Active Users:1590 Time:17/12/2025 05:17:30 AM
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules
I admit... Etzel Send a noteboard - 28/09/2009 07:49:32 PM
Only one thing makes me think that the messenger was an Asha'man: In an earlier book (LoC?) there is a POV from Graendal when someone makes a gateway, but doesn't fully open it. They sound a chime to which she responds before they gateway finishes opening. She thought something like "it seems someone remembers the courtesy...". The gateway in the prologue to tGS just opens, no pause for "courtesy".
It could be that Moridin, as Naeblis, doesn't think he needs to do that anymore, but I was left with the impression that the gateway was opened by the messenger.


That Graendal is no way muses that the messenger must be a channeler, though. However, I prefer my idea that the messenger is Osan'gar reborn and not just an Asha'man, because his good body seems comparable to those Moridin and Cyndane got.


Transmigration takes a very long time, and it's only been weeks since the Cleansing. We also know that 2nd chances are rare for the DO ... it means that he won't give a third chance to his servants no matter how much they ask.

Besides, calling Graendal 'My Lady'? There is no way he'll be subservient to her, even if he's mindtrapped and filled with all sorts of punishments. Cyndane and Moghedien let her know that they were still Forsaken.


That it's one of my more unorthodox theories.. ;)
However, I think your counter-arguments can be refuted.

We don't know how long a transmigration process actually takes, especially now since the DO's touch is growing more stronger and TG comes nearer. According to the Tellings of the Wheel-timeline the Cleansing happened on day 716. Semirhage was captured on day 748. If the Forsaken meeting in TGS, prologue, happened a few days after this event, the DO had more than one month to transmigrate Osan'gar. Should be enough time if a suitable body is available.

Considering that only Lanfear-reborn was called "last chance" it might imply other reborn Forsaken would get another chance (at least if there aren't traitors), especially because they are such useful to the Shadow (RJ explained that the DO especially trusts on his original Forsaken).

And if Osan'gar really got his last chance now and is mindtrapped, I can see him being even more submissive than before (where he had to serve Rand in a way). And calling Graendal "lady", isn't even such an indignity for Osan'gar, IMO. Normally even high-ranking DF grovel before Forsaken and call them e.g. "great mistress".
Reply to message
TGS Prologue - your thoughts (part 3) *spoilers* Sidious - 20/09/2009 09:38:16 PM 3073 Views
Demandred's Proxies Iceman - 20/09/2009 10:25:36 PM 1025 Views
I still don't know about Murandy Matrimony Cauthon - 20/09/2009 11:54:51 PM 860 Views
agreed it's a best guess, maybe the sea folk either *NM* Iceman - 21/09/2009 12:28:54 AM 718 Views
Does anyone else feel the LOC Forsaken plan was scrapped in an unsatisfactory way? Shannow - 20/09/2009 10:47:37 PM 967 Views
Using the Bowl of Winds and cleansing the taint have altered the plan I guess. bad guys adapted *NM* Iceman - 20/09/2009 11:02:25 PM 360 Views
I think they caused a lot of chaos Rurouni_Kenshin - 21/09/2009 12:28:08 AM 817 Views
Demandred did something right Sidious - 21/09/2009 05:03:49 AM 838 Views
How do you know it was scrapped? NaClH2O - 21/09/2009 05:57:46 PM 810 Views
Which Forsaken do you think will die in TGS? Matrimony Cauthon - 20/09/2009 11:58:30 PM 872 Views
Re: Which Forsaken do you think will die in TGS? Heiko - 21/09/2009 12:33:20 AM 785 Views
I would like to see a Forsaken severed. Darth_Katie - 21/09/2009 01:30:39 AM 795 Views
Theoretically they only get killed off in odd numbered books, right? Seriana Sedai - 21/09/2009 04:11:37 AM 939 Views
Cyndane is bidding her time. Moridin will go down first GameMaster - 17/10/2009 02:51:37 PM 711 Views
Re: Which Forsaken do you think will die in TGS? Corwin - 21/09/2009 06:33:07 AM 893 Views
Re: Which Forsaken do you think will die in TGS? ClubCaved - 22/09/2009 02:16:58 AM 820 Views
That would be a great twist--- Elza could end up saving Rand from his own ability to kill a woman Matrimony Cauthon - 22/09/2009 02:46:03 AM 836 Views
One problem with this Terez - 23/09/2009 01:51:30 AM 655 Views
Re: Which Forsaken do you think will die in TGS? randfandom - 22/09/2009 07:35:15 AM 695 Views
Aran'gar Terez - 23/09/2009 01:56:59 AM 800 Views
A few more thoughts after a re-read of the prologue Etzel - 21/09/2009 05:20:17 PM 1051 Views
Agree with most of this, not sure about Justice and I think Fain... NaClH2O - 21/09/2009 05:41:29 PM 805 Views
Really? Etzel - 21/09/2009 07:12:43 PM 853 Views
I like your idea! Ashaman_Luc - 22/09/2009 02:21:50 AM 740 Views
Huh Sidious - 22/09/2009 03:39:03 PM 837 Views
It's a "theory".. Etzel - 22/09/2009 04:04:56 PM 741 Views
2 thoughts dadof5 - 21/09/2009 08:33:23 PM 918 Views
Faile NaClH2O - 22/09/2009 02:02:46 AM 744 Views
Thoughts on Faile The Wandering Gambler - 22/09/2009 02:05:27 AM 946 Views
Comments on Graendal's PoV Etzel - 21/09/2009 09:08:06 PM 1164 Views
Anyone else dislike the way the Power is being described? Sidious - 22/09/2009 03:48:58 PM 908 Views
Who made this Gateway anyway? Etzel - 22/09/2009 05:03:48 PM 823 Views
Re: Who made this Gateway anyway? Sidious - 22/09/2009 11:04:06 PM 878 Views
Hmmm... Etzel - 23/09/2009 02:50:44 PM 755 Views
Can't spy Rurouni_Kenshin - 23/09/2009 06:10:40 PM 699 Views
I meant Moridin's messenger as a possible spy Etzel - 23/09/2009 06:35:04 PM 715 Views
Re: I meant Moridin's messenger as a possible spy Rurouni_Kenshin - 23/09/2009 10:10:28 PM 679 Views
Well... Etzel - 24/09/2009 06:49:14 PM 735 Views
Re: TGS Prologue - your thoughts (part 3) *spoilers* Gerbeaud - 22/09/2009 04:05:57 PM 910 Views
That at least can be explained alanna aes sedai - 23/09/2009 02:41:24 AM 769 Views
A general problem Etzel - 22/09/2009 06:47:45 PM 1031 Views
I have the same uneasy feeling Sidious - 22/09/2009 11:05:58 PM 749 Views
Re: A general problem Rurouni_Kenshin - 22/09/2009 11:12:19 PM 752 Views
Ituraldes Stike at the Seanchan The Dude - 22/09/2009 08:11:05 PM 974 Views
General comment about inconsistencies... entyti - 23/09/2009 04:15:09 AM 1050 Views
Re: General comment about inconsistencies... AliasRY - 23/09/2009 09:53:08 AM 951 Views
Re: General comment about inconsistencies... bogotabandit2 - 24/09/2009 06:51:21 AM 874 Views
An alternative or additional power base for Demandred Etzel - 23/09/2009 03:32:24 PM 818 Views
I found it interesting that creatures in the blight don't obey the Chosen Lanfear - 23/09/2009 10:08:44 PM 772 Views
Re: I found it interesting that creatures in the blight don't obey the Chosen Rurouni_Kenshin - 24/09/2009 02:53:17 AM 724 Views
Maybe... Etzel - 24/09/2009 06:24:52 PM 761 Views
Predictions of the other PoV? Etzel - 24/09/2009 07:48:35 PM 679 Views
No Elaida? *NM* Rurouni_Kenshin - 24/09/2009 08:59:08 PM 322 Views
Well... Etzel - 25/09/2009 04:18:19 PM 669 Views
Re: Predictions of the other PoV? Timthetrolloc - 26/09/2009 09:20:05 PM 671 Views
Theory on the beautiful messenger Etzel - 25/09/2009 06:48:58 AM 768 Views
Re: Theory on the beautiful messenger eromreven - 27/09/2009 02:46:44 PM 857 Views
It's strange... Etzel - 27/09/2009 03:35:45 PM 669 Views
There is almost zero chance of this Sidious - 28/09/2009 04:58:19 AM 714 Views
I admit... Etzel - 28/09/2009 07:49:32 PM 677 Views
Time line Rurouni_Kenshin - 27/09/2009 09:12:31 PM 673 Views
Re: Time line StinkerSkunk - 27/09/2009 09:40:41 PM 674 Views
Why is it impossible? Rurouni_Kenshin - 27/09/2009 11:58:02 PM 748 Views
Re: Why is it impossible? StinkerSkunk - 28/09/2009 01:02:53 AM 647 Views
It has to be after Toun arrived Rurouni_Kenshin - 12/10/2009 06:49:31 AM 649 Views
Re: It has to be after Toun arrived StinkerSkunk - 12/10/2009 03:18:03 PM 696 Views
I really wish chapters had the dates ajfurst - 28/09/2009 06:26:34 AM 726 Views
Tylee's comment on an alliance with Westlanders... Etzel - 03/10/2009 01:21:24 PM 737 Views
Domination isn't cooperation Rurouni_Kenshin - 03/10/2009 11:50:03 PM 620 Views
It was pointed out by someone at Dragonmount... Etzel - 03/10/2009 04:07:54 PM 780 Views
i'd guess it's in the prologue of the last book. BlackAdder - 13/10/2009 01:10:16 AM 655 Views
What will Perrin and co be up to now? RandAllThor - 16/10/2009 04:40:01 PM 648 Views
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules

Reply to Message

Block Quote Paragraph Quote
Formatting
Smiley Codes