Well, we aren't going to agree at all (and I DID say it was opinion)
SilverWarder Send a noteboard - 07/03/2010 09:00:37 AM
Your points are also OPINION. Not fact, nothing but.
And if it was to be legalized tomorrow would you start growing pot? I bet you wouldn't.
Punishment is pointless. The hardened criminals aren't punished by our system, they're just removed from circulation for awhile. Going to prison is a bit of a badge of honor.
But yes, if the system were less burdened with valueless 'crimes' then it would run more smoothly.
Not as many as you think. Almost everyone speeds a certain amount now and the fines can be pretty steep even for those folks.
However, I will agree that for very direct cause and effect things like speeding there probably is some deterrent effect.
It doesn't really work for more serious crimes though. That's been proven (repeatedly) and it most definitely doesn't work for crimes of passion as those folks are already in a screwed up headspace and aren't thinking about consquences.
People are actually really bad at long term consequences. So bad at them in fact that the new credit card laws in the States are designed to reduce how effectively credit card lendors can take advantage of this known fact.
When you start try to make points with such a silly opening you've pretty much damned yourself. Try again.
Punishment only makes victim's families feel a little better. It doesn't bring their loved ones back or return their lost belongings. Some kind of weregild would be far superior.
Not true nowadays. DNA testing can provide it in many cases. So can photos, video and the like. It's not a majority of cases, but it's much larger than it used to be.
I know it is a consideration to me. I could probably make a living growing pot but the idea of going to prison scare the crap out of me.
And if it was to be legalized tomorrow would you start growing pot? I bet you wouldn't.
I am not against rehabilitation but punishment needs to be part of equalization as well. Part of the problem is the system is overwhelmed with drugs cases that really have no reason to be in prison. If the system was smaller it would be more manageable and more effective.
Punishment is pointless. The hardened criminals aren't punished by our system, they're just removed from circulation for awhile. Going to prison is a bit of a badge of honor.
But yes, if the system were less burdened with valueless 'crimes' then it would run more smoothly.
I'm sorry but that simply isn't true. Knowing the consequences does not stop everyone but it does stop mist from committing crimes. how many people would even follow the speed limit if there is no punishment.
Not as many as you think. Almost everyone speeds a certain amount now and the fines can be pretty steep even for those folks.
However, I will agree that for very direct cause and effect things like speeding there probably is some deterrent effect.
It doesn't really work for more serious crimes though. That's been proven (repeatedly) and it most definitely doesn't work for crimes of passion as those folks are already in a screwed up headspace and aren't thinking about consquences.
People are actually really bad at long term consequences. So bad at them in fact that the new credit card laws in the States are designed to reduce how effectively credit card lendors can take advantage of this known fact.
It can't be about revenge - that' pointless and lowers the state to a pretty abominable level. Horse shit. *SNIP*
When you start try to make points with such a silly opening you've pretty much damned yourself. Try again.
Punishment only makes victim's families feel a little better. It doesn't bring their loved ones back or return their lost belongings. Some kind of weregild would be far superior.
The problem is you almost never get the level of certainty you are speaking of.
Not true nowadays. DNA testing can provide it in many cases. So can photos, video and the like. It's not a majority of cases, but it's much larger than it used to be.
May God stand between you and harm in all the empty places you must walk.
Old Egyptian Blessing
Old Egyptian Blessing
A level-of-comfort question regarding imprisonment of mixed innocent and guilty groups.
- 05/03/2010 02:39:53 AM
326 Views
as things stands, I don't think we'd ever reach a level where that'd be necessary oO
- 05/03/2010 03:24:07 AM
205 Views
100%
- 05/03/2010 03:47:31 AM
212 Views
Law of averages says there are certainly many innocent people in prison.
- 05/03/2010 04:09:41 AM
198 Views
Doesn't matter
- 05/03/2010 04:22:19 AM
187 Views
Clarification: X% of them definitely did not meet the standards of reasonable doubt.
- 05/03/2010 09:44:09 PM
171 Views
A relevant question; it seems to hinge on where one draws the line.
- 05/03/2010 04:19:34 AM
175 Views
I never really liked silly questions like this
- 05/03/2010 02:23:36 PM
205 Views
If there were 2,000,000 innocent and only 1 guilty, retrying everyone would not be practical.
- 05/03/2010 09:22:16 PM
177 Views
That's silly though
- 05/03/2010 09:39:53 PM
183 Views
Re: That's silly though
- 05/03/2010 11:11:50 PM
191 Views
Re: That's silly though
- 06/03/2010 12:11:06 AM
174 Views
what does the chance of reoffending have to do with guilt?
- 05/03/2010 10:02:21 PM
163 Views
Debt can be paid off, leaving the question of rehabilitation. *NM*
- 05/03/2010 10:32:38 PM
67 Views
I still don't see the realtionship to guilt
- 05/03/2010 10:59:28 PM
156 Views
Re: I still don't see the realtionship to guilt
- 05/03/2010 11:31:51 PM
170 Views
there is a reason they call it the justice system and not the rehabilation system
- 05/03/2010 11:33:55 PM
187 Views
It's called all kinds of things
- 06/03/2010 12:02:00 AM
185 Views
Re: It's called all kinds of things
- 06/03/2010 05:44:32 AM
175 Views
Well, we aren't going to agree at all (and I DID say it was opinion)
- 07/03/2010 09:00:37 AM
149 Views