Active Users:210 Time:01/05/2024 12:15:37 PM
No worries The Shrike Send a noteboard - 26/08/2022 01:19:23 PM


From my understanding (mostly based on what I picked up back in high school), the Weimar republic was an actual working democracy (while it lasted), and that the personality cult hadn't really emerged yet until after 1933. But I realise that might be a very naïve view.

You are right that Weimar was a <mostly> functioning democracy. I think that is my point I am trying to make. The US in 2022 like Weimar in the 1920s is a functioning democracy (though the US is way better than Weimar) but there were cults of leadership back then. Nazism in the 1920s was a movement yes, but it was centered on Hitler. I am not in any way saying that Trump is another Hitler. Just that cults of personality in a democracy are very dangerous. Instead of differences by party, we have one party succumbing to one man. So in the US it's Democrats versus Republicans versus Trumpicans.

As for the personality cult beginning much earlier in Weimar - here's a paragraph from Wikipedia. The sources cites are from Kershaw's Hitler biography so they are reputable.

In June 1921, while Hitler and Eckart were on a fundraising trip to Berlin, a mutiny broke out within the Nazi Party in Munich. Members of its executive committee wanted to merge with the Nuremberg-based German Socialist Party (DSP).[100] Hitler returned to Munich on 11 July and angrily tendered his resignation. The committee members realised that the resignation of their leading public figure and speaker would mean the end of the party.[101] Hitler announced he would rejoin on the condition that he would replace Drexler as party chairman, and that the party headquarters would remain in Munich.[102] The committee agreed, and he rejoined the party on 26 July as member 3,680. Hitler continued to face some opposition within the Nazi Party. Opponents of Hitler in the leadership had Hermann Esser expelled from the party, and they printed 3,000 copies of a pamphlet attacking Hitler as a traitor to the party.[102][d] In the following days, Hitler spoke to several packed houses and defended himself and Esser, to thunderous applause. His strategy proved successful, and at a special party congress on 29 July, he was granted absolute powers as party chairman, replacing Drexler, by a vote of 533 to 1.[103]

Reply to message
Does everyone remember when Liz Cheney was a monster who betrayed her lesbian sister? - 20/08/2022 11:46:38 AM 340 Views
Cheney has a career 76% rating from all the major conservative organizations. - 20/08/2022 04:47:06 PM 132 Views
2024 - 22/08/2022 03:07:40 AM 146 Views
I find it somewhat disconcerting… - 22/08/2022 03:47:01 AM 123 Views
I find it reassuring! - 22/08/2022 04:45:22 AM 119 Views
Are you following the Utah Senate race? - 22/08/2022 07:25:39 PM 120 Views
Re: Are you following the Utah Senate race? - 22/08/2022 10:00:41 PM 107 Views
Yes - 20/08/2022 11:08:52 PM 128 Views
Yes, I'm pretty sure everyone does remember. - 21/08/2022 07:44:30 PM 114 Views
MTG - 22/08/2022 03:05:20 AM 105 Views
Trump was the best president in my lifetime! - 22/08/2022 11:23:27 PM 112 Views
I was born one month after Ike’s first election. - 23/08/2022 01:26:19 AM 112 Views
Not a fan of Reagan? - 23/08/2022 01:51:40 PM 105 Views
Re: Not a fan of Reagan? - 23/08/2022 08:38:40 PM 111 Views
Largest peacetime tax increase in history? Are you fucking on drugs yourself? - 26/08/2022 03:49:59 PM 121 Views
two things can both be true - 26/08/2022 05:11:13 PM 124 Views
I’d be hard-pressed to name one since before WWI - 24/08/2022 04:20:27 AM 111 Views
Actually I would put RMN at the bottom of my list of worst Presidents. - 24/08/2022 01:41:34 PM 94 Views
Really? I'm not even sure I'd rank Nixon below Bush. - 24/08/2022 07:34:18 PM 116 Views
I would - 24/08/2022 08:36:19 PM 103 Views
I must say I agree with Legolas on this... - 24/08/2022 11:45:34 PM 108 Views
You read about the Nixon years. I was in high school when he won in ‘68. - 25/08/2022 02:37:57 AM 118 Views
You also lived through Bush, right? - 25/08/2022 07:25:26 PM 107 Views
at least two of my three were historical characters *NM* - 25/08/2022 08:50:27 PM 58 Views
James Buchanan as worst. - 26/08/2022 01:24:42 PM 124 Views
In Weimar part II, loyalty to the Führer is paramount for many Republicans. - 23/08/2022 01:49:15 PM 120 Views
There was no Führer in the Weimar republic - 23/08/2022 08:07:51 PM 121 Views
Given that I have a Masters in German History, that is not the point. But thank you. - 24/08/2022 01:57:06 PM 141 Views
I thought I was replying to someone else, actually - 25/08/2022 02:31:22 AM 133 Views
No worries - 26/08/2022 01:19:23 PM 140 Views
Very interesting comparison *NM* - 26/08/2022 05:05:48 PM 67 Views

Reply to Message