Active Users:413 Time:17/06/2025 02:24:56 AM
No offense intended, but have *you* read it carefully? Tom Send a noteboard - 16/06/2017 01:41:19 AM

You keep mentioning the Freikorps as though they're some evil force that eroded the Weimar Republic. In reality, virtually no one on any side of the political spectrum had respect for the Republic, but the Freikorps nearly always ended up defending the Republic.

There was a spike in regionalism in some of the German states, particularly Bavaria, who toyed with independence as a means of dissociating themselves from Prussian militarism, war guilt and the reparations that were tied to it. However, far stronger than that were the armed groups of the Left, which sought to replicate the Soviet experiment by seizing power through armed force.

Don't forget that the very same day the Weimar Republic was announced, Karl Liebknecht proclaimed the founding of a Soviet state. This led to the January 1919 uprising, which was only crushed because groups of Freikorps formed to defend the Weimar Republic against the communists. It was only because of them that the Spartacist uprising was crushed. Liebknecht got what he deserved - he initiated the violence and paid for that with his life. Sic semper communistis...

However, in Bavaria the communists seized power and lasted for almost a month of socialist terror before being put down by the Freikorps, who restored the democratically elected forces.

The term is used very loosely, sort of like we would use the term "militia" - it doesn't by necessity mean someone of any particular political persuasion. Indeed, the record of the various Freikorps units skews wildly all over the spectrum, with some groups scrupulously defending order and others pushing extreme agendas. Some were anti-Semitic while others welcomed Jews. Historian Thomas Weber did a good analysis of just what happened in Munich during the revolution, who supported whom, how Hitler tried to coordinate with the Kapp Putsch only to realize it had ended by the time he got to the area around Berlin and what the general political currents were in his book Becoming Hitler (note: I read this book in German because I found it on amazon.de and wasn't aware it had been translated until I got the book and saw the translator's name, though I'm glad I read it in German because there are copious citations from letters that were restored to their original German).

If I had to point to the downfall of Weimar, it was that no one really liked it or wanted to save it. Everyone was seeking to resolve disputes in radical, violent ways and everyone was looking for a strong leader to push whatever agenda they had. The economic hardships, combined with the polarization of political views that inevitably resulted due to the internal pressures on society from those economic hardships, made half-measures seem weak rather that conciliatory. For the US to get to that point we would have to have another major economic meltdown. Also, note that it was the Left that first resorted to violence all across Germany. The right began to fight as a self-defense strategy.

Political correctness is the pettiest form of casuistry.

ἡ δὲ κἀκ τριῶν τρυπημάτων ἐργαζομένη ἐνεκάλει τῇ φύσει, δυσφορουμένη, ὅτι δὴ μὴ καὶ τοὺς τιτθοὺς αὐτῇ εὐρύτερον ἢ νῦν εἰσι τρυπώη, ὅπως καὶ ἄλλην ἐνταῦθα μίξιν ἐπιτεχνᾶσθαι δυνατὴ εἴη. – Procopius

Ummaka qinnassa nīk!

*MySmiley*
Amazon link
This message last edited by Tom on 16/06/2017 at 01:41:38 AM
Reply to message
The Left Won’t Rest Until Someone Gets Killed - 14/06/2017 02:47:58 PM 1999 Views
Totally agreed with this article... - 14/06/2017 03:58:40 PM 1295 Views
The funny thing about violence is you can't control it. - 14/06/2017 04:31:35 PM 1241 Views
So you thought that would scare me Tom? - 14/06/2017 09:30:34 PM 1202 Views
especially since the gunman has been identified - 14/06/2017 05:42:14 PM 1271 Views
And the penny drops... *NM* - 14/06/2017 05:59:30 PM 679 Views
Bernie isn't a Democrat, though - 14/06/2017 06:31:28 PM 1243 Views
How embarrassing that he accidentally ran for their presidential nomination! - 14/06/2017 07:18:57 PM 1162 Views
Not an accident - 14/06/2017 07:28:12 PM 1147 Views
And in Wonder Woman the Movie they wore different hats!!! - 14/06/2017 09:09:57 PM 1140 Views
You mean the Clinton cabal stopped him - 15/06/2017 04:22:41 AM 1130 Views
I think you give too much credit to the Clintons - 15/06/2017 04:49:26 AM 1222 Views
I would have actually respected her more... - 15/06/2017 07:07:08 PM 1097 Views
well no other democrats wanted to run against her there was an opening *NM* - 15/06/2017 09:41:50 PM 679 Views
There are valid points, but rather a lot of bullshit inbetween for my taste. - 14/06/2017 07:07:10 PM 1378 Views
Obviously excessive hyperbole is a problem from both sides - 14/06/2017 07:20:59 PM 1189 Views
Sure, I will admit that. - 14/06/2017 07:23:24 PM 1158 Views
There you go again. - 14/06/2017 07:52:47 PM 1219 Views
Yeah, that part sucked.... - 14/06/2017 09:14:10 PM 1097 Views
You know what I did? - 15/06/2017 04:16:08 AM 1209 Views
Good Idea.... - 15/06/2017 06:59:47 PM 1126 Views
Yup. Isn't it shocking? - 14/06/2017 09:18:45 PM 1191 Views
I find myself drifting more and more to the right - 14/06/2017 08:26:26 PM 1140 Views
I don't, or at least not in an American context, but I agree about the dead horse. - 14/06/2017 09:32:23 PM 1241 Views
That's not correct. - 15/06/2017 04:19:06 AM 1228 Views
I agree with Tom's premise, if not the content. - 15/06/2017 09:46:57 AM 1198 Views
I really should post more. We're letting Tom and Cannoli get away with far too much. *NM* - 15/06/2017 10:12:53 AM 607 Views
YES, YOU SHOULD - 15/06/2017 11:09:34 AM 1141 Views
Agreed. *NM* - 15/06/2017 02:45:40 PM 1055 Views
It would still be a pretty right-wing site - 15/06/2017 02:58:30 PM 1230 Views
funny you would say that - 15/06/2017 03:20:58 PM 1207 Views
I so miss Camilla. - 15/06/2017 08:50:36 PM 1113 Views
Camilla and the Aussies were our lefty leaders - 15/06/2017 09:04:12 PM 1242 Views
God I miss Wads - 15/06/2017 10:29:38 PM 1242 Views
D'oh! *NM* - 15/06/2017 03:20:58 PM 642 Views
*NM* - 15/06/2017 04:37:56 PM 697 Views
I never could tell when you were being sarcastic and when not. On the whole I'm thinking yes. *NM* - 15/06/2017 08:48:54 PM 571 Views
Hmm... I miss Camilla too. - 15/06/2017 08:55:04 PM 1010 Views
Sad but true - the left is truly unhinged, full of violence and hate - 15/06/2017 03:36:20 AM 1128 Views
I was considering making a post called "what the fuck is wrong with progressives?" - 15/06/2017 06:49:10 AM 1259 Views
It's because they have begun to eat themselves. - 15/06/2017 02:14:23 PM 1164 Views
Yeah, but... - 15/06/2017 02:46:51 PM 1223 Views
yes, that - 15/06/2017 03:20:00 PM 1157 Views
The day I realized that I didn't know every damned thing was when I at last gained a little wisdom. - 15/06/2017 03:30:07 PM 1098 Views
I get where you're coming from, but... - 15/06/2017 05:01:13 PM 1152 Views
Isn't that a good characterization of much of the Left? - 15/06/2017 04:09:10 PM 1105 Views
Maybe? A large section of the academic left, anyway - 15/06/2017 05:17:14 PM 1067 Views
Well, yeah - 15/06/2017 04:36:37 PM 1161 Views
The Wheel of Time turns, and Ages come and pass... - 15/06/2017 10:40:42 PM 1236 Views
I can promise you they haven't read their history. - 16/06/2017 12:25:56 AM 1020 Views
No offense intended, but have *you* read it carefully? - 16/06/2017 01:41:19 AM 1335 Views
I've read it somewhat carefully. I think I said my point poorly, though. - 16/06/2017 03:23:26 AM 1145 Views
An obsession with the rule of law in Weimar Germany? - 16/06/2017 04:26:30 AM 1095 Views
She blocked me after telling me to go fuck myself. - 16/06/2017 04:38:43 AM 1049 Views
Sounds like a winner, that one - 16/06/2017 02:20:19 PM 1182 Views
Poor Weimar. - 16/06/2017 12:32:09 PM 1115 Views
Ha! - 16/06/2017 03:00:38 PM 1089 Views
Their shenanigans actually hurt their cause. - 15/06/2017 03:32:09 PM 1152 Views
Also, they're just puerile. Pussy hats? Seriously? If you want to be taken seriously, dress properly - 16/06/2017 12:36:36 AM 1207 Views
A short webcomic for you ghavrel - 16/06/2017 01:54:00 AM 1166 Views
Most Americans laugh at "microaggressions" and phrases like "toxic masculinity" - 16/06/2017 04:31:40 AM 1021 Views
I unironically use some of those - 16/06/2017 04:42:21 AM 1253 Views
Quit gaslighting me, dude *NM* - 16/06/2017 02:18:17 PM 598 Views
Why do you hate the word gaslighting? - 16/06/2017 08:42:34 PM 1083 Views
It's used by progressives whenever someone disagrees with them. - 16/06/2017 11:24:03 PM 1231 Views
So let me come at this from a different angle - 17/06/2017 04:48:37 AM 1135 Views
You're overthinking this. - 17/06/2017 10:28:47 AM 1213 Views
What are you even talking about? - 17/06/2017 11:01:42 AM 1260 Views
POC - 16/06/2017 01:54:31 PM 1117 Views
I would assume "POC" meant "piece of crap" - 16/06/2017 02:17:07 PM 1098 Views
Point of Contact - 16/06/2017 03:09:26 PM 1313 Views
WTF? "Good needs"? That doesn't even make any sense! - 16/06/2017 05:55:45 PM 1190 Views
I have some good needs - 16/06/2017 06:07:35 PM 1086 Views
I'll just bet you do. *NM* - 16/06/2017 06:13:23 PM 601 Views
Neither does "handicapped", honestly - 16/06/2017 07:18:15 PM 1159 Views
It will stop, the robots will one day take over - 16/06/2017 08:41:03 PM 1183 Views
My opinion on this - 16/06/2017 08:39:40 PM 1352 Views
No - 17/06/2017 07:11:17 AM 1086 Views
Belas, a rhetorical question, where do monsters come from? *NM* - 17/06/2017 08:58:00 AM 605 Views
These come from institutions of higher "learning" *NM* - 17/06/2017 05:07:47 PM 647 Views
under the bed or in the bedroom closet. d'uh. *NM* - 17/06/2017 05:30:05 PM 605 Views
POP - 16/06/2017 09:07:28 PM 1208 Views
Thought you were going to make a People of Penes / Penii joke - 16/06/2017 09:43:31 PM 1153 Views
That is the way I started to feel about the conserative movement - 15/06/2017 09:41:07 PM 1129 Views
President Mike Pence - 15/06/2017 03:53:15 PM 1160 Views
LOL - 15/06/2017 03:56:37 PM 1128 Views
Too much Jacobin. Not enough Jacques. - 15/06/2017 09:58:27 PM 1201 Views
RAWR, bows down to the sexiness - 15/06/2017 10:45:41 PM 1098 Views

Reply to Message