Active Users:312 Time:04/05/2024 02:55:59 AM
Some of those comparisons are quite useful to make. Others not so much. Legolas Send a noteboard - 18/05/2017 06:42:40 PM

To take one obvious case, it's quite relevant for Americans to know that the 'land of the free' ranks second in the world (behind, bizarrely, the Seychelles) when it comes to the percentage of its population locked up in prison at any given time. Especially when you look at how vast the differences are; to take three other major countries, the US has 1.5 times Russia's rate, but 5 times that of the UK and more than 8 times as many people in prison, per capita, as Germany.

There may be good reasons to be an outlier in international comparisons - whether it's conscious choices to do things differently, or just unintended but logical consequences of cultural or physical differences. But if you don't make the comparisons, you can't know if there are logical reasons for them, or if in fact they suggest that there may be more efficient ways to organize a certain aspect of society, without violating the national principles and preferences. Which I would say is most certainly the case with the American incarceration rate.

That said, I haven't seen the show you mentioned and it's entirely possible the guy was just being a jackass.

Reply to message
Why do TV politicians yammer about how "our country is XXth in the world" in domestic criteria? - 18/05/2017 04:27:32 AM 432 Views
Argument by sound bite - 18/05/2017 05:19:10 AM 191 Views
Seriously, why do we have more homeless people? Can't we turn them into soap? - 18/05/2017 06:17:34 AM 152 Views
Obviously not - 18/05/2017 02:42:28 PM 128 Views
Touché *NM* - 18/05/2017 08:43:15 PM 55 Views
I realize that one could wash hobo corpses - 18/05/2017 10:07:15 PM 121 Views
When I read that, I laughed like Sideshow Bob for at least a minute *NM* - 19/05/2017 01:57:52 PM 88 Views
Something from an episode of Monk - 19/05/2017 02:32:10 PM 114 Views
Some of those comparisons are quite useful to make. Others not so much. - 18/05/2017 06:42:40 PM 122 Views
Still reaching for "XXXth in the world" - 18/05/2017 06:58:33 PM 129 Views
The world can't get enough XXX - 20/05/2017 03:00:04 PM 107 Views
Certainly *NM* - 20/05/2017 09:03:20 PM 58 Views

Reply to Message