Active Users:332 Time:28/04/2024 04:33:54 AM
Not bullshit. The rate decreases. It is still elevated relative to the general population. Ghavrel Send a noteboard - 27/07/2017 03:00:15 AM

The study you link cites a metaanalysis which found that "after sex reassignment, 80% of individuals with GID reported significant improvement in gender dysphoria . . . 78% reported significant improvement in psychological symptoms . . . 80% reported significant improvement in quality of life . . . and 72% reported significant improvement in sexual function" and concludes that "very low quality evidence suggests that sex reassignment that includes hormonal interventions in individuals with GID likely improves gender dysphoria, psychological functioning and comorbidities, sexual function and overall quality of life."

The data we have on the phenomenon is poor, and trans people suffer from comorbid mental illness at a vastly elevated rate relative to the general population, but the data we have does suggest that transition improves mental health and reduces the risk of suicide.

The study you linked does not address that, because the control is the general population. In fact, the study you linked specifically warns against using it the way you did:

"For the purpose of evaluating the safety of sex reassignment in terms of morbidity and mortality, however, it is reasonable to compare sex reassigned persons with matched population controls. The caveat with this design is that transsexual persons before sex reassignment might differ from healthy controls (although this bias can be statistically corrected for by adjusting for baseline differences). It is therefore important to note that the current study is only informative with respect to transsexuals persons health after sex reassignment; no inferences can be drawn as to the effectiveness of sex reassignment as a treatment for transsexualism. In other words, the results should not be interpreted such as sex reassignment per se increases morbidity and mortality. Things might have been even worse without sex reassignment. As an analogy, similar studies have found increased somatic morbidity, suicide rate, and overall mortality for patients treated for bipolar disorder and schizophrenia. This is important information, but it does not follow that mood stabilizing treatment or antipsychotic treatment is the culprit."

"We feel safe when we read what we recognise, what does not challenge our way of thinking.... a steady acceptance of pre-arranged patterns leads to the inability to question what we are told."
~Camilla

Ghavrel is Ghavrel is Ghavrel

*MySmiley*

Reply to message
Thoughts on the internet outrage over Trump's transgenders in the military announcement - 26/07/2017 05:42:34 PM 818 Views
Maybe because.... - 26/07/2017 06:08:16 PM 374 Views
I get that - 26/07/2017 06:12:35 PM 381 Views
I don't think that your reasoning is flawed.... - 26/07/2017 06:31:06 PM 430 Views
bottom line - 26/07/2017 06:40:36 PM 386 Views
*shrug* - 26/07/2017 07:05:17 PM 351 Views
I dare say a lot of the rhetoric is seriously over the top... - 26/07/2017 06:13:59 PM 377 Views
like I replied to Jeo, I don't see this as a betrayal of the LGBT cause - 26/07/2017 06:19:01 PM 408 Views
LGB is not the same as T. We need to stop treating it all the same. - 26/07/2017 06:58:05 PM 375 Views
No the least of which... - 26/07/2017 07:06:21 PM 425 Views
Physical mutilation is a more appropriate word. - 26/07/2017 07:07:33 PM 372 Views
You're correct.... - 26/07/2017 09:28:20 PM 359 Views
Not always, keep that in mind. - 26/07/2017 07:35:34 PM 393 Views
I would still consider that.... - 26/07/2017 09:02:36 PM 401 Views
John McCain is the Left's favorite RINO - 26/07/2017 08:09:41 PM 422 Views
He's not a RINO. Just built his career on being independent-minded. - 26/07/2017 09:49:32 PM 426 Views
I really don't see the independence. Where is it? - 27/07/2017 01:33:27 AM 374 Views
So which is it, is he a RINO or a faithful Republican foot soldier? - 27/07/2017 08:08:04 PM 425 Views
RINOs are a pack. - 28/07/2017 12:46:44 AM 390 Views
Agreed with McCain - 27/07/2017 03:35:06 PM 388 Views
It makes eminent sense why trannies shouldn't be allowed. - 26/07/2017 06:57:00 PM 396 Views
I tried to keep my points to the logic of excluding an 18 yr old trans person - 26/07/2017 07:16:37 PM 436 Views
I don't have any desire to stop people from doing it - 26/07/2017 07:32:08 PM 372 Views
I agree - 26/07/2017 07:59:18 PM 440 Views
Absolutely agree on all counts *NM* - 27/07/2017 06:40:03 AM 219 Views
You don't need to be 'straight' to fight and die for your country. You just need to shoot straight. - 27/07/2017 10:14:11 PM 378 Views
You're an idiot. *NM* - 28/07/2017 12:47:21 AM 229 Views
You also need to pass some sort of physical standards - 28/07/2017 03:52:14 AM 401 Views
So I was reading.... - 26/07/2017 09:07:11 PM 394 Views
This is part of my point - 26/07/2017 09:47:39 PM 400 Views
The rate goes down significantly after transition. - 26/07/2017 11:24:50 PM 386 Views
Bullshit. - 27/07/2017 01:40:05 AM 490 Views
I also like that study because it uses correct terminology: transsexual, sex-reassigned. - 27/07/2017 01:42:19 AM 392 Views
Gender has had a non-grammatical meaning since the 1950s, and you know it. - 27/07/2017 03:05:09 AM 383 Views
And people misuse the subjunctive all the time. Your point? - 27/07/2017 04:57:19 AM 369 Views
Re: And people misuse the subjunctive all the time. Your point? - 27/07/2017 02:13:57 PM 376 Views
That's not necessarily a biological difference - 27/07/2017 05:03:30 PM 418 Views
or liposuction or laser fat removal too. *NM* - 27/07/2017 05:06:56 PM 237 Views
Facelifts, tummy tucks, collagen implants, nose jobs... *NM* - 27/07/2017 05:09:01 PM 221 Views
Not bullshit. The rate decreases. It is still elevated relative to the general population. - 27/07/2017 03:00:15 AM 390 Views
"transition is the cure" - 27/07/2017 04:50:11 AM 376 Views
which should then close the debate on the original question - 27/07/2017 05:07:34 AM 406 Views
Exactly. *NM* - 27/07/2017 01:26:48 PM 231 Views
Well, to the extent that it covers people with dysphoria, sure. - 27/07/2017 02:26:26 PM 360 Views
As I said above, Viagra treats a dysfunction - 27/07/2017 05:08:19 PM 397 Views
also, to a point you made earlier - 27/07/2017 05:39:32 PM 353 Views
So let me understand your position correctly via asking a few questions - 28/07/2017 04:01:50 AM 402 Views
Too long - 28/07/2017 01:54:11 PM 380 Views
The main reason for the post was the standard you created - 28/07/2017 05:00:27 PM 362 Views
Reductio ad absurdum, Roland? - 28/07/2017 05:29:23 PM 360 Views
I know Tom and Cannoli don't care, but on the off chance that you do... - 29/07/2017 12:39:16 AM 389 Views
I didn't realize that - 29/07/2017 01:10:30 AM 340 Views
Also trivia - 29/07/2017 01:22:37 AM 336 Views
No worries. I'm not offended. I just thought you might want to know. *NM* - 29/07/2017 02:32:01 AM 198 Views
Thanks - 29/07/2017 03:25:08 AM 342 Views
I don't? *NM* - 29/07/2017 08:23:14 AM 225 Views
Girlfriend Mookie, you are projecting onto me. - 29/07/2017 01:17:47 AM 405 Views
I absolutely respect you, Roland/Matt - 29/07/2017 01:40:28 AM 320 Views
We are cool - 29/07/2017 02:36:00 AM 378 Views
Blah blah blah and now I am showing off like an asshole - 29/07/2017 02:52:48 AM 350 Views
you're a nice guy, Roland00 - 29/07/2017 03:22:15 AM 353 Views
OMG mookie gave me the Nice Guy speech / Good Guy speech - 29/07/2017 07:41:23 PM 317 Views
I've never seen Newsroom - 29/07/2017 08:00:38 PM 352 Views
Teases I'll get you, my pretty, and your little dog too! - 29/07/2017 09:13:30 PM 350 Views
Nah, I'm not that subtle. - 29/07/2017 11:01:39 PM 317 Views
Edit: Double Posted due to bad wifi *NM* - 28/07/2017 04:01:51 AM 194 Views
Serving its end: As long as everyone argues over this, no one talks about Trumpcare nor Russiagate - 27/07/2017 10:05:00 PM 344 Views
Joel, seriously - 29/07/2017 08:33:14 PM 367 Views
No the real boogeymen are the ones we do not see with our eyes, but are still lurking in the shadows - 29/07/2017 09:16:34 PM 313 Views
And Rejoice - 29/07/2017 09:17:42 PM 356 Views
Everybody Is Missing The Mark Here - 29/07/2017 10:25:04 PM 430 Views
Nice comments. Thanks for that explanation. *NM* - 29/07/2017 11:15:29 PM 214 Views
Also, For the Record - 30/07/2017 08:02:58 AM 399 Views
Incite or Insight *NM* - 01/08/2017 06:30:28 AM 201 Views

Reply to Message