Active Users:484 Time:01/07/2025 02:59:17 PM
Feels we are talking past each other. Roland00 Send a noteboard - 22/01/2018 07:52:53 PM

View original post
It was a variant of i that made its way into codices in the Middle Ages to make the "i" clearer and more distinct. The fact that it is pronounced in so many different ways shows that it wasn't created to represent a particular sound, ja?

Feels we are talking past each other. Literally this is what happened.
View original post
Introducing systems of recording ideas is a completely different and far more organic process than attempting to artificially dump a new character into an existing system that doesn't need it. I can't think of a single instance where the latter has succeeded.

The J sound is not new, but the J letter is what only 500 years old?

You are correct it started as a variant I symbol, but it became a popular enough symbol that we started using the J letter for multiple sounds that existed prior and were used to be done in different ways, we all swapped to this new way. This does not happen often but this does happen.



And while it happens in languages (rarely), it also happens in other systems as well where we use symbols to communicate ideas. For example mathematical notation, scientific notation, computer programming has their rules of syntax of both words and sentences change quite frequently. So while in writting / language the notation rarely changes, it happens far more often in other ways ways to use symbols to communicate ideas. For example the standard way to do algebra equations X+Y+Z=A+B+C and while there were predecessors it was Rene Descartes who popularized this notation with algebra / math in the last 370 years or so.

For the other sciences the "syntax" changes are even more recent and they are ever changing, for example with modern programming languages the syntax rules are such that you may "evolve" a language or create a new language altogether.

Reply to message
The Fascinating History of 10 Extra Letters the English Alphabet Used to Have - 18/01/2018 06:35:45 PM 1187 Views
I have to take issue with the & and the "long s" - 18/01/2018 07:28:09 PM 532 Views
Ok, let's define what a letter is. - 18/01/2018 11:25:22 PM 577 Views
Yes, the long "s" is just a variant. It didn't have a name in Old English. - 19/01/2018 03:39:51 PM 722 Views
I don't think not having a name in Old English matters here. - 19/01/2018 05:05:47 PM 828 Views
I think it does, quite definitively. - 20/01/2018 08:46:24 PM 563 Views
All th Germans I have known have considered ß to be a letter. - 20/01/2018 11:01:40 PM 606 Views
ß is a ligature - 21/01/2018 04:04:48 PM 530 Views
That article is even sloppier than the first - 20/01/2018 09:01:33 PM 520 Views
All letters were once "fake". - 20/01/2018 10:59:11 PM 604 Views
Isn't that kind of idealist - 21/01/2018 08:02:14 AM 570 Views
Realist perhaps - 22/01/2018 01:54:14 AM 526 Views
Pivots - 22/01/2018 03:43:56 AM 647 Views
Meanwhile - 22/01/2018 12:23:13 PM 482 Views
Olympics are grand aren't they? *NM* - 22/01/2018 05:23:56 PM 301 Views
Deutschland, Deutschland! - 22/01/2018 05:26:50 PM 437 Views
No, actually that's quite incorrect. - 21/01/2018 04:14:18 PM 532 Views
You've missed the point. - 22/01/2018 01:53:59 AM 565 Views
No, I'm trying to show the qualitative difference between the two events. - 22/01/2018 04:34:20 PM 465 Views
The letter J? *NM* - 22/01/2018 05:19:14 PM 353 Views
No, J is a lot like the long s. - 22/01/2018 07:23:01 PM 517 Views
Feels we are talking past each other. - 22/01/2018 07:52:53 PM 573 Views
You're wrong. - 23/01/2018 01:21:26 AM 614 Views
Agreed. Ligatures aren't letters. *NM* - 19/01/2018 06:13:43 AM 334 Views
Eh . . . the Ampersand is probably now considered a logogram rather than a ligature. - 19/01/2018 01:27:21 PM 521 Views
ſ is just a variant. *NM* - 19/01/2018 03:40:53 PM 378 Views
I enjoy this thread muchly...yet I will not participate besides saying - 19/01/2018 10:46:40 PM 506 Views
You're using sublime too often; it's losing its luster - 20/01/2018 12:15:10 AM 561 Views
Do I? (in regards to sublime) - 20/01/2018 12:46:35 AM 482 Views
(in regards to sublime) - 20/01/2018 03:18:04 PM 537 Views
Brilliant! *NM* - 20/01/2018 03:38:39 PM 302 Views
- 20/01/2018 11:20:11 PM 538 Views
*NM* - 23/01/2018 09:18:01 PM 310 Views
Is this payback for the irritating word, Umami? - 24/01/2018 07:25:56 AM 430 Views
Upapi? *NM* - 25/01/2018 08:41:14 PM 348 Views
Thank all gods everywhere they are gone. - 22/01/2018 12:23:34 PM 512 Views
Some other letters should go too. - 22/01/2018 01:12:31 PM 585 Views
How would you replace the ch sound? - 22/01/2018 04:15:04 PM 531 Views
I thought of removing C, as well. - 22/01/2018 06:16:20 PM 519 Views
The CH is a problem. - 22/01/2018 06:34:47 PM 430 Views
And calling people you don't like "fu king unts"? *NM* - 22/01/2018 07:25:29 PM 401 Views
Meanwhile if it were written as fuking kunts, no one would have any issues - 22/01/2018 07:54:41 PM 587 Views
I have an issue, kunts looks too much like nuts or knuts - 22/01/2018 08:09:52 PM 515 Views
Would you prefer a Knut? - 22/01/2018 10:55:09 PM 483 Views
Yes I like my internet memes and thus I do not want to be confused by that word sometimes directed - 23/01/2018 10:28:58 PM 455 Views
Yes, ask him - 24/01/2018 01:32:08 AM 486 Views
Totes I will ask him about Tot *NM* - 24/01/2018 09:49:45 PM 332 Views
Yes, about the meanings. Pronounced quite differently. - 25/01/2018 06:17:22 PM 593 Views
Scheisse. I did forget it. - 26/01/2018 05:24:21 PM 498 Views
You mean Scheiße? *NM* - 26/01/2018 06:49:26 PM 324 Views
No. I mean Scheisse. *NM* - 26/01/2018 07:15:21 PM 351 Views
*NM* - 26/01/2018 11:07:18 PM 401 Views
*NM* - 28/01/2018 02:15:03 AM 323 Views
all those k's.... - 22/01/2018 08:23:09 PM 472 Views
So . . . no Klondike bars or Kit Kats for you. - 22/01/2018 10:55:53 PM 566 Views
But it would look "fuking" stupid - 23/01/2018 01:30:15 AM 501 Views
All languages change - 23/01/2018 01:40:18 AM 473 Views
They change, but resistance is not futile. - 23/01/2018 02:10:17 AM 545 Views
Also, you're not talking about the language changing. You're talking about changing the language. - 23/01/2018 02:16:39 AM 555 Views
I am being a realist who understands that spellings change. Letters get dropped. Language evolves. - 23/01/2018 06:53:25 PM 590 Views
It is posts like this that remind me why you are my RAFO tree - 23/01/2018 10:29:53 PM 468 Views
Nope sadly he did not *NM* - 23/01/2018 10:30:09 PM 259 Views
What are you talking about here? - 24/01/2018 12:21:55 PM 516 Views
I am talking about Logograms - 24/01/2018 09:48:48 PM 498 Views
Evolution, not revolution - 23/01/2018 10:54:37 PM 619 Views

Reply to Message