Active Users:340 Time:17/05/2024 12:13:33 AM
Episode 8 was a disaster Narg Send a noteboard - 27/12/2021 05:24:33 PM


And yes, WoT Novices would not know this, I am aware. My point is, the show writers don’t understand the meaning of stuff from the books. They’re not remotely attempting to tell a variant of the same story, just strip-mining it for names and ideas to bolt patchwork fashion onto the hideous visage of their own fantasy creation.

This is exactly right. This isn't an adaptation of the books for TV. Rather, this is Rafe's big chance to show how creative he is by writing a totally different story with some of the same names and concepts. The problem is that he hasn't written a good story.

Nearly everything they chose to do in this episode sucked.

-The defense of Tarwin's Gap was ludicrous. Get your channelers on the wall and hold that narrow space at all costs. Make a series of ditches. Have a ton of men on top of the wall. I could go on and on about this.

-Rand's confrontation with Ishy fell totally flat.

-Perrin may as well have not been in this episode.

-Why is this the first time we have heard of the Horn of Valere? Apparently it is going to factor heavily into season 2 since it seems to be Fain's main goal at Fal Dara. However, nobody will care about the theft of the horn that you only now mentioned for the first time. Good thing we spent so much time with Logain and Stepin when we could easily have used a bit more of Tom to set up some important world building like the Horn of Valere. Also, the horn is just under Agelmar's throne... ugh.

-Why is Uno a blond midget? This is the worst casting decision of all.

-Why would Moraine not take Lan to the Eye? It is a supposedly dangerous journey through the blight and in her view everything hinges on getting there safely. Her warder should be indispensable here and his personal safety would be a tertiary consideration for her when she believes the fate of the worlds rests on Rand getting to the Eye and succeeding. Instead Lan needs to get Nynaeve's advice about how to track Moraine and Rand through the blight and then does nothing at all.

-The whole circle led by Amalissa with burnouts and Egwene sad-healing (resurrecting?) Nynaeve was such a weird choice. If Rafe is going to have someone steal Rand's thunder at Tarwin's gap, at least have the wonder girls take some initiative or something.

-Why would the Seanchen show up to an empty beach with no city/town and with a steep mountain range abutting the beach and make a weird tidal wave? It won't wash inland because of the mountains. It won't overrun any defenses because there aren't any. What is the point? Maybe they think that little girl must be killed at all costs? It is just stupid writing. And why give the Seanchen a barbarian vibe rather than the uber-civilized empire whose superior organization makes them an enormous threat to the entirety of Randland?



A little learning is a dangerous thing.
Reply to message
"Wheel of Time" Episode 8 - 24/12/2021 05:45:37 PM 825 Views
Re: "Wheel of Time" Episode 8 - 24/12/2021 08:32:47 PM 295 Views
It's mediocre at best - 25/12/2021 02:35:31 AM 453 Views
Little bit of good, some meh, but way too much WTF? - 26/12/2021 03:51:48 AM 258 Views
How dare an important character be, uh... Middle Eastern looking. *NM* - 25/12/2021 04:05:25 AM 147 Views
Not Middle Eastern, but a regular guy you meet on the street - 25/12/2021 12:43:21 PM 325 Views
I think you should re-watch that section. - 25/12/2021 11:03:26 PM 324 Views
Good point.....that makes a lot of sense. *NM* - 26/12/2021 03:52:43 AM 148 Views
But how did Rand do it? - 27/12/2021 01:50:48 AM 319 Views
Re: But how did Rand do it? - 27/12/2021 06:14:00 PM 405 Views
And that's another huge failing of the writing team..... - 27/12/2021 08:42:33 PM 300 Views
I love the show; it doesn't mean I think it's good. I love Doctor Who too. - 28/12/2021 05:04:55 AM 260 Views
Love. Really? - 28/12/2021 07:27:30 PM 258 Views
It's an adaptation of books I adored, on TV, with special effects. - 29/12/2021 10:23:22 PM 264 Views
Episode 8 was a disaster - 27/12/2021 05:24:33 PM 275 Views
Agreed - E8 was an epic disaster - 27/12/2021 08:49:42 PM 253 Views
Yeah, they covered ta'veren briefly in an early episode. I think Episode 1. *NM* - 28/12/2021 05:05:58 AM 153 Views
Didn't they just name drop it in the first 2 minutes then never really develop it again? *NM* - 28/12/2021 12:38:22 PM 152 Views
Yes, I think this was the case..... - 29/12/2021 03:33:57 AM 264 Views
Re: Episode 8 was a disaster - 30/12/2021 12:39:38 AM 295 Views

Reply to Message