The 'if I were scum would I...?" and various variations on how someone wouldn't make a mistake or error of that type only works if it's got some track record. You actually do have a track record of occasional aggressive swings without too solid of targeting, I don't particular think people's style changes much when scum or town in that respect, so I am actually quite sure you were trying to stir up a case on me without looking like it, and I'm betting the others will agree. Now that doesn't make you scum, you might be town or scum and regardless be doing it, and the reason could be something as simple as 'wanted to push things forward'.

However, one thing you can't sell was that it wasn't a real accusation. Because it was, it looks like an attempt to accuse without seeming to do so in a fashion you couldn't withdraw from. I certainly ain't going to buy that, and I don't think the others will accept that either. Doesn't mean they'll sign onto a lynch, again its entirely believable that your motives were to stir the pot a bit or pro-town, but accidental premeditated and thoroughly researched accusations? No, linking to acts of mine from prior games doesn't really fit the casual or incidental accusation narrative.



Well it doesn't seem you had a problem articulating it so much as a problem finding anything concrete to put your chips on so you went with vague implications like 'kill Isaac for acting like he always does' in the same one where you say 'kill Isaac because he's acting different' and 'kill Isaac because we need to teach him a lesson in humility'.

There's also the whole cherry-picking, hitting me for having a pro-active and homicidal plan to break up Day 1 idleness because one of them was when I was scum makes as much sense as killing FT because he often refuses to role claim when he's scum, he also supports a lot of lynches on Day 1 when scum. This is true, FT is very reluctant to RC when scum and regularly pushes lynches when scum... he also happens to do that when he's town. Heck, while we're at it, "Kill FT and Isaac because they've pushed more lynches ending in town death's than any other player", this is also true. Or, "Every time Isaac is scum, a townie gets lynched on Day 1", that's actually not true but close enough, the others were SKs or third party or no lynch day enders, same difference right?

So, here's what it comes down to, you're claiming this was a 'hunch' and you've doubled down on that... but you still have your vote on me. Why exactly was that again?