Active Users:174 Time:02/06/2024 12:19:52 PM
Actually... Cannoli Send a noteboard - 02/06/2011 09:56:59 PM

Don't worry, Cersei in the show comes off as utterly dangerous and massively despicable. Very one-sided and vilainous for now (though IRRC, this will be balanced a bit later when we get to see what kind of father she has,
But see, that's the problem! People keep jumping on her background as an excuse, but we see in her own recollections in Book 4 that she had the closest and most affectionate relationship with Tywin of the three children (though we see that the relative decency of each one seems inverse to his or her relationship with Tywin - Tyrion was practically a child-abuse victim and is the best by far, while Cersei who was treated better than Jaime makes him look honorable and virtuous), but Tyrion and Jaime have at least a cursory understanding of right and wrong. Jaime really seems to be somewhat spoiled by having never had to truly be tried or tested - his tragic background is in having everything come so easily to him that he is completely lacking in compassion or empathy and has never been trained to obey any sort of moral code other than his family's reputation or interests. With that as the only moral compass, much of his actions can be understood, if not justified, particularly in light of his drunken rant to Catelyn. Cersei however, is spoiled in the classical sense, having assumed a sense of entitlement from her upbringing and absorbed an ethos of ruthlessness, combining to strip her of any moral yardstick beyond her own wishes and whims. But instead people argue that her father mistreated her or something which justifies her own behavior, that being spoiled somehow excuses or justifies her. Diagnosis is not a cure. The word "spoiled" is used for a reason.


The scene that nailed her character in the show (for a non-reading audience) is the one where she comes to the room to see if Bran will die, manipulating Catelyn's emotions (toward despair and pain, which was utterly mean) with her fake empathy derived from the death of her own first born (it came off as if she didn't care much about that, or worse that she killed that baby from Robert or knows her family did) - when the audience remembers all too well she gave the order to kill Bran, and was obviously very displeased when Tyrion told her he would live.
She didn't. Tyrion actually works out that it was Joffrey and only tells Jaime who seems to think it might be possible. Cersei had nothing to do with it and doesn't seem to know (or care) who was behind it. If any adult had anything to do with it, it was a careless drunken remark by Robert about putting Bran out of his misery. Joffrey swiped the dagger Robert had won betting on the tourney (betting against Jaime and rubbing it in his face), and armed a minion with it to kill Bran. He gives himself away when he hacks up Tyrion's book at his wedding breakfast and boasts "I am no stranger to Valyrian steel." Tyrion makes the connection at that point, and offers to replace the book with a dagger he describes like the one used against Bran. Joffrey's reaction to the description confirms it to Tyrion and following the meal he questions Sansa to ascertain Joffrey's motivation.

Dangerous and cynical, and expert at hiding her real game is how she came off (it taints whatever she says afterward, you're not inclined to trust anything she says anymore).
That's sort of what I got, but I was influenced by foreknowledge from the books. I felt it might have seemed to the viewers as if she was actually sympathetic. Combined with her later chat with Robert it might cause people to more readily accept her justifications, taking her claims of loving her children at face value. And I don't read her character from the books as dangerous, except in the sense of being in a position of great power with absolutely no compunctions about doing whatever she wishes at all. She's dangerous in the way that an impulsive six-year-old is behind the wheel of a tractor trailer truck. When you get the whole picture of what was going on in the first book, her seeming control of the situation is actually a combination of a pose and arrogant false assumptions of her own power and invulnerability. She herself later admits that Ned might still have won if not for a couple of lucky breaks, and in retrospect, given that Petyr has been manipulating this whole confrontation, you have to see his betrayal of Ned as the real deal-breaker, rather than any cunning of Cersei's.

The way she traps Sansa in her webs is also quite obvious in the show - you even suspect a lot that after recent developments she must be the one who forced Joeffrey to pretend to be nice and finish to seduce Sansa away from her family.
Agreed. They did do that better and more noticeably in the series, whereas in the book it was earlier and more gradual and gave the impression instead that their relationship had simply been mended.
Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
Reply to message
Game of Thrones 1.06 - 23/05/2011 09:38:12 PM 1412 Views
Re: Game of Thrones 1.06 - 23/05/2011 10:00:57 PM 671 Views
Re: Game of Thrones 1.06 - 24/05/2011 01:08:53 AM 577 Views
That's who she is! Tonks! - 24/05/2011 12:29:38 AM 573 Views
the Imp's champion is Bronn - 24/05/2011 12:36:32 AM 794 Views
I was very excited when she appeared. TONKS! *NM* - 24/05/2011 08:15:21 PM 236 Views
I was disappointed by the lack of a flashback when Ned woke up - 24/05/2011 12:49:20 AM 646 Views
Blame religion on the lack of the seven kingdoms including the riverlands, there are actually 9 - 24/05/2011 01:33:24 AM 557 Views
Storm of Sword Spoilers - 24/05/2011 01:38:02 AM 603 Views
Yeah, no. What? - 24/05/2011 03:09:03 AM 702 Views
Re: Yeah, no. What? - 24/05/2011 07:37:16 PM 475 Views
Aegon converted to the Seven during the invasion. - 25/05/2011 01:14:04 AM 463 Views
The Kingdom Count has been a hot topic for years - 25/05/2011 01:22:12 AM 555 Views
Huh. I always just assumed nobody counted the Iron Islands. - 26/05/2011 10:03:30 PM 418 Views
Re: I was disappointed by the lack of a flashback when Ned woke up - 26/05/2011 02:25:36 PM 456 Views
Actually... - 02/06/2011 09:56:59 PM 532 Views
Here is another thing I missed entirely in the books... - 24/05/2011 03:26:28 AM 531 Views
Another great episode. - 24/05/2011 02:51:41 PM 502 Views
No, he was drunk in the book too. *NM* - 24/05/2011 08:17:39 PM 205 Views
It was a great episode. - 24/05/2011 08:24:20 PM 578 Views
Re: It was a great episode. - 25/05/2011 01:19:45 AM 463 Views
I feel very bad for Sansa. - 25/05/2011 02:47:07 AM 485 Views
I feel like I should. - 26/05/2011 06:45:23 PM 530 Views
Yeah, she's pretty annoying - 26/05/2011 08:53:24 PM 438 Views
Re: Yeah, she's pretty annoying - 26/05/2011 10:22:19 PM 481 Views
Re: Yeah, she's pretty annoying - 27/05/2011 01:54:21 AM 428 Views
Re: Yeah, she's pretty annoying - 27/05/2011 02:04:50 AM 459 Views
Exactly. *NM* - 27/05/2011 03:31:30 AM 208 Views
Re: *HBO spoilers in here* - 27/05/2011 05:13:20 AM 434 Views
Re: *HBO spoilers in here* - 28/05/2011 03:16:28 PM 491 Views
I agree 100 % *NM* - 28/05/2011 03:27:24 PM 212 Views
Re: *HBO spoilers in here* - 30/05/2011 08:01:59 PM 412 Views
As someone else who doesn't know the books... - 25/05/2011 03:24:30 PM 543 Views
Re: As someone else who doesn't know the books... - 25/05/2011 05:23:36 PM 503 Views
I agree - 25/05/2011 11:16:47 PM 480 Views
She becomes more ambiguous later on, not so much at the start. *NM* - 26/05/2011 10:06:14 PM 195 Views
Re: Game of Thrones 1.06 - 26/05/2011 03:33:47 AM 532 Views
Re: Game of Thrones 1.06 - 26/05/2011 01:13:01 PM 494 Views
Re: Game of Thrones 1.06 - 26/05/2011 07:00:56 PM 446 Views
Re: Game of Thrones 1.06 - 26/05/2011 10:07:30 PM 464 Views
I cant stand Sansa - 26/05/2011 05:03:26 AM 497 Views
Re: I cant stand Sansa - 26/05/2011 01:27:43 PM 485 Views
Easy killer! - 27/05/2011 12:04:25 AM 473 Views
well its good to knwo i have somethign to look forward to - 27/05/2011 02:59:48 AM 442 Views
Re: Easy killer! - 27/05/2011 06:05:39 AM 441 Views
That's not entirely fair... she does grow a lot as a person. *NM* - 27/05/2011 10:28:16 PM 202 Views
She grows a lot and advances to being tolerable - 28/05/2011 09:20:10 AM 364 Views

Reply to Message