I think I may have realized what my problem with BG2 is. It's the way the story is presented. I'm happy that the game does not hold my hand at all when it comes to the gameplay, but BG2 takes this same approach when it comes to the storyline, and seems to take it for granted that anyone playing it will have already played BG1 or is at the very least familiar with Dungeons and Dragons lore and mechanics. But I'm not, not even in the slightest. And being thrust into a world in medias res is something I enjoy in books and video games, but only if some explanations are later provided so I can puzzle pieces together. Here Harpers are casually mentioned, Bhaal, other gods, various factions, etc, and all without any explanation anywhere.

I'll have to check out Neverwinter Nights, and maybe a few of those other games too. I seem to not have too much trouble jumping from generation to generation of video games, considering I was playing Dragon Age: Origins again a little while ago before getting bored of it and deciding to give its spiritual predecessor a try.