Active Users:413 Time:08/09/2025 06:30:08 AM
Re: just a comment about your rich=bad DomA Send a noteboard - 08/04/2010 05:58:13 PM
It's important to note, that the "rich" in Harry Potter are not only rich. They are people along the lines of what passes for wizard nobility, or at least of that heritage. The Malfoys are an excellent case.


I agree a lot of this is inspired by British culture (history, but also literature like Dickens) and by her Scotish sensibilities too probably, though she had several important characters who had the blood lineage and who were painted very positively - but most of them were either poor or nothing was made of their wealth (eg: Neville, the Weasleys etc.). Only Sirius and Harry were technically very rich, and sometimes Rowling was tempted to show this as a challenge/danger (and source of guilt) to Harry. He had to learn to use his wealth the right way, not to show off or embarass his poorer friends with over the top generosity etc.

Her harshest critic of the wealthy was of course the Malfoys. They treat their "staff" terribly, show off their wealth all the time, use it as a source of power for bribes etc. and they sneer at the poor, even the pure blood ones like the Weasleys who were to them a disgrace to the pure blood.

Let's say her own background (and even her poverty at the time) showed a bit in the way she depicted the mediocre middle-class wannabe bourgeois like the Dursleys and the insanely rich like the Malfoys, offering the poor, struggling Weasleys as her central positive family.

I'm not against it mind you, I found her satirical elements very amusing, but it was a bit black and white... maybe.

Reply to message
Harry Potter (the entire series) - 06/04/2010 11:00:07 PM 1895 Views
Re: Harry Potter (the entire series) - 06/04/2010 11:29:49 PM 1175 Views
Really? - 07/04/2010 05:41:46 PM 1227 Views
I honestly think it's a combination of the two - 07/04/2010 05:55:18 PM 1104 Views
I'll give you that.... - 07/04/2010 06:11:27 PM 1136 Views
Yeah, I believe she's explicitly said she did that on purpose - 10/04/2010 08:24:47 PM 1045 Views
Um...you forgot a book. - 06/04/2010 11:37:27 PM 1166 Views
My bad...much thanks for reminding me. - 07/04/2010 05:43:53 PM 1115 Views
Re: Harry Potter (the entire series) - 07/04/2010 12:26:22 AM 1445 Views
I get where you're coming from - 07/04/2010 06:19:13 PM 1236 Views
That's kind of the point though... - 07/04/2010 08:44:26 PM 1164 Views
This is how I see it too - 08/04/2010 12:43:03 AM 1287 Views
just a comment about your rich=bad - 08/04/2010 02:05:32 AM 1247 Views
Re: just a comment about your rich=bad - 08/04/2010 05:58:13 PM 1242 Views
it was a bit black and white... - 08/04/2010 08:48:05 PM 1057 Views
I agree with many of your points. - 07/04/2010 12:44:31 AM 1345 Views
I have to dispute the concept of going "too far." - 07/04/2010 06:32:47 AM 1108 Views
Hm, I don't know. - 07/04/2010 11:08:12 AM 1164 Views
This is a lot like the argument I'm having with Joel on the CMB concerning original sin. - 08/04/2010 07:21:39 AM 1079 Views
Where is this debate? I'd like to read it. - 08/04/2010 05:18:38 PM 1748 Views
I agree entirely about Snape *NM* - 07/04/2010 11:50:00 AM 536 Views
More conversation on Snape. - 07/04/2010 06:01:37 PM 1392 Views
Brief comments on Magic, Dumbledore, and The Epilogue. - 07/04/2010 07:13:55 AM 1446 Views
Re: Brief comments on Magic, Dumbledore, and The Epilogue. - 07/04/2010 06:09:20 PM 1282 Views
The movies are even worse about this. - 07/04/2010 06:15:35 PM 1166 Views
Hmmm.... - 07/04/2010 06:21:40 PM 1140 Views
Oh, that's definitely why they did it - 09/04/2010 06:44:50 AM 1474 Views
how many high school relationships... - 08/04/2010 02:13:48 AM 1131 Views
Re: Brief comments on Magic, Dumbledore, and The Epilogue. - 08/04/2010 03:25:38 PM 1250 Views
Harry Potter and Star Wars have two radically different approaches to this - 07/04/2010 06:13:25 PM 1360 Views
When my son asked for his own set of Harry Potter books, - 07/04/2010 10:26:37 PM 1192 Views
This is assuming of course... - 07/04/2010 11:00:15 PM 1239 Views
yes, that's where parenting gets "complicated" - 08/04/2010 02:16:06 AM 1146 Views
You are taking this a bit extreme I feel. - 08/04/2010 08:51:34 AM 1088 Views
I agree. *NM* - 08/04/2010 06:11:06 PM 489 Views
Re: This is assuming of course... - 08/04/2010 03:30:33 PM 1297 Views
I am the same way with a few books. - 08/04/2010 08:05:04 PM 1129 Views
I was most irritated by the ironic names - 08/04/2010 05:38:59 AM 1253 Views
Re: I was most irritated by the ironic names - 08/04/2010 10:07:40 PM 1678 Views
Sheriff Lobo wasn't a werewolf, either, and Bear wasn't a bear. - 09/04/2010 12:47:48 AM 1097 Views

Reply to Message