Active Users:370 Time:03/05/2024 08:55:04 AM
bad analogy moondog Send a noteboard - 07/05/2014 12:19:26 AM

View original post
(Note: Maybe a conversation will be good for the place?)

The idea that you sitting there listening (or not listening as the case were) amounts to "forcing" you to participate boggles my mind. You do realize that prayer is not a passive activity? It is active. If you're sitting there listening to someone else pray, that is not prayer. You are just sitting there listening to someone else talk.

Also the concept of the presence of religion in a public setting amounts to establishing a religion does not work. A government establishing a religion would be the Church of England (historical). The king established the faith. He modeled it after what he believed and wanted using another as 95% of the framework (note: percentage made up on the fly...but you get my meaning hopefully).

I'm not picking a fight. I'm just stating that you sitting there doesn't amount to you participating or supporting. Much akin to <name a group> has a parade doesn't make you a supporter because you happen to pay taxes in that city.

~Jeordam


if i have a reason to be sitting at that parade, then yes i am being forced to endure something i may not believe in. if i go to a government meeting, it is because i am participating in my government. active participation, not passive, as you say. it is presumed that i chose to attend a government meeting in order to do my civic duty as a citizen. why should i be subjected to an invocation that i do not practice, and what will the government agents' reaction to me be if i do not participate in the prayer? you know what i would appreciate, if we are going to have this kind of religious discussion at government meetings? do the invocation at the end, after the business has been taken care of, and for the people who wish to participate. i do not go to meetings to get deluged with religion, i go to them because their business affects me and i need to participate to be heard.

that being said, if the town of greece wants to invite multiple faiths to provide the invocation, that is fine because they are then truly not establishing a particular faith for their meetings. by only allowing in the other faiths after they ask to be included, they are de facto establishing a particular religion as the preferred one, something i think should not have been able to stand.

"The RIAA has shown a certain disregard for the creative people of the industry in their eagerness to protect the revenues of the record companies." -- Frank Zappa

"That's the trouble with political jokes in this country... they get elected!" -- Dave Lippman
Reply to message
SCOTUS - Time to pray at Town Council meetings! - 05/05/2014 06:54:56 PM 902 Views
I'm agnostic but I think they made the right decision - 05/05/2014 08:09:21 PM 511 Views
Yeah, pretty much how I feel *NM* - 06/05/2014 12:27:22 AM 223 Views
Absolutely.....I'm not religious, but I love this decision..... - 06/05/2014 02:36:29 AM 454 Views
I think you're misunderstanding the problem. It's not a question of being "offended" - 06/05/2014 02:43:26 PM 421 Views
But look at what you're advocating for... - 06/05/2014 10:55:56 PM 432 Views
let's not go to extremes - 07/05/2014 12:33:38 AM 428 Views
please point out where constitution calls for a separation of church and state - 07/05/2014 06:44:42 PM 433 Views
"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion...." - 08/05/2014 12:37:06 AM 390 Views
so the answer no you can't - 08/05/2014 04:50:26 AM 405 Views
Again- it's not about being offended - 07/05/2014 04:02:29 AM 475 Views
America doesn't have seperation of church and state it has freedom of relgion - 07/05/2014 06:42:19 PM 427 Views
Not exactly. - 07/05/2014 07:01:23 PM 423 Views
The words are clear and the intent is well documented - 08/05/2014 05:13:42 AM 429 Views
Yeah, seems sensible. - 05/05/2014 10:08:39 PM 447 Views
Re: Yeah, seems sensible. - 06/05/2014 07:04:01 PM 429 Views
our Constitution expressly prohibits the establishment of religion by government, though - 06/05/2014 09:20:19 PM 419 Views
I couldn't disagree more... - 06/05/2014 10:50:19 PM 431 Views
bad analogy - 07/05/2014 12:19:26 AM 432 Views
But the GOVERNMENT is participating/supporting - 07/05/2014 04:17:32 AM 418 Views
Yeah, I'm aware. - 07/05/2014 07:03:36 AM 429 Views
That's not unreasonable - 06/05/2014 08:01:48 AM 487 Views
There's plenty that I don't want.... - 06/05/2014 10:57:41 PM 468 Views
In Keeping With Tradition Is Terrible Justification - 08/05/2014 03:37:34 AM 451 Views

Reply to Message