Active Users:163 Time:19/05/2024 02:37:24 AM
I can see the argument, but in general, no. Cannoli Send a noteboard - 18/01/2014 08:37:43 PM

As far as the major events, I think you have to accept those books. I can see writing the trilogy off for the purposes of characterization and so forth, and I really do think the relative disinterest in WoT discussions and theories, following ToM, when Sanderson's narrative flaws really began shining through, in the homestretch of the series, a point when they should have been at their peak, can be attributed to his poor writing, and mishandling of the story. That said, however, the events have to be considered canon. Rand beat the Dark One the way aMoL says he did. The people who died, died and so forth. We might have been happier about some of the more troublesome events of that trilogy had we been able to read Jordan's description or character-rationalizations of their actions, but the things that happened, happened. Maybe we can write off the characterization as a world-wide Gas Leak, but we're stuck with B-Sand's contribution.

To the extent I agree with the idea, I might, for example, refrain from citing Egwene's more atrocious actions in the latter books as proof of her detestability, but that's about as far as I'd go. I certainly would not accept a counter-argument that if RJ had written the books, she'd have behaved a lot better.

Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
Reply to message
Should the last three books be officially removed from Canon? - 17/01/2014 08:31:08 AM 1540 Views
The first six books were fantastic - 17/01/2014 07:22:28 PM 902 Views
...this is dumb *NM* - 17/01/2014 08:55:32 PM 382 Views
+1 *NM* - 18/01/2014 03:56:32 PM 418 Views
+1 *NM* - 21/01/2014 07:50:30 PM 390 Views
+1 *NM* - 19/03/2014 04:17:18 AM 387 Views
The final post in the brief discussion there says it all. - 17/01/2014 09:59:17 PM 1050 Views
Why does anybody care? - 18/01/2014 05:05:32 AM 971 Views
Or to put it another way, I agree with beetnemesis. *NM* - 18/01/2014 05:06:14 AM 514 Views
Dumb - 18/01/2014 01:53:42 PM 727 Views
I can see the argument, but in general, no. - 18/01/2014 08:37:43 PM 868 Views
If anything, I think BS was more aware of Egwene's flaws - 20/01/2014 04:00:24 AM 852 Views
That's Cannoli's point. - 21/01/2014 07:55:07 PM 712 Views
This just makes me sad all over again. - 19/01/2014 01:55:08 AM 769 Views
I would remove the last few RJ books from Canon, before BS' trilogy..... - 20/01/2014 04:13:03 AM 900 Views
+1 *NM* - 21/01/2014 07:50:14 PM 400 Views
Heartily agreed. *NM* - 29/01/2014 09:50:41 PM 412 Views
No, whatever most of the people here say - they're good! *NM* - 28/01/2014 05:44:49 AM 455 Views

Reply to Message