Active Users:211 Time:22/09/2023 03:15:16 AM
No, Caplan is for dismantling high school Roland00 Send a noteboard - 03/09/2022 01:38:52 AM

He has called for kids that are age 13 to do apprenticeships, yet he says that is a bad choice, unless all 13 year olds due apprenticeships (due to signal mechanisms)

And thus you need the whole NATIONAL system to be disrupted all at once or else you get perverse incentives says Caplan for he is a "true believer."


And do not get Caplan onto civics, and how much people retain!


Of course so much of the human brain is against what Caplan is calling for, people who actually study education, novelty, learning skills in a stepwise matter (for you do not learn all at once, and when you do learn a trade often you learn faster and better in the zone of proximal development with a teacher or fellow class mates helping you to test you at the full maximum of what you currently are capable to do in a group but by yourself without aid it would be beyond your abilities.)

But Caplan theories are also design if you can't measure it, then it is wasted by his definition of non-beneficial surplus. But humans are not built the way Caplan thinks we are.

shrug he is dealing with areas of reality we can't really test for, they are not falsifiable. Except when we do test for it, he discounts those forms of tests. He is a true believer, there is no arguing with him.

Like I said earlier he has dozens of pet projects and once you start looking at what he believes, you see he truly believes it, but also most of what he is suggesting is unworkable and often completely weird. Yet since he is on another planet sometimes you listen to him not because he has good ideas but because if you are in the fields he is critiquing you need to deal with these complaints even if they are good faith / bad faith / neither faith.

Reply to message
100% YES to this - 01/09/2022 04:34:03 PM 272 Views
Bryan Caplan, Now, that's a name I haven't heard in a long time... A long time. - 01/09/2022 09:11:50 PM 96 Views
Blind squirrel, broken clock. - 02/09/2022 04:11:25 PM 82 Views
He is interesting to read. - 02/09/2022 07:39:40 PM 82 Views
The website and phone person lied to me, *sigh* *NM* - 03/09/2022 12:23:56 AM 45 Views
What a typical display of American stupidity... - 02/09/2022 12:26:08 PM 111 Views
I don't read this as a call for the end of K-12 schooling. - 02/09/2022 03:57:24 PM 90 Views
No, Caplan is for dismantling high school - 03/09/2022 01:38:52 AM 82 Views
We've had school vouchers for almost 30 years now, in Sweden - 02/09/2022 03:57:56 PM 91 Views
Yeah that's probably the biggest objection here from those who oppose vouchers. - 02/09/2022 04:17:45 PM 98 Views
Problem is... - 12/09/2022 05:34:34 PM 84 Views
Do you mind explaining the history of how that happened in Sweden? - 02/09/2022 07:42:44 PM 84 Views
How our current school system came about? - 04/09/2022 03:38:42 AM 74 Views
As Mr H. L. Mencken said... - 02/09/2022 04:17:28 PM 83 Views
Or as Mr. Samuel Clemens said, - 02/09/2022 04:29:50 PM 86 Views
You both sound like aliens - 03/09/2022 04:04:01 PM 91 Views
Re: You both sound like aliens - 03/09/2022 04:43:56 PM 71 Views
Alienation? - 03/09/2022 05:52:25 PM 82 Views

Reply to Message