I don't think it's a two-way street in that manner. It's PoMo appropriating Victorian not vice versa
Dan Send a noteboard - 21/04/2011 11:40:29 PM
As far as a "reasonable reason for its anachronistic presence", there isn't one, and according roughly to postmodern precepts, there needn't be. The only criterion they use if it looks cool or not. The lack of "reasonable reason" should indicate that it's postmodernism doing the appropriating, not the other way around. It's not terribly deep, but I'm not arguing that and I'm not concerned with depth.
It just feels a little off to me, most of the time, when we aren't given a reasonable reason for its anachronistic presence. I mean, if I went to Lascaux and saw paintings of cave men tooling around in a '57 Chevy my first reaction wouldn't be "how imaginative". 
The Sprawl Trilogy and Thoughts Thereof (or What Ever Happened to Cyberpunk?)
- 19/04/2011 10:50:26 PM
2847 Views
Why I prefer cyberpunk in near future settings to (most) of the steampunk sub-genre.
- 19/04/2011 10:55:57 PM
1603 Views
The difference is that steampunk, by and large, is very aware of its implausibility.
- 20/04/2011 01:32:57 AM
1128 Views
You keep giving steampunk backhanded compliments like that and you'll start to confuse me.
- 20/04/2011 02:12:53 AM
1193 Views
Being entertaining is not a backhanded compliment.
- 20/04/2011 02:34:15 AM
1268 Views
It is when asserting something is better than a source containing more than entertainment.
- 20/04/2011 03:26:50 AM
1346 Views
...didn't you wear a top hat to your wedding? *NM*
- 20/04/2011 04:04:42 AM
563 Views
IIRC I wore morning dress, the CURRENT standard here.
- 20/04/2011 05:08:26 AM
1187 Views
Top hats in morning dress have gone the way of the ascot (you didn't wear an ascot, did you?).
- 20/04/2011 05:41:54 AM
1153 Views
Well, my wife, mother-in-law and the woman at the haberdashery all disagree.
- 20/04/2011 07:05:09 AM
1221 Views
the ability to wear a costume at a convention is hardly a ringing endorsement of a genre
- 22/04/2011 01:49:40 AM
1290 Views
Your impression is close to being my comments verbatim.
- 22/04/2011 02:50:18 AM
1279 Views
I tried to avoid that word, but I'll leave comparisons there and discuss pure cyberpunk henceforth.
- 22/04/2011 03:58:29 PM
1295 Views
You keep coming back to this argument, and it keeps being a stupid one.
- 22/04/2011 10:33:14 PM
1199 Views
I also can't help noting how this whole argument mirrors Count Zero.
- 24/04/2011 05:35:01 AM
1643 Views
I think it's just a matter of two separate genres that share very similar names and perhaps origins.
- 20/04/2011 01:32:50 AM
1299 Views
It's hard to argue that the genres are separate, but I did try to avoid suggesting a competition.
- 20/04/2011 03:08:49 AM
1341 Views
Ok, what are you trying to argue for and/or explore in this thread? There are three options:
- 20/04/2011 04:22:52 AM
1249 Views
It is under-appreciated critically, largely due to relative unpopularity.
- 20/04/2011 06:35:27 AM
1460 Views
"Victorian Postmodernism" is viable because Postmodernism can appropriate other periods and styles.
- 21/04/2011 01:13:45 AM
1226 Views
But can other periods and styles appropriate postmodernism?
- 21/04/2011 07:38:29 PM
1283 Views
I don't think it's a two-way street in that manner. It's PoMo appropriating Victorian not vice versa
- 21/04/2011 11:40:29 PM
1297 Views
It's only superficially postmodern though, else there'd be no wistfulness for Victorian styles.
- 22/04/2011 03:17:38 PM
1323 Views
IMO, cyberpunk has become somewhat dated.
- 20/04/2011 04:46:55 AM
1390 Views
Actually, I can live with that, though terms like "dated" invite trouble.
- 20/04/2011 07:01:50 AM
1229 Views
Re: Actually, I can live with that, though terms like "dated" invite trouble.
- 22/04/2011 04:12:20 AM
1295 Views
so...is bladerunner cyberpunk
- 20/04/2011 09:48:15 PM
1098 Views
It's usually seen as the archetypal cyberpunk film, yeah.
- 21/04/2011 10:50:44 AM
1419 Views
so cyber is the time and punk is the attitude?
- 21/04/2011 12:57:01 PM
1195 Views
I don't think the portmanteau is that precisely defined.
- 21/04/2011 08:31:34 PM
1336 Views
I am amazed that no one has referenced this TVTropes page yet...
- 23/04/2011 07:45:14 PM
1616 Views
Playing with fire; I should've known TVTropes would exhaustively cover the derivatives.
- 24/04/2011 03:11:56 AM
1523 Views
It's always hard to pigeonhole things, especially as they become more specific
- 24/04/2011 06:27:28 PM
1162 Views
The "dated" idea is interesting.
- 23/04/2011 08:08:26 PM
1233 Views
PS the Takeshi Kovacs books are great, and you should all go read them *NM*
- 23/04/2011 08:09:54 PM
535 Views
*MN*
I think it underestimates cyberpunk, and overestimates (present) reality (yes, spoilers now).
- 24/04/2011 02:24:01 AM
1251 Views