Active Users:230 Time:29/03/2024 05:00:23 AM
Is there an uncanny valley of sci-fi hardness? aerocontrols Send a noteboard - 14/12/2018 03:17:46 PM

I keep seeing the trailer for Mortal Engines, and it really grinds my gears.* The concept of whole cities going mobile to attack each other sets off alarm bells in my scientific brain. It's just so wrong, from every perspective. We know how conquering works: you just send your armies to kill your enemies and take their stuff. You don't bring your hospitals, your churches, your grandparents, your grade schools, etc. So I completely reject the premise, and I know that this will ruin the story for me, the same way I couldn't stand The Matrix (and let me tell you - that was a lonely opinion until the first sequel was released).

But I don't have this problem accepting far more or equally fantastical premises for entertainment purposes: Tolkien, Marvel, Rowling, Early Lucas, Roddenberry, etc. I think the reason why is that they are so much further out on the sci-fi 'hardness' scale (towards 'soft' sci-fi). I can buy into a story with a fantastic premise (what if magic or what if future tech plus faster-than-light travel or what if superheroes) and then whether I enjoy the movie will depend on the quality of the movie.


Meanwhile, 'harder' sci-fi like The Martian, Contact, Primer, Firefly, or Moon is also something I can accept, and again my enjoyment of the product depends only on how well it's put together and presented to me.

So I know there is almost no chance I will like Mortal Engines for the same reasons I didn't like The Matrix.


*If any young people are present at this site, this is how middle-aged and older people say they're triggered.

Hollywood has the best moral compass, because it has compassion.
Reply to message
Is there an uncanny valley of sci-fi hardness? - 14/12/2018 03:17:46 PM 371 Views
the trailers look stupid - 14/12/2018 05:01:30 PM 233 Views
The premise is the only thing that made me want to see it - 15/12/2018 04:09:16 PM 230 Views
I just look at them as fantasy with a technology theme - 17/12/2018 01:04:12 PM 229 Views
I can't - 17/12/2018 02:34:17 PM 205 Views
or just use nuclear power - 17/12/2018 10:20:43 PM 219 Views
There are ways you could make sense of the Matrix if you try. (Doing so is of course absurd.) - 18/12/2018 01:26:56 AM 216 Views
My final sentence allows for that - 18/12/2018 02:21:19 PM 213 Views
Looks like the moviegoing public agrees - 18/12/2018 03:11:28 AM 230 Views

Reply to Message