Just to be clear, I was only arguing against the Reaper motivation being an illogical plot hole. Of course their "solution" is evil from the moral standpoint of an organic, but it does make a certain kind of sense. You can argue that they should have contacted the organics, or only wiped out the synthetics, etc, but the reapers never said there weren't other solutions, only that theirs was the best.

As for the rest, I more or less agree with you. I'd have liked to see more variety in the ending, didn't feel like I was given a lot of meaningful choice, etc. I'm with you there, I just didn't feel like the Reapers' motivations were nonsensical and absurd like a lot of people did. There were problems with the ending, yes, but "it doesn't make sense for the reapers to wipe out all organic life for the reasons they stated" wasn't one of them. To me, anyway.