Active Users:315 Time:16/07/2025 05:35:42 PM
Umm isn't the reason for the wording obvious? fionwe1987 Send a noteboard - 28/10/2021 10:01:39 PM

I thought, once we got the 3 Black Oaths, the reason was obvious enough why the 'hour of my death" clause is present:

1) I shall obey all commands given by those placed above me in service to the Great Lord; 2) I shall prepare for the day of the Great Lord’s return; and 3) I shall hold close the secrets of the Black Ajah, unto the hour of my death.

1 and 3 contradict each other, if, say, a Darkfriend placed about you orders you to reveal all the Black Ajah's secret. If they swore to never reveal those, period, the two Oaths would contradict, and the Black sister would fall dead.

The "hour of my death" clause gives you the out. Since failing to follow the orders of this person would kill you, the "hour of my death" clause allows Oath 3 to be subordinate to Oath 1. That's why that clause exists.

And yes, the Oath could have been "I shall hold close the secrets of the Black Ajah, unless commanded otherwise by those placed above me in service to the Great Lord", but that leaves the BA beholden completely to anyone placed above them.

The existing Oath, however, has some wiggle room. The BA can negotiate a way out of babbling all secrets right away.

This message last edited by fionwe1987 on 28/10/2021 at 10:05:04 PM
Reply to message
A New WoT trailer dropped... - 27/10/2021 06:25:53 PM 697 Views
I liked it, especially the new stuff we got to see - 27/10/2021 07:52:58 PM 195 Views
Re: I liked it, especially the new stuff we got to see - 27/10/2021 11:05:31 PM 200 Views
This did nothing to quell my apprehensions. - 27/10/2021 08:21:59 PM 276 Views
On the five... - 27/10/2021 08:46:46 PM 192 Views
There's another brief trailer now where Moiraine literally says the Dragon might be a girl. - 04/11/2021 11:53:47 AM 175 Views
Xe is born again! - 04/11/2021 02:02:26 PM 253 Views
Well, it'll definitely include some New Spring stuff, clearly. - 27/10/2021 09:28:09 PM 191 Views
No doubt... - 27/10/2021 10:58:16 PM 205 Views
Re: No doubt... - 28/10/2021 12:33:41 AM 178 Views
Re: No doubt... - 28/10/2021 04:53:28 PM 199 Views
It's going to be the Woke of Time, you'll see *NM* - 28/10/2021 10:23:48 PM 91 Views
The video of Rafe Judkins commenting on the trailer is also worth watching. - 27/10/2021 09:19:11 PM 282 Views
Yeah he definitely seems very knowledgeable about the series - 27/10/2021 09:40:43 PM 203 Views
I liked him way back on Survivor. I guess it's good he didn't win - 28/10/2021 10:18:44 AM 177 Views
The truncated Third Oath is just sloppy whatever the justification. - 28/10/2021 06:56:54 PM 291 Views
Trailers truncate. That's nothing new. *NM* - 28/10/2021 07:15:24 PM 94 Views
Part of the whole oaths thing - 28/10/2021 07:38:38 PM 290 Views
Ugh - 28/10/2021 09:11:57 PM 207 Views
True! - 28/10/2021 09:16:14 PM 213 Views
He also created the original 3 Oaths - 28/10/2021 09:28:30 PM 264 Views
Well... - 28/10/2021 09:31:19 PM 249 Views
Umm isn't the reason for the wording obvious? - 28/10/2021 10:01:39 PM 195 Views
Though clever, this explanation isn't very satisfying. - 29/10/2021 12:00:17 AM 218 Views
I don't think so - 29/10/2021 01:26:46 AM 191 Views
Yeah, that was silly... - 28/10/2021 07:50:47 PM 181 Views
I'm most concerned by the Aes Sedai being burned at the stake by white cloaks. - 28/10/2021 11:47:51 PM 261 Views
Don't forget the one they managed to hang. - 29/10/2021 02:38:46 AM 251 Views

Reply to Message