Active Users:650 Time:17/01/2026 10:34:40 AM
Re: I was hoping to hear what a union supporter recognizes as flaws of unions. moondog Send a noteboard - 14/12/2012 10:07:39 PM
He implied that he thinks unions have flaws, I was wondering what he thinks they are.


here are some from my own observations, in no particular order:

- incestual relationships with other union groups: unions can only hire other union workers when they need work done in a field where their workers do not have any specialty. e.g. - if you work for UAW and you need your building remodeled, only union carpenters and electricians, etc can be hired. this is meant to show solidarity with other union workers, but ends up costing extra in the short term. these things should be up for competitive bidding, imho. let the union workers compete with non-union and take the least expensive, best quality option. if the union is slightly more expensive but has considerably higher quality work, fine. if the work is equal, it should go to the most cost-effective bid

- protectionism: if your facility is a union shop, you CANNOT have ANY non-union people do work, even on a volunteer basis. i had the occasion to work on a convention in a union convention hall and some of the people in our crew had worked on a different convention a few weeks earlier in the same hall. they said the union tacked on several tens of thousands of dollars because people wanted to help clean up and started stacking chairs to help the regular crew. the union bosses charged extra for it because they wanted to punish people for helping out. sometimes, people just want to feel helpful, they should not be punished for their volunteerism.

- inflexibility: i think unions sometimes move too slowly to keep up with the business needs of the companies they work for. part of this is because their bargaining agreements last years and part of this is related to the protectionism i mentioned before. i don't think workers should keep giving up pay and benefits so that CEOs can give themselves bigger and bigger bonuses, but i also don't think unions should completely rule out the changing climate when they go into negotiations.
"The RIAA has shown a certain disregard for the creative people of the industry in their eagerness to protect the revenues of the record companies." -- Frank Zappa

"That's the trouble with political jokes in this country... they get elected!" -- Dave Lippman
Reply to message
Congrats to Michigan - The Newest Right to Work State! - 12/12/2012 04:59:29 AM 1561 Views
It's great that they were able to do it. - 12/12/2012 02:45:39 PM 865 Views
I just think it's so... odd... that people don't realize things constantly evolve. - 12/12/2012 05:18:11 PM 806 Views
Isn't this a symptom of evolution? - 12/12/2012 06:12:36 PM 846 Views
we also don't need unions to keep people on the job who are bad at it..... - 12/12/2012 06:20:22 PM 838 Views
Unions are all about protecting underperforming workers and the union leadership. - 12/12/2012 06:37:41 PM 788 Views
Dude, that's insane. - 12/12/2012 06:58:42 PM 840 Views
That's a bit naive. And instead of evolution, I should have said "ever-changing" - 12/12/2012 06:55:41 PM 731 Views
No, big companies aren't all of a sudden altruistic... - 12/12/2012 07:33:16 PM 798 Views
your three examples are of employers demanding workers do more for less - 12/12/2012 07:41:12 PM 882 Views
The good and the bad of unions: - 12/12/2012 10:33:46 PM 962 Views
Double post. - 12/12/2012 10:33:50 PM 1060 Views
Yes, and if there was not a union... - 13/12/2012 04:56:57 AM 812 Views
What are the downsides of Unions? *NM* - 12/12/2012 10:30:17 PM 476 Views
What are the upsides for anyone BUT unions? - 13/12/2012 11:58:23 PM 868 Views
the answer to the political influence is hard campaign contribution limits from individuals only - 14/12/2012 12:27:57 AM 762 Views
- 19/12/2012 01:33:13 AM 987 Views
I was hoping to hear what a union supporter recognizes as flaws of unions. - 14/12/2012 08:55:46 PM 889 Views
I'll tell you what my perceptions are.... - 14/12/2012 09:30:33 PM 933 Views
one point i need to address here: - 14/12/2012 10:09:24 PM 730 Views
Re: I was hoping to hear what a union supporter recognizes as flaws of unions. - 14/12/2012 10:07:39 PM 712 Views
Sorry, didn't realize this was addressed to me. Sure, ok: - 15/12/2012 05:14:57 AM 954 Views
it's great? - 12/12/2012 05:29:00 PM 810 Views
Pissed off people.... - 12/12/2012 06:16:49 PM 740 Views
again, what industry will those people looking for work go to in michigan? - 12/12/2012 06:23:47 PM 858 Views
This used to be the case, but no longer. - 12/12/2012 06:34:01 PM 710 Views
but that's my point exactly - 12/12/2012 06:40:20 PM 777 Views
Which industry are you refering to? *NM* - 12/12/2012 06:23:55 PM 402 Views
As a native Michigander, I can tell you it's great. - 12/12/2012 06:26:53 PM 743 Views
+1 - This is going to help bring jobs to MI and benefit the auto industry. - 12/12/2012 06:33:43 PM 769 Views
So let me get this straight. - 13/12/2012 03:54:14 PM 814 Views
Yes, it's a good thing, a very, very good thing! - 13/12/2012 05:45:43 PM 769 Views
no "right to work" in MO, MT, CO, NM, KY, WV, OH, MA, NY, DE, MN, WI, PA, OR, WA, HI, AK, MD - 13/12/2012 06:56:17 PM 801 Views
Just to play devil's advocate... - 13/12/2012 09:12:02 PM 772 Views
That would be an interesting study... - 13/12/2012 09:51:21 PM 761 Views
Re: Just to play devil's advocate... - 13/12/2012 09:57:07 PM 718 Views
I, for one, stipulate that you are correct. - 13/12/2012 10:06:34 PM 797 Views
Re: I, for one, stipulate that you are correct. - 13/12/2012 10:18:27 PM 790 Views
How is that wrong? - 13/12/2012 10:52:24 PM 737 Views
it's wrong because it ultimately drives down *all* workers' pay, not just the unions - 13/12/2012 11:26:00 PM 759 Views
Your argument is completely fallacious. - 14/12/2012 04:17:58 AM 763 Views
A brilliant argument... - 14/12/2012 07:23:53 AM 835 Views
the only reason unions are obsolete is because republicans don't want them supporting dems - 14/12/2012 06:43:56 PM 745 Views
Unions being obsolete has almost nothing to do with internal American politics - 14/12/2012 07:10:38 PM 687 Views
i would disagree, at least with respect to the spate of "right to work" laws being pushed through - 14/12/2012 07:32:26 PM 760 Views
Unions aren't going to help rein in CEO pay or corporate profits. - 14/12/2012 10:48:51 PM 741 Views
i'll take you one further.... - 14/12/2012 11:24:26 PM 709 Views
I have suggested that before - 15/12/2012 02:31:07 PM 739 Views
so you did. sorry about that! - 15/12/2012 03:59:16 PM 714 Views
So to work with your thoughts (regarding the Romans) - 14/12/2012 06:07:06 PM 739 Views
funny thing about that..... - 14/12/2012 07:25:50 PM 700 Views
And so what if they are all shit jobs with substandard pay! - 14/12/2012 07:08:41 AM 765 Views
What do you want me to say? - 14/12/2012 05:58:45 PM 859 Views
And so the destruction of the Middle Class continues. *NM* - 13/12/2012 03:43:36 PM 386 Views
Damn, I agree with Anonymous2000. - 14/12/2012 04:29:36 AM 801 Views
This must be a trying time for you. - 14/12/2012 07:06:56 AM 757 Views
Callandor sees the light, perhaps it's time for you as well! *NM* - 14/12/2012 02:08:47 PM 350 Views
HOW they are doing it..is bullshit - 13/12/2012 06:33:09 PM 918 Views
How? Residents of MI elected a Republican legislature and Governor..... - 13/12/2012 09:25:43 PM 748 Views

Reply to Message