Active Users:279 Time:06/05/2024 01:19:07 AM
True, it's apples and oranges - but aren't most sports statistics then? Legolas Send a noteboard - 05/03/2024 05:41:18 PM

Other than perhaps the most extreme cases, like Wilt Chamberlain's 100 point game before the 3 point shot even existed, nearly all sports records have to be considered with various caveats or asterisks. But still people like to keep track of them.

View original postBecause Pete Maravich didn't play NCAA women's basketball. He played men's ball. Caitlin Clark is an incredible player, and what she has done is a great accomplishment. But it's ridiculous to claim what she did puts her on top of both the women's and men's scoring leaders. LeBron James became the first NBA player to score over 40,000 points this week. If Caitlin Clark plays for over 20 years in the WNBA and scores more, did she surpass LeBron?

LeBron's achievement is more a proof of his unusual longevity - paired with his maturity as a young player, skipping college entirely to get more years in the NBA than his peers - than of his GOAT-ness. Even though he certainly should be in the conversation for that.

As for Caitlin Clark scoring more than 40,000 points, that would first require the WNBA, at a minimum, to play equally long games as the men and more importantly play as many games in a season... neither of which seems remotely viable. As it stands, female WNBA players generally play two seasons each year, one in the WNBA during a couple of months and most of the rest of the year in some other league, in Europe or Turkey. As scoring goes, reaching 10k in the WNBA is about as big a milestone as reaching 30k in the NBA. Or even as big as 40k - only Diana Taurasi has reached 10k and only just, having played roughly as long as James, with nobody else even at 7.5k. Clark would need one hell of a career - or a dramatic increase in the number of minutes played per season - to even equal Taurasi.

View original postWhen Maravich played, college athletes had only 3 years of eligibility and there was no 3 point shot. Whereas Clark is in her 4th year and all have been played with the 3 point shot in effect. Even if they were both men or both women, it's apples to oranges.

Very true.
View original postIt does not diminish Caitlin Clark to view her accomplishments within the perspective of the women's game. As they should be viewed.

Reply to message
Caitlin Clark becomes the career points leader for NCAA women's basketball - 04/03/2024 11:24:12 PM 74 Views
True, it's apples and oranges - but aren't most sports statistics then? - 05/03/2024 05:41:18 PM 40 Views

Reply to Message