Active Users:168 Time:14/06/2024 06:56:25 AM
RJ said... Etzel Send a noteboard - 26/04/2010 07:51:10 AM
IIRC, certain members of this community got their panties in a bunch over Jordan's statements that clashed with their own interpretations of the scene. One statement was that he did not show everyone who was present, such as Erian Boroleos(sp? ), Semirhage and Graendal, which meant that those who built enormous theories on Semirhage's non-appearance (particularly those who presumed on absolutely no evidence whatsoever that she is the most badass Forsaken of all and her absense was the sole reason for the good guys' victory/survival) tried to claim that Jordan was lying or wrong because Graendal WAS seen (by Verin). I recall some rather bitter recriminations flying around the WoTMB of wotmania on the topic.
However, we see in these comments above, Jordan distinguishes between different types of mentions.
I’ve mentioned them, but I did not show them; you were not there. There’s a difference between mentioning and actually being there, taking a character there to see them
This could be the converse of his statements about the Cleansing, where he had a character see Graendal, but she was never mentioned. The Forsaken facing Verin's circle could have been a different woman in disguise, for all we know. She is never positively identified, and we don't get her PoV. A wordsearch of that portion of the book for her name would not turn up anything except possibly one of her comrades thinking of her. Since Jordan feels the distinction between mentioning and showing is important enough to interrupt an interviewer/questioner over, his statements regarding the presence of Graendal at the Cleansing might now be reconciled with her presumptive appearance in the actual book.

"Semirhage was present at Shadar Logoth, though not seen. You didn't see Graendal, either, though admittedly Moghedien thought of her, thinking it would be good if she or Cyndane died. If I always tried to show everyone who was present at a battle or the like, the books would be a LOT longer than they are now. And those battles would get rather boring, a list of names. Go down the checklist and make sure everyone gets mentioned. Boring."

This is clearly wrong, because Graendal was actually seen and shown, contrary to Semirhage who wasn't.
Reply to message
First paragraph of ToM *slight spoilers* - 24/04/2010 10:23:06 AM 31047 Views
I think its clear now... - 24/04/2010 04:38:42 PM 3848 Views
I don't know - 24/04/2010 05:00:49 PM 3590 Views
About the Jordan comments - a defense of his old comments on the Cleansing - 26/04/2010 01:38:29 AM 4032 Views
RJ said... - 26/04/2010 07:51:10 AM 3510 Views
My point was, he might have been thinking of the PoVs. None of her or people who knew her - 26/04/2010 12:40:39 PM 3468 Views
No - 26/04/2010 12:59:34 PM 3292 Views
RJ confused the Towers of Midnight and the Tower of the Ravens - 30/04/2010 10:23:33 AM 3258 Views
I'm not that sure - 30/04/2010 11:07:40 AM 3199 Views
I am - 30/04/2010 06:54:04 PM 3268 Views
Well.... - 01/05/2010 09:52:14 AM 3204 Views
Re: Well.... - 01/05/2010 10:00:16 AM 3190 Views
Yeah, cool! *NM* - 01/05/2010 10:12:02 AM 1855 Views
Usually people are consistent with their mistakes during a given period of time - 03/05/2010 05:11:04 AM 3187 Views
Agreed. *NM* - 03/05/2010 05:50:59 PM 1873 Views

Reply to Message