These were all relative comments, essentially trying to come up with one for each person, and ? wasn't in the original.

Scott - This is not his first time playing mafia, so the newbie aspect doesn't apply as a strong safe.

? wasn't in the list, and I was really just trying to come up with one devil's advocate comment for everyone. ? wasn't in the list just because he wasn't as early as the others and I had really focused on the tiny time gap between the first and second answer. I didn't think the first answer would be from a scummer and I couldn't see that second answer being strongly connected to the first, a mere five minutes later... everybody after that just had too much time to consider it, but ? wasn't too much after it and he didn't seem to scummy to me after a few more comments.

As for specifically in regards to memory... I don't keep a strong track of Skype Chat comments the way I do the main series game, and the RP Mafia game, as FT can testify specifically on my behalf, was very confusing to me. There was no real way in that game to ascertain anyone's normal mafia skill level. All I can establish is that Scott had played before and that I was fairly confident he had remarked or had been remarked of to have played before, that could mean many games, I left it vague because I didn't know and figured he could fill in the blank if it was deemed important. The core point is that he hadn't played with us much, so it would be impossible to determine if he would assume Lie Detector was a common or uncommon role with us, like how Tracker and Roleblocker make it into virtually every game, essentially as common as doc or cop. The whole comment is centered around how we couldn't automatically assume the rapid response was that of an innocent newb townie, but that that was the most probable scenario.