Active Users:648 Time:16/03/2026 10:56:41 AM
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules
Agreed in the case of Lions of al-Rassan. Legolas Send a noteboard - 07/04/2012 10:34:02 AM
I said elsewhere on occasion when his name would be brought up that I disliked his heavy-handed borrowing from historical sources, as it dried up my interest almost immediately, as I knew what would broadly happen, as I recognized the real-life analogues to the characters.

Haven't read Sarantium or Under Heaven. The thing with borrowing so heavily from real sources is that you're pretty much damned if you do and damned if you don't. Either you follow history as it really happened and then the most interested readers will also be the ones who already know what will happen. Or you deviate from history as it happened at a certain point, as in Lions of al-Rassan, and then those readers will be hypercritical about how realistic or plausible your departure from history is.

I loved how Jacqueline Carey did it, though - sufficiently far from real history that she could write her own stories without bothering the history buffs.
Reply to message
Is there a universally liked fantasy book? Tim - 06/04/2012 08:51:12 PM 2054 Views
I like The Fionavar Tapestry, but I don't expect everybody does. Legolas - 06/04/2012 09:08:18 PM 1504 Views
Not really Larry - 07/04/2012 01:23:38 AM 1413 Views
That surprises me. I would think you'd have enjoyed LIONS or TIGANA. *NM* Ghavrel - 07/04/2012 07:39:08 AM 546 Views
I disliked Sarantium and Under Heaven Larry - 07/04/2012 07:49:50 AM 1381 Views
Agreed in the case of Lions of al-Rassan. Legolas - 07/04/2012 10:34:02 AM 1294 Views
i love ggk. haven't read the other one. interesting question... curious to see what comes of it temeraire - 07/04/2012 03:19:45 AM 1237 Views
Seems a silly question to ask. Ghavrel - 07/04/2012 07:37:44 AM 1294 Views
Simply--no. Palatine - 07/04/2012 04:37:16 PM 1695 Views
Except for LOTR wasn't that original. Stephen - 07/04/2012 05:14:49 PM 1190 Views
Perhaps. Palatine - 08/04/2012 04:33:07 PM 1352 Views
Re: Perhaps. dacole - 09/04/2012 02:39:42 AM 1242 Views
Agreed. Tolkien is the closest you'll get. Tom - 09/04/2012 12:46:04 AM 1341 Views
I agree about Tolkien DomA - 11/04/2012 12:35:51 AM 1311 Views
Sword of Truth series. *NM* Kotagg - 07/04/2012 06:11:27 PM 537 Views
Seconded. We should all grow yurds. *NM* Artsapat - 09/04/2012 07:33:00 PM 635 Views
I haven't read either of those A Deathwatch Guard - 07/04/2012 11:52:47 PM 1247 Views
Hm. I think it'd be hard to hate David Eddings' The Belgariad beetnemesis - 09/04/2012 06:32:49 PM 1197 Views
That only counts for those who have nostalgic feelings for it, I'm afraid. *NM* Legolas - 09/04/2012 08:45:48 PM 571 Views
Yes, trying to read it for the first time aged 19 wasn't an enjoyable experience. Stephen - 10/04/2012 01:03:19 AM 1188 Views
More like having your love for it curdle into hate after reading the Mallorean, Elenium & Tamuli Cannoli - 10/04/2012 02:42:49 PM 1439 Views
Ha, at least in Mallorean it was a plot point (albeit a lame one) beetnemesis - 10/04/2012 03:52:27 PM 1315 Views
nostalgia kick for sure. i daren't reread that Foxhead - 01/05/2012 10:25:24 PM 1647 Views
I would've thought Tigana. rebelaessedai - 10/04/2012 04:24:56 AM 1199 Views
Horrendous Book Wibble - 10/04/2012 12:16:55 PM 1251 Views
I love Tigana, but yeah, Wibble's not the only one who doesn't. Legolas - 10/04/2012 07:13:00 PM 1199 Views
Good to know. rebelaessedai - 16/04/2012 04:56:48 AM 1562 Views
I read Tigana very recently Stephen - 16/04/2012 02:12:38 PM 1331 Views
Well, like I said, it's not one of my faves. rebelaessedai - 10/05/2012 03:53:49 AM 1385 Views
Of course not. Who could like something that's not real? *NM* jh - 10/04/2012 07:39:30 PM 548 Views
Oh, that's a really good question. Vivien - 10/04/2012 08:52:51 PM 1313 Views
Re: Oh, that's a really good question. DomA - 10/04/2012 11:33:36 PM 1236 Views
I had Hobb recommende to me LadyLorraine - 11/04/2012 03:38:35 AM 1244 Views
Same here. Stephen - 16/04/2012 02:14:06 PM 1262 Views
so the tawny man onwards kind of sucked Foxhead - 01/05/2012 10:27:41 PM 1408 Views
ursula le guin - earthsea? *NM* Foxhead - 01/05/2012 10:28:35 PM 668 Views
The first one, at least, should be liked by everyone. (IMO) Tim - 01/05/2012 10:59:34 PM 1231 Views
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules

Reply to Message

Block Quote Paragraph Quote
Formatting
Smiley Codes