah and all of your initiates in the medical facility. From a humanitarian standpoint, I get it - but in terms of how what the White Tower, Lightside Ashaman and Wise Ones were facing, every Circle would help.

I'm not too much of a fan of the non-channelers, even though I have interest in strategy and military history, so I'm not touching those with a ten foot shocklance.

TBQH I found myself more apprehensive of Faile's storyline, moreso than the actual battlefield drama. Pretty good way for the Falcon to end the series.

"Those who think they have no time for bodily exercise will sooner or later have to find time for illness."
This message last edited by RugbyPlayingAshaman on 25/10/2013 at 05:38:01 PM
Reply to message
Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 19/08/2013 08:47:35 AM 1432 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 19/08/2013 05:40:49 PM 727 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 19/08/2013 09:09:48 PM 840 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 20/08/2013 01:04:39 AM 859 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 21/08/2013 04:05:44 PM 1016 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 22/08/2013 01:20:26 AM 826 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 22/08/2013 04:13:42 AM 924 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 19/08/2013 10:52:26 PM 884 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 20/08/2013 02:06:05 AM 845 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 21/08/2013 04:45:49 PM 918 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 21/08/2013 10:34:06 PM 753 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 22/08/2013 12:46:54 AM 960 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 21/08/2013 10:48:26 PM 1397 Views
Which reminds me... - 23/08/2013 06:09:14 PM 789 Views
Re: Which reminds me... - 23/08/2013 08:42:47 PM 727 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 22/08/2013 04:24:19 AM 979 Views
Re: Hey, looks like I finally read it. - 20/08/2013 02:08:16 AM 785 Views
I wish I had something to add - 22/08/2013 07:26:07 PM 716 Views
Well, that's still something . *NM* - 23/08/2013 03:35:41 AM 357 Views
I agree... - 23/08/2013 08:47:07 PM 684 Views
Tarmon Gaidon ended up being a series of skirmishes - 25/10/2013 05:33:01 PM 857 Views
I'm a C+ terran on ICCUP, you still play Broodwar? *NM* - 27/10/2013 04:07:08 AM 367 Views
That's pretty impressive! - 27/10/2013 04:18:10 AM 783 Views
Re: That's pretty impressive! - 27/10/2013 06:02:37 PM 636 Views

Reply to Message