Active Users:432 Time:06/03/2026 05:03:35 AM
Sidenote Charles W Mill died this week Roland00 Send a noteboard - 22/09/2021 04:45:03 PM

View original post
If you want, we can do 50 more rounds of this as we add new confounds that disprove your statement that "voting as your constituents want" is what all politicians do.

Or you can accept that this is neither completely true nor necessary for success in politics, and as leaders, Senators have an obligation to use their access to greater amounts of information, and their ability to request any kind of study they want, to inform the public of the risks of what they want, and suggest ways to account for catastrophic damage while not leaving their constituents in the lurch economically.

Is that an idealistic scenario? Yes. But in that ideal, as in the now, the judgement of politicians matters, which means pointing out factors that bias their judgement is the duty of the media, both to inform the public and to keep these leaders in check.

You're blaming the media for this, but the real issue is that either out of fear of his constituents or the lack of sufficient information (which he can access quite easily) and a lack of leadership, Manchin is leaning towards voting for something that will benefit his constituents for the short term, at best, and most likely will harm them on net every year, and the nature of that harm is compounding as we proceed with the current status quo, so he's actively harming them.

You can be cynical about government and say this is how all politicians are. But if so, blaming the media for pointing out ways in which politicians do wrong merely makes your cynical assessment a self-fulfilling prophesy, because nothing then challenges these so-called leaders from their comfortable, thoughtless use of their political power to merely get themselves re-elected.


I am still shooked by this fact, and I am in disbelief I brought Charles Mill up since we are talking ideal theory and non ideal theory.

Reply to message
The NY Times editorials bemoaned Joe Manchin holding Biden’s climate agenda in his hands… - 20/09/2021 02:26:25 AM 634 Views
Is he supposed to be a leader or a vote-button-punch monkey? - 20/09/2021 02:58:22 AM 332 Views
Everyone in Congress votes as their constituents want them to vote. - 20/09/2021 03:35:30 AM 287 Views
They do? - 20/09/2021 03:00:21 PM 294 Views
what a skillful riposte - 20/09/2021 03:26:57 PM 396 Views
If you'd share relevant data... - 20/09/2021 06:56:16 PM 374 Views
one would surmise there is at least a modest connection - 20/09/2021 08:47:57 PM 351 Views
But neither extreme is true - 21/09/2021 12:04:49 AM 354 Views
Did she defeat Crowley because the 14th District is so progressive? - 21/09/2021 12:52:20 AM 290 Views
So now it's ethnicity or voting history that get you re-elected? - 22/09/2021 05:27:11 AM 282 Views
Sidenote Charles W Mill died this week - 22/09/2021 04:45:03 PM 314 Views
Unbiased media is dead, if it ever lived to begin with. Get used to it, old man! - 22/09/2021 12:58:42 AM 323 Views
You’re not wrong - 22/09/2021 02:48:25 AM 296 Views
He is representing his state well. - 22/09/2021 08:19:21 PM 278 Views
I'm not convinced that wind and solar are good long term solutions. - 23/09/2021 08:54:26 PM 374 Views
Nuclear is still the best option. But the modern Green voter is not scientifically literate. - 28/09/2021 09:16:39 PM 263 Views
It's another NIMBY thing. - 28/09/2021 09:38:20 PM 352 Views
Nothing is completely clean - 28/09/2021 10:34:48 PM 347 Views
Obviously, nothing is completely clean - 28/09/2021 11:15:33 PM 317 Views
That is wishcasting - 28/09/2021 11:41:39 PM 359 Views
call it whatever you want - 29/09/2021 05:56:03 PM 291 Views
I never said do not fund research. - 30/09/2021 12:09:49 PM 312 Views
Re: Obviously, nothing is completely clean - 29/09/2021 01:23:07 PM 264 Views
We should import more French people. - 29/09/2021 01:19:50 PM 252 Views
Massachusetts would definitely support building a nuclear power plant - 29/09/2021 01:46:24 PM 333 Views
On that same note... take a good look at a map of the French nuclear power plants. - 29/09/2021 06:40:49 PM 266 Views
exactly - 29/09/2021 06:59:49 PM 313 Views
Coasts have a natural explanation - 29/09/2021 11:15:42 PM 291 Views

Reply to Message