Oh I don't know, I wouldn't be too surprised if we were able to figure something out, assuming that everyone told the truth about their settings, of course. And while I think you're right about the NIPZ generally keeping more visible players out of the spotlight, I am not particularly sure what you are trying to imply about the relevance of that fact to finding the horrible creature that attacked Napoleon. Am I missing something? Regardless of their participation in the conversation or the NK, we have a list of settings for everyone except F-T. And if he was indeed Rb'd, then he couldn't have attacked Napoleon anyway.




It does place him pretty squarely in the prob-town category. And it's not like there's anyone else who could contradict his lie if he is Mafia since it's contingent on the actions of the Mafia.



I don't think you're an obvious target. Just because Kronin turned out to not be evil doesn't mean that you are automatically innocent. As I seem to recall, the case against you was that you and Kronin appeared to be working together for evil ends? And then Kronin started sticking his foot in his mouth and we leaped all over him. So in retrospect you obviously weren't working with Kronin, but that doesn't necessarily make you prob-town. In my opinion, you have about the same chances as most other people as being Mafia. I think I will take some time to go back through Yesterday and review what went down.



I would disagree that ALL these things can be considered anti-Town. Yes, the line of questioning Yesterday culminated in the lynch of Townie. But Kronin genuinely messed-up, he said so himself. I don't think the fault there can be laid in the questions themselves - I think on the whole they have been helpful. Right now we are using them to try to find whomever attacked Napoleon. Besides, whatever forces the Scum to stick to one story is good in my opinion.

So while I do think Isaac's questions idea was pro-Town, I don't think that necessarily in and of itself would be motivation for the scum to NK him. After all, what's done is done, and killing him after the fact is not going to make the questions go away. Furthermore, he had already garnered some opposition Yesterday, so killing him would only remove a potential lynch target, as you've said yourself. And then there's always the WIFOM of who's going to be Doc'd and who's going to be NK'd, so to make a long story short I don't find it particularly surprising or suspicious that Isaac is still alive.







Thanks. I promise to use my powers for good and no evil.




Absolutely not, for reasons that have already been outlined.



No, I think if we get too many of those going it will be too confusing. Hypocopping is good enough.