Active Users:888 Time:05/07/2025 07:48:05 AM
Charity as a substitute for tax. That's probably one of the dumbest American ideas I've encountered. fionwe1987 Send a noteboard - 17/01/2019 05:19:06 AM

View original post
( ͜ | ͜ )

Many Americans who are doing well, either by an accident of birth or by working hard to overcome disadvantages and bad decisions, have no problem whatsoever donating both material and time resources to charities that help those less fortunate. What they don't want is to turn that all over to the government and pay more taxes to support it. It's a fundamental difference in belief of the purpose of government. The Left believes it's the responsibility of government to care for the weak. Small government conservatives, like me, don't agree. It is not the responsibility of government. Rather, it's the responsibility of humanity.

So I give money to several charities, and did so before I started itemizing deductions. I also volunteer for events held by the Connecticut Special Olympics and will be a participant in a polar bear plunge in March to help them raise money. But I oppose government taking away my ability to choose to make charitable gifts and making it mandatory via taxation.


Tax isn't charity. It isn't something you give out of the goodness of your heart. Its the bill for all the many services you enjoy, whether you're rich, or poor. If you disagree, spend a week using literally zero government provided services, and then talk.

The idea that giving to charity is enough to improve humanity is fundamentally idiotic. Large scale issues, whether it is government funding of medical research, or food inspections, or validating drugs, simply cannot be solved by charitable giving. Nor can you be charged per service, since the ripple effects of these kinds of service mean pretty much everyone benefits.

Americans like you just aren't aware of the efficiencies and advantages they gain from even their imperfect and less than completely efficient government. You've taken so many aspects of your life for granted that you are, it appears, completely unaware that, constantly obstructed as the American welfare system is by nitwits like you, there is still a trickle of services that barely manage to maintain reasonable stability.

Next time you feel the urge to claim that your charitable giving is somehow supposed to substitute for taxes, I urge you to try that tactic with Amazon, or Walmart. Ask them if you'll be given the stuff you want from their stores in exchange for maybe giving donations to their workers.

Reply to message
"Whenever you are offended, you are automatically right!" - 13/01/2019 05:45:16 PM 645 Views
This question offends me. That means I win, amirite? *NM* - 13/01/2019 10:35:07 PM 193 Views
Would you rather be correct or right? - 13/01/2019 11:03:50 PM 544 Views
As for me - 13/01/2019 11:06:47 PM 395 Views
I’m right some of the time. - 13/01/2019 11:46:14 PM 379 Views
Do you find the "golden mean" when you are "being correct?" - 14/01/2019 12:05:24 AM 387 Views
The debate I read the other day.... - 14/01/2019 10:17:39 PM 396 Views
I need more context to have an opinion on that. - 15/01/2019 07:18:10 PM 389 Views
The context was non-existant - 15/01/2019 11:55:05 PM 381 Views
Backs away from the debate you are referring to. - 16/01/2019 04:40:01 AM 372 Views
Not every conversation, - 16/01/2019 04:35:30 PM 382 Views
Of course - 16/01/2019 04:43:03 PM 371 Views
Of course you are becuase that makes you a victim - 15/01/2019 01:41:48 PM 390 Views
Everyone is a victim in their own story ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ - 15/01/2019 07:16:04 PM 380 Views
why is everybody always picking on me - 16/01/2019 02:59:10 PM 393 Views
But politics are never going to go away - 16/01/2019 05:00:06 PM 363 Views
I agree but it should be need based and not race or some other factor - 16/01/2019 05:53:06 PM 375 Views
Yes - 16/01/2019 07:49:16 PM 378 Views
Do just deserts grow deserving cacti? *NM* - 16/01/2019 08:04:03 PM 176 Views
Woosh - 16/01/2019 08:12:53 PM 385 Views
a just desert could be an equitable arid region, yes? *NM* - 16/01/2019 08:35:08 PM 172 Views
A just desert has artic foxes, it is known *NM* - 16/01/2019 10:05:13 PM 194 Views
what you say is true ... (here comes the but) - 16/01/2019 05:56:19 PM 391 Views
The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas *NM* - 16/01/2019 06:24:24 PM 197 Views
So what are you suggesting? - 16/01/2019 07:20:39 PM 385 Views
I can't speak for you Mookie, you are a mixed kind of being, which is a mixture of wonder and vice - 16/01/2019 07:41:35 PM 376 Views
My tax dollars paid for an original HBO series? - 16/01/2019 07:59:29 PM 383 Views
Well the 3rd thing I recommended - 16/01/2019 08:11:46 PM 392 Views
people who love to reference the maximum tax rates in the 50's and 60's... - 16/01/2019 08:32:19 PM 370 Views
All this is addressed in the Vox's episode - 16/01/2019 09:46:02 PM 372 Views
I listened to the entire episode. - 17/01/2019 05:12:19 PM 371 Views
LeBron James is not a billionaire ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ - 17/01/2019 05:29:33 PM 385 Views
No, he isn't. Not the best example - 17/01/2019 06:01:25 PM 400 Views
Charity as a substitute for tax. That's probably one of the dumbest American ideas I've encountered. - 17/01/2019 05:19:06 AM 375 Views
Re: why is everybody always picking on me - 17/01/2019 03:35:52 AM 368 Views
Interesting - 15/01/2019 09:07:38 PM 373 Views
I don't think that. - 15/01/2019 11:53:21 PM 403 Views
Well now. Thank you for this gift. - 15/01/2019 07:43:11 PM 355 Views
Hypocrisy is my gift of charity for all - 15/01/2019 07:50:28 PM 392 Views
Twitter says you're wrong! - 16/01/2019 09:05:00 AM 377 Views
I am offended by your offense, thus my being right has salience / primacy over you being right. - 16/01/2019 04:45:11 PM 363 Views
So let it be written, So let it be done! - 16/01/2019 05:07:38 PM 556 Views
I want that body! - 16/01/2019 05:32:49 PM 383 Views

Reply to Message