Active Users:431 Time:26/04/2024 11:47:42 AM
Some points Cannoli Send a noteboard - 25/02/2017 11:54:50 PM

View original post
How does a world replete with powerful magic never use it to improve anyones life? Because most peoples knowledge of that great power begins with the Breaking and ends with the machiavellian Aes Sedai. Imagine a world where everyone was a member of Earth First from birth: If someone offered them refineries that "poisoned the world for the profit of corporate conspiracies" how many would accept? Even the relatively "enlightened" Aes Sedai do not fully nor even MOSTLY understand the One Powers mechanics, regularly being crippled, killed or outright annihilated by the few limited experiments they still attempt. They DO understand and rightly fear their consistently catastrophic history of exploiting the One Power to gain temporal power. So Hogwarts was never on the table for anyone.
You might have accurately described the attitudes, but it's still bullshit, to such a degree I am not entirely sure that even the obvious and between-the-lines aspects of their brainwashing and group think explain the extreme degree to which they carry their caution. I kind of think people are GOING to gravitate towards more efficient or effective solutions when they are readily available for minimal tradeoffs. More than once in the latter books, the Aes Sedai themselves deal with issues of lack of light and conserving fuel for their lamps. But the most basic and fundamental skill they demonstrate as novices is making balls of light. Why are they straining their eyes peering over papers late at night in a tent by the light of oil lamps, when they could tie off globes of light that would last forever? Why are they selling cuendillar ornaments for the 1% instead of making a fortune in volume by selling eternal balls of light for pennies apiece? For that matter, given all the other ways they piss all over the spirit of their Oaths, why are they not having their unsworn initiates converting swords and pike- & arrowheads and armor plates into cuendillar in preparation for the last battle? Elaida says she could only make good weather in a single farm...but that's today. Why can't she tie it off and do a second farm tomorrow? This is not social justice, this is the source of the food she herself eats! Elaida wards rats away from the palace, and Moiraine from the Queen's Blessing, but again, why is she not doing a building a day? She indicates later in her own PoV that she is very much aware of the sanitation issues involved in large cities.

I really think the only explanation for this stuff is Jordan's failure of imagination. Maybe people would fear the Power that broke the world being used for their homes, but how are they going to know, or prevent it or undo it? Warding a home against vermin without people's knowledge or consent is far more justifiable from a public health perspective than mandatory "ring" vaccination programs.



At first he has no ambition beyond marrying his favorite village girl,

Actually he wasn't all that eager to get married.
then his goal is bitterly sacrificing himself for an ungrateful world, and at last he is eager both to save the world AND survive doing so before vanishing to avert that worlds permanent dependence on him (one alternate realities Rand witnesses while battling the DO surely includes his existence as God Emperor of Dune. )
Stop being so absurd. If he's the God Emperor of Dune, where are his hordes of fanatically loyal blue-eyed desert super-warriors? Where is his polygamous relationship with a desert shaman girl and a princess trained by a secretive all-female order of manipulators? Where is his twin son & daughter? Does he have children born with superhuman abilities? Get your facts straight before making absurd comparisons to other works.
Most other main characters grow to varying degrees. Mat is initially more rebellious and lazy than even Rand, but circumstances and friendship gradually evoke his sense of loyalty, which command in turn develops into a sense of responsibility; where Perrin disdains the prestige and luxury of nobility, Mat is fully comfortable with both and merely disdains nobilitys DUTIES, but eventually accepts those as well.

That was Sandersonian bullshit. Mat always had a sense of duty and personal obligation, from his proud assertion that he does his chores every day back in EotW, to his loyalty to Rand even under the influence of the Shadar Logoth dagger, and the extremes to which he is dragged on his quest in tDR. He always took care of his men and retainers, and placed himself in danger or took up leadership positions when necessary. He disdained nobles for their stereotypical sensibilities and behaviors, and probably for his perception of their failures at the obligations of their positions, as well as their abuse of their powers and privileges (see, for example, his sarcastic comments to his gambling companions regarding their loss of aristocratic immunity to prosecution). Perrin is the one who actually shirks the duties of a noble, though out of not understanding their significance, rather than reluctance to undertake them.
Perrins honor morphs into neuroses, and Egwenes loss of naivete comes at the cost of her innocence as well
Perrin's obsessive issues had nothing to do with honor, and everything to do with excessive concern for his wife. He freely admitted he would have done anything dishonorable if it could have restored Faile to him. He never really articulated his morals and values as honor or anything like that.
Between Jordans general outline, Sandersons conscientiousness, Harriets protectiveness and Dohertys loyalty, it may just be a case of too many cooks overcooking the broth.

I didn't see any of that. IDK what Harriet was protecting, because the finished product, especially the companion/dictionary thing, reeks of desperation to shove something onto the market to take advantage of a devoted fan base before it dissipates. However conscientious Sanderson might have been, his actual writing and command of the English language were appalling, from even a casual re-read, and he got many of the characters and details flat out wrong. I could understand not conveying the story properly, but making sure all the fact are just right, as an expression of conscientiousness, but that's not what we got.

Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
Reply to message
How did you feel after completing AMoL? - - 24/02/2017 04:03:10 AM 1612 Views
Unsatisfied I suppose or perhaps regretful - 24/02/2017 02:54:12 PM 1059 Views
I'll post this again - 25/02/2017 01:29:16 AM 793 Views
Very good post, can't argue with it. - 25/02/2017 02:40:18 AM 979 Views
I can argue with some of it - 25/02/2017 09:32:17 PM 906 Views
You can say whatever you want, but you're wrong - 25/02/2017 10:40:58 PM 841 Views
We are not discussing concrete facts, so objective error is impossible - 26/02/2017 01:21:46 AM 967 Views
In any discussion, error is possible. In your discussions, it's a near certainty. - 28/02/2017 08:24:59 PM 797 Views
On a different topic, how important do you think that stuff is? - 03/03/2017 07:20:15 AM 912 Views
It's all about suspending disbelief, isn't it? - 04/03/2017 01:13:12 AM 897 Views
That makes a lot of sense. - 08/03/2017 10:18:56 PM 894 Views
On further reflection, I think the religion element being left out is important. - 04/03/2017 04:07:53 AM 819 Views
Middle-Earth? - 08/03/2017 09:53:45 PM 985 Views
A Elbereth Gilthoniel... - 10/03/2017 04:48:50 PM 838 Views
Personally, "religion" in WoT makes perfect sense... For the AoL. Not so much the Third Age - 09/03/2017 01:55:29 AM 920 Views
But did they really undeniably prove this existence? - 09/03/2017 04:19:43 PM 1029 Views
Re: But did they really undeniably prove this existence? - 10/03/2017 07:47:11 AM 1015 Views
I think we are saying similar things - 12/03/2017 08:31:13 PM 922 Views
Some points - 25/02/2017 11:54:50 PM 888 Views
Well, some THINGS anyway. - 26/02/2017 01:56:29 AM 852 Views
Your recognition of irony is profound - 26/02/2017 08:39:47 AM 811 Views
mosty disappointment - 27/02/2017 10:15:29 PM 818 Views
Exhausted - 27/02/2017 10:52:51 PM 824 Views
Total agree about Moiraine's return..... - 28/02/2017 03:57:57 AM 851 Views
With Demandred... That was likely at least somewhat the point. - 28/02/2017 06:09:13 AM 797 Views
Not best pleased. - 27/02/2017 11:59:06 PM 767 Views
It felt like the end of Grease when the car flew off - 01/03/2017 02:22:19 AM 827 Views
Re: It felt like the end of Grease when the car flew off - 01/03/2017 08:39:23 AM 941 Views
Re: It felt like the end of Grease when the car flew off - 01/03/2017 11:23:18 PM 916 Views
Re: It felt like the end of Grease when the car flew off - 02/03/2017 06:07:12 AM 800 Views
I still haven't read it. - 01/03/2017 08:03:53 PM 763 Views
Interesting, any reason why you haven't read it yet? *NM* - 01/03/2017 10:26:21 PM 475 Views
It was the end of their world as I knew it, and I felt fine. *NM* - 02/03/2017 11:13:25 PM 504 Views
You were just happy that you-know-who died! *NM* - 03/03/2017 02:47:38 AM 512 Views
Disappointed, shocked, relieved. - 03/03/2017 04:44:56 PM 757 Views
Curious - what were you hoping to happen to Rand at the end? *NM* - 03/03/2017 09:00:12 PM 526 Views
Me too! - 04/03/2017 10:19:21 AM 706 Views
I cried and I was glad it was over! - 04/03/2017 09:13:03 PM 848 Views
there's just SO MUCH that could happen - 05/03/2017 09:33:26 AM 855 Views

Reply to Message