Active Users:1433 Time:02/05/2026 03:35:09 AM
Re: There has to be something more, though. Macharius Send a noteboard - 20/12/2011 12:21:39 PM
I think the complaints about the misogyny in Martin's books are somewhat shakier, however. First off, he has a significant number of major female characters with agency, several of whom do not use their sexuality to get what they want (Arya, most notably) whilst others do (Cersei, Daenerys) and others reject that notion (Brienne). Secondly, ASoIaF is much more closely based on - or at least inspired by - real historical events (the Red Wedding is a re-enactment of the Black Dinner, when King James II of Scotland personally killed Earl Douglas at a dinner held under a flag of safe conduct, and Douglas was stabbed through the throat and thrown out of a window like Robb, though his head was not removed that we know of) and the level of 'misogyny' reflects that. On a related note, Mary Gentle, in her research for ASH: A SECRET HISTORY, discovered evidence that child prostitution amongst camp followers during medieval warfare was commonplace, and depicts her heroine starting life in such a role, something that goes way beyond anything seen in Martin (or Bakker, for that matter).

In fact, ASoIaF rather lowballs the levels of violence and rape that take place during major conflicts. The accounts of the devastation of Silesia and much of Eastern Germany during the Red Army's march on Berlin in 1945 are truly disturbing, and the notion that medieval warfare did not feature such things when there was far less reporting going on seems unrealistic.


All of which raises the point for me that, if I want to read about atrocities, the real world has far too many examples for me to want to have them featured and indeed highlighted in my recreational reading. That many of the events in ASoIaF have at least some historical background is no excuse for making a spectacle of the worst parts in the name of "authenticity".
Reply to message
Violence, rape, and agency in the "gritty fantasies" - 17/12/2011 01:36:54 PM 2047 Views
Hm, ok. - 17/12/2011 10:51:21 PM 1473 Views
I think we largely agree - 17/12/2011 11:23:00 PM 1326 Views
Re: Hm, ok. - 26/12/2011 01:08:14 AM 1334 Views
Martin, Goodkind... - 18/12/2011 01:58:33 PM 1320 Views
More than just those - 18/12/2011 08:15:27 PM 1229 Views
Re: More than just those - 26/12/2011 01:13:21 AM 1176 Views
Re: Martin, Goodkind... - 26/12/2011 01:11:12 AM 1139 Views
On more of a "meta" level, what makes a fantasy story "gritty" in the first place? - 19/12/2011 02:58:57 PM 1182 Views
There has to be something more, though. - 19/12/2011 03:47:56 PM 1351 Views
Re: There has to be something more, though. - 19/12/2011 05:29:30 PM 1228 Views
Re: There has to be something more, though. - 19/12/2011 09:06:14 PM 1207 Views
I agree about Martin - haven't read enough Bakker to judge. - 19/12/2011 09:56:17 PM 1275 Views
My problem with aSoIaF... - 20/12/2011 05:16:42 AM 1314 Views
The Rhoynish influence pretty much ends in Dorne. - 20/12/2011 06:15:54 AM 1248 Views
And that makes sense? - 20/12/2011 08:54:16 AM 1411 Views
Yes and no. - 20/12/2011 03:10:54 PM 1404 Views
Re: Yes and no. - 26/12/2011 03:12:01 AM 1186 Views
Re: And that makes sense? - 18/05/2012 01:42:52 AM 1287 Views
Re: There has to be something more, though. - 20/12/2011 12:21:39 PM 1145 Views
That's a question for each reader to answer then. - 20/12/2011 03:20:39 PM 1046 Views
You appear to have not understood my point. - 20/12/2011 05:59:07 PM 1079 Views
Re: There has to be something more, though. - 26/12/2011 03:14:04 AM 1170 Views
Re: There has to be something more, though. - 26/12/2011 03:01:34 AM 1133 Views
That's my general take as well - 20/12/2011 07:15:51 AM 1123 Views
I like violence *NM* - 20/12/2011 07:51:39 PM 566 Views
Re: Violence, rape, and agency in the "gritty fantasies" - 25/12/2011 11:52:41 PM 1334 Views

Reply to Message