None of us will count it as a loss if we lynch the jester, a win for her, sure, if she is one, we kill her and she dumps into Amys or Hobo's body with a win, game continues. It's not like the town or scum have to go "Oh, just second place" if they win, it's still a win. If we don't lynch her, we leave this up as a possible future roleclaim for safety and it might encourages other mods to use the role. Long term, our best option is to nuke these sort of roles on principle.

But this all assumes she really is a jester, and she hasn't claimed that. She says she's not a vig, she says she did attack Napoleon... ironically she also said she didn't get a dawn/dusk message, which if she attacked Napoleon seems fairly unlikely, though he may have simply communicated the result via day 2 intro post.

Point being, she could have gotten herself lynched easily on day 1, or today, without drawing suspicion. In fact, were she a jester, winning by lynch but not NK, she should have tried hard yesterday, where it takes little effort to get oneself lynched and there's no chance of falling prey to a NK. She had three weeks to have come up with a method, all the while having me pan out series of way in which to have done it, but she made no attempt at all. Any of those questions, she could have arranged to have made contradictory and expected to draw attention. MRE Yes? Well nothing but high fantasy and scifi then. MCS No, claim Superman as your setting, instead of the wider DC. Getting lynched on day 1 isn't that hard, yet nothing in her posts seems designed to have gone that route. I don't see it. I could see her treading too lightly out of fear of sparking Jester worries if she'd gone all out, but one would expect to see something in her style yesterday indicating some attempt to draw suspicion.

I want to hear her response, but somehow I don't think she's trying to get lynched, and even if she is, I don't see any reason not to oblige her, it gains us valuable information, her 'faction' gets wiped out, she returns as an inactive player, we proceed safely knowing it's a two party game.