Active Users:1590 Time:20/08/2025 04:39:43 PM
At the least they could reverse the character assassination of Isildur Cannoli Send a noteboard - 09/03/2019 11:28:28 AM


Everything from the events leading up to the fall of Numenor to the end of the Second Age takes place in Elendil's / Isildur's lifetime (even if Elendil's lifetime lasted over three hundred years).

The Second Age is basically three thousand years with very little recorded history in any more detail than 'Numenoreans interact in various ways with the less advanced humans in Middle Earth while Celebrimbor makes the Rings', and then a whole lot in 1 or 2 centuries at the end. But then again, the Third Age is quite similar, though to a lesser extent as we know a bit more about the history of Gondor/Arnor.

I'm not too confident it will be great and I might've preferred that they just leave Tolkien alone, but if they were going to make a series anyway, I don't think it was a bad idea to pick those final centuries of the Second Age as a setting. Of course there's less going on than in the First Age, but that may not be a bad thing if you're trying to attract a wider audience and don't want to have to do too much exposition in the beginning. Plus, the Atlantis-like story of the downfall of Numenor is easy to make both gripping and relevant to a contemporary audience.


IIRC, Jackson cast the sleaziest looking guy he could find on short notice to play Isildur. Everyone runs around calling Aragorn Isildur's heir and a lot of people think it means he's the heir of crook or a slimeball, rather than arguably the greatest hero of an Age.

Cannoli
"Sometimes unhinged, sometimes unfair, always entertaining"
- The Crownless

“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Deus Vult!
Reply to message
Númenor! Amazon's LOTR Series To Be Set During The Second Age - 07/03/2019 05:56:47 PM 900 Views
The article about this on tor.com raises some good points... - 07/03/2019 07:52:43 PM 647 Views
All the Tolkien books are now 0.00 through Kindle Unlimited. - 07/03/2019 09:54:46 PM 517 Views
Sure they could. But I wish either they or the Tolkien Estate would announce it. *NM* - 07/03/2019 09:59:14 PM 207 Views
Welcome To The Second Age - 07/03/2019 10:39:35 PM 609 Views
As with things of this nature.... - 07/03/2019 10:06:08 PM 489 Views
Speaking of food - 07/03/2019 10:46:58 PM 483 Views
No, see....here's the deal. - 07/03/2019 11:02:54 PM 480 Views
does this mean... - 07/03/2019 11:13:59 PM 499 Views
I drink all alcohol. - 08/03/2019 12:27:44 AM 484 Views
Vegan?! - 08/03/2019 04:05:56 AM 466 Views
LOL - 08/03/2019 01:50:09 PM 474 Views
Awesome...this is exactly what I was hoping for - 08/03/2019 06:36:46 PM 437 Views
I was hoping for that as well. - 08/03/2019 08:24:36 PM 496 Views
Honestly... The Second Age is probably the most boring time to place it. - 08/03/2019 07:33:32 PM 480 Views
Canon Schamnon - 08/03/2019 08:29:09 PM 474 Views
It would be little more then a cosmetic skin though... - 09/03/2019 07:34:47 AM 494 Views
That isn't close to true, if you've read beyond LotR - 08/03/2019 08:38:12 PM 466 Views
Yet... It is though. - 09/03/2019 06:52:45 AM 501 Views
Most of it takes place in only one generation, though. - 09/03/2019 11:10:52 AM 488 Views
At the least they could reverse the character assassination of Isildur - 09/03/2019 11:28:28 AM 505 Views
This is the correct take. - 09/03/2019 03:03:53 AM 485 Views
Agreed, I'm excited as well! - 09/03/2019 02:17:07 PM 435 Views

Reply to Message