Active Users:204 Time:18/05/2024 04:05:54 AM
If by "interesting" you mean shitty, then perhaps. Tom Send a noteboard - 29/07/2018 03:54:34 PM

First of all, I'm not sure why people even bother using Twitter if they want to make nuanced and lengthy arguments. It's a useless medium for that. He's not the first person I've seen to do this, but I certainly have very little patience for someone making arguments by chain Twitter.

Terrible choice of format aside, the guy is spinning Russian history to give it a pro-Ukrainian angle. I would take issue with most if not all of his characterizations, such as saying that the growth of Muscovy was due to "brutally conquering" other states. There were a few competing states that were conquered by force, but a great deal of the land Muscovy got was through inheritance following intermarriage, feudal pledges of fealty by small and weak states who needed protection and in some cases, purchase.

Also, I strongly take issue with his use of "Kyiv" as the name of the capital of Ukraine. It was Kiev in all the old chronicles - Kyiv is a modern name. It would be similar (not a perfect analogy, but useful nonetheless) to calling Constantinople "Istanbul" when talking about it c. 1000 AD.

He's also done a really shoddy job of explaining Russian learning. This is the same old tired theory about "not having access to learning" that I've heard from older sources. The problem is that it really ignores the reality of the situation. First of all, Old Church Slavonic was not so different from Old East Slavic (the predecessor of Russian) that people needed specialized training to understand it. I recently read a somewhat dry 800-page book about the history of the language and the differences are really not that strong. OCS was slightly different, so the OES gorod (city) became OCS grad, OES golova (head) became OCS glava, OES bereg (riverbank) became OCS breg. A lot of words didn't have complex consonant clusters is OES, so OCS nadezhda (hope) became OES nadezha. The conjugation system was slightly simpler in OES, but the OCS forms were recognized.

[EDIT: Let me add that I learned OCS in a couple of days based on my knowledge of Russian. I'm not sure if that was clear. Some of it can be read by any Russian speaker, but even the parts that need to be explained can be quickly and easily explained and isn't something that would take any significant expenditure of effort to learn]

Not only that, but all the monasteries were translating works from Greek into OCS/OES (creating a hybrid language that would become Russian). They had access to Greek philosophy and non-liturgical works. Not only that, but educated people in the court and monasteries in Muscovy learned Latin. The myth that Russia didn't have access to Western learning is just that.

The real difference is that Russian xenophobia made them suspicious of much of this learning. It took Peter the Great and other leaders (like Catherine the Great) who dragged Russia kicking and screaming into modernity.

Certainly, the choice of Orthodoxy meant that the church wasn't run from Rome, which later in Russian history meant the Church was subservient to the State (though in Muscovy the opposite was really true - the Church was if anything dictating terms to the tsars earlier on, and the Church perpetuated the rule by Mongols and Tatars because it benefited from the Mongols' disinterest in spiritual matters both economically and politically). However, this choice is again a reflection of a light xenophobia. Even had Russia accepted Catholicism, arguendo, it would have broken away early on because there was a high level of suspicion of outsiders.

That, by the way, is something that is common in "border areas" that are the object of constant invasions and attacks. I would argue that the geography shaped the culture, which shaped the choice of religion.

Political correctness is the pettiest form of casuistry.

ἡ δὲ κἀκ τριῶν τρυπημάτων ἐργαζομένη ἐνεκάλει τῇ φύσει, δυσφορουμένη, ὅτι δὴ μὴ καὶ τοὺς τιτθοὺς αὐτῇ εὐρύτερον ἢ νῦν εἰσι τρυπώη, ὅπως καὶ ἄλλην ἐνταῦθα μίξιν ἐπιτεχνᾶσθαι δυνατὴ εἴη. – Procopius

Ummaka qinnassa nīk!

*MySmiley*
This message last edited by Tom on 29/07/2018 at 03:56:56 PM
Reply to message
trump is not the first US president to hand the white house to the russian government - 17/07/2018 07:22:36 PM 1097 Views
What about Ted Kennedy's alleged 1984 request to Andropov to help him win the Presidency? - 17/07/2018 07:59:12 PM 533 Views
This isn't based on the Steele dossier - 17/07/2018 08:50:04 PM 514 Views
Hanlon's razor, really. - 17/07/2018 11:50:17 PM 557 Views
It wouldn't be the first time. - 17/07/2018 11:57:13 PM 453 Views
I just believe the stupidity came earlier - 18/07/2018 12:09:20 AM 483 Views
Apparently you also believe Putin is equally stupid. - 18/07/2018 12:15:29 AM 453 Views
Why? - 18/07/2018 03:35:33 AM 452 Views
Obviously - 18/07/2018 03:49:34 AM 531 Views
Oh please - 18/07/2018 05:39:01 AM 481 Views
Mookie - 18/07/2018 04:13:03 PM 493 Views
Well said. - 18/07/2018 06:03:17 PM 465 Views
Notice how everyone claims to understand what Russia wants? - 22/07/2018 05:55:44 AM 486 Views
What does Russia actually want? - 22/07/2018 04:15:07 PM 527 Views
To be treated and respected as a significant power - 23/07/2018 04:20:26 PM 533 Views
Thanks, that was a very interesting read. - 23/07/2018 10:39:07 PM 456 Views
New questions..... - 24/07/2018 01:19:04 AM 456 Views
So many ways to answer this - 24/07/2018 03:16:30 AM 533 Views
That was a good answer. *NM* - 24/07/2018 04:13:50 PM 281 Views
*Claps* well said. *NM* - 24/07/2018 03:33:41 AM 278 Views
Honest question - 26/07/2018 05:50:38 PM 568 Views
Very interesting essay Tom. *NM* - 31/07/2018 03:54:26 PM 812 Views
Here is another interesting Russian History Summary (I would also like some Tom Feedback.) - 29/07/2018 02:36:46 AM 549 Views
If by "interesting" you mean shitty, then perhaps. - 29/07/2018 03:54:34 PM 486 Views
I’ve always suspected... - 22/07/2018 06:45:28 PM 434 Views
Of course - 23/07/2018 04:22:32 PM 460 Views
Mental Shorthand - 24/07/2018 03:20:05 AM 461 Views
And how about Obama trying to defeat Netanyahu a few years ago? - 18/07/2018 03:31:00 AM 433 Views
Hey, that was also Soros *NM* - 18/07/2018 09:13:55 AM 268 Views
Not sure what the point of the homophobic imagery is... - 17/07/2018 08:38:42 PM 476 Views
I don't read much news.... - 17/07/2018 10:55:31 PM 457 Views
Re: I don't read much news.... - 17/07/2018 11:17:01 PM 455 Views
Re: I don't read much news.... - 18/07/2018 12:19:54 AM 507 Views
It appears you don't read much news either, Cannoli... - 18/07/2018 06:23:12 AM 404 Views
I agree with everything you have said, barring one thing: - 20/07/2018 12:14:14 PM 472 Views
Hmm - 21/07/2018 03:25:03 AM 441 Views
Re: Hmm - 21/07/2018 03:46:12 AM 469 Views
Re: Hmm - 26/07/2018 05:58:19 PM 431 Views
We see the world differently.... - 18/07/2018 11:08:27 PM 429 Views
Moondog be better than the NYT Opinion section please *NM* - 18/07/2018 12:17:03 AM 275 Views
moondog = *NM* - 04/08/2018 05:52:18 PM 244 Views

Reply to Message