Active Users:356 Time:29/04/2024 01:19:34 PM
I guess that's my issue with it darius_sedai Send a noteboard - 20/10/2016 09:53:38 PM

View original post
Yet this is never really played out in the books.

Sadly no, but then again none of our main PoV characters know much or have any desire to learn about the Reds. Yet they enjoy a measure of respect, the Yellow and Gray support the Red over the Blue in the Hall (in NS). Maybe they're better than we know.
View original postGreens, while obviously military in their organization, seem to be vastly more prepared to root out communities of Dark friends. Not that we really see them do much either, but the Greens we do encounter are much more likely to be out in the world engaging in fighting the forces of the Dark One which would imply that they are more likely to sniff out DFs than a group of Reds who are singularly hunting for male channelers, who are not by definition aligned with the DO.

I would assume the Greens place heavy emphasis on the Borderlands. They are interested in battles against Trollocs and preparing to counter Dreadlords, not going after sneaky, cowardly Darkfriends. The Red network of eyes-and-ears on the lookout for anything suspicious (uncommon luck, strange deaths, etc.) that could imply male channeling seems more suited to stumbling on the occasional DF plot, even if only by accident.




View original postI suppose my issue with this reason for Pevara choosing Red is that it feels irrelevant to me. It's like someone deciding to join Homeland Security instead of the Army because their family was killed by gang violence. There doesn't appear to be any real direct correlation in the choice of one over the other. What did the Red offer her that the Green could not in terms of stopping DFs?

Honestly, dunno. Could have been a coincidence? Perhaps she was taken in by some Red AS with a great reputation for sniffing out DFs.



It's not implausible, but it's also not obvious enough to understand why a woman like Pevara would make a life altering change such as choosing the Red over the Green. Give us a reason that is blatant

I actually don't have a really negative view of the Red, or at least no more so than any other Ajah. Sure we had a few antagonists early in the series coming from that direction, but given the situation of Rand being a male channeler who was quite clearly going insane it's easy to understand why so many Reds have a dim view of all men. The Ajah performs an absolutely critical function for the society, and it becomes very obvious why it would be difficult for Reds to allow themselves to truly like men or develop positive relationships with men when their primary function revolves around the necessity of essentially killing men. At some point one has to realize that through the eyes of a Red Sister all men have the potential to turn out to be rabid dogs in a very literal way. Cut to several thousand years of this and it becomes pretty clear that this pre-disposition becomes a primary personality trait in what the Ajah tends to seek out.

I think RJ used the Reds mentality to illustrate the negativity of non-gender balanced society and showed us many unsympathetic characters from the Red ... Elaida, Liandrin, Bonwhin, Tetsuan and at first tried to balance that out with Blues such as Moiraine, Siuan, Sheriam and Anayia who very clearly philosophically opposed the Reds and later introduced the more emotional Greens such as Alanna and Myrelle, but once the story really moved beyond these basics archetypes he began showing us more variety in personality even within an Ajah so we suddenly had Pevara, Silviana and on the flip side we had Merise who was sever and almost asexual along with Cadsuane who was described as typical of Greens, but didn't at all fit into the early vision RJ put out of nearly universally beautiful and mysterious pseudo-warrior-women.

I think the only reason he introduced the idea of Pevara flipping her choice was to be able to give her a reason for secretly learning the Warder bond weave.

Domani Drag Queen in the White Tower ... Aran'gar watch out!
This message last edited by darius_sedai on 21/10/2016 at 03:26:44 AM
Reply to message
Noticed something odd - 13/10/2016 09:31:54 PM 1066 Views
Familiarity breeds contempt? - 14/10/2016 12:41:44 AM 936 Views
I can see how this would keep a woman from attaining the Shawl - 14/10/2016 03:00:32 PM 556 Views
Re: Familiarity breeds contempt? - 17/10/2016 06:35:20 PM 698 Views
Ironically, that was a rather ill-informed comment - 18/10/2016 11:25:44 AM 634 Views
Re: Ironically, that was a rather ill-informed comment - 18/10/2016 03:54:23 PM 577 Views
Re: Ironically, that was a rather ill-informed comment - 18/10/2016 04:02:54 PM 552 Views
Re: Ironically, that was a rather ill-informed comment - 18/10/2016 05:03:58 PM 500 Views
Re: Ironically, that was a rather ill-informed comment - 18/10/2016 07:18:13 PM 643 Views
I think politics keeps women away from the Blue - 18/10/2016 10:20:50 PM 532 Views
I think it's RJ's gender commentary - Blue are ambitious, which is not a stereotypical female trait - 19/10/2016 02:57:51 AM 725 Views
Re: I think it's RJ's gender commentary - 19/10/2016 01:01:14 PM 572 Views
Sorry, I am gonna ramble a bit - 19/10/2016 09:19:01 PM 695 Views
Re: Sorry, I am gonna ramble a bit - 19/10/2016 09:48:17 PM 511 Views
Re: Sorry, I am gonna ramble a bit - 20/10/2016 06:13:27 PM 609 Views
Re: Sorry, I am gonna ramble a bit - 20/10/2016 07:14:51 PM 479 Views
I guess that's my issue with it - 20/10/2016 09:53:38 PM 622 Views
Grays=political power... How exactly? - 21/10/2016 08:38:07 AM 554 Views
Re: Grays=political power... How exactly? - 21/10/2016 09:21:13 AM 654 Views
Comparative to joining the Red is how I meant that - 21/10/2016 03:22:46 PM 573 Views
Forget the "locals"... IIRC Aes Sedai have kids "rarely" not "never". - 14/10/2016 06:40:56 AM 552 Views
Another good point! - 14/10/2016 03:28:44 PM 540 Views
Re: Noticed something odd - 11/11/2016 12:54:24 AM 670 Views
Possibly, - 11/11/2016 08:45:15 PM 747 Views

Reply to Message