Active Users:280 Time:22/05/2024 12:10:21 AM
Re: This thing is all over the place darius_sedai Send a noteboard - 30/06/2015 09:39:43 PM

View original post
There is so much confusion and dubious interpretation by the authors of this article. It seems pretty clear that RJ only noted down the most superficial of details of his One Power system, while keeping the bulk of the nuance and deeper knowledge in his head.

For starters, which is it now? 66 levels of all females or 66 levels of Aes Sedai? Or is it 60 levels of Aes Sedai? Or 60 levels of all females below Nicola?

If the 12 new levels were added specifically for Nicola and the Supergirls does that mean Nynaeve is on level 1 of that new list? What then about the females who are stronger than Nynaeve?

Another thing: It seems obvious that the levels are not equidistant from each other. As we see, the longevity gain is not consistent across the 72 levels.

Lastly, if Moiraine is indeed on around level 14 or thereabouts - meaning only 13 or so levels below Lanfear (or is that Nynaeve), then it is clear that volume of power channeled has a non-linear relationship with "stuff that you can do with the power".

Meaning that a small increase in volume channeled (strength), ceteris paribus, results in a very large increase in the physical effects you can achieve with the Power.

It would seem evident then that 5% more Power results in for example a fireball twice as big as that which you could create without that extra 5% of Power.

So while "strength" as such might increase in linear fashion, it is in fact a linear representation of some type of geometric "channeling effectiveness" growth.

Daigian can barely launch a fireball. Verin or Alanna can toss fireballs all day long, interspersed with earth eruptions and fists of Wind etc. They are 2 times as strong as Daigian on the strength scale, but their fireballs aren't merely twice the volume of Daigian's. Instead, they are more like 7 or 8 times as lethal as Daigian is.

In short, this list does not make clear what the real world difference in channeling effectiveness is of people on the scale, even if we put aside for a moment their differences in skill and dexterity.

I don't think the current authors really understand RJ's real intentions behind the One Power "Power Distribution". Power as in what people at different levels can actually DO with saidin or saidar.



Well, I think it's always been intuitively obvious that every channeler is fairly unique in their abilities. Talents and Flow strengths play roles in what effects an individual channeler is capable of and RJ seemed rather uninterested in strength as a raw measure. In fact, he went out of his way to illustrate that as stupid way to measure ability.

Domani Drag Queen in the White Tower ... Aran'gar watch out!
Reply to message
Strength in the OP: the Encyclopedia chapter is out! - 24/06/2015 09:56:33 PM 1948 Views
Re: Strength in the OP: the Encyclopedia chapter is out! - 25/06/2015 08:01:04 AM 848 Views
Re: Strength in the OP: the Encyclopedia chapter is out! - 25/06/2015 05:49:52 PM 950 Views
That still would not make sense - 25/06/2015 09:22:48 PM 944 Views
It would - 01/07/2015 07:17:09 PM 981 Views
Re: That still would not make sense - 01/10/2015 11:54:06 PM 1011 Views
Re: Strength in the OP: the Encyclopedia chapter is out! - 25/06/2015 05:23:32 PM 1118 Views
I suspect... - 25/06/2015 05:47:59 PM 961 Views
Re: I suspect... - 25/06/2015 06:33:10 PM 1018 Views
Yeah, a comprehensive scale restricted to AS would not be comprehensive - 25/06/2015 09:22:36 PM 935 Views
Re: Yeah, a comprehensive scale restricted to AS would not be comprehensive - 25/06/2015 09:56:22 PM 898 Views
Sorilea can GRASP the Source reliably; there is no indication she can USE it - 27/06/2015 08:19:19 PM 956 Views
Re: Sorilea can GRASP the Source reliably; there is no indication she can USE it - 29/06/2015 07:58:55 PM 842 Views
Since she looks her age I suspect reaching it is almost entirely due to natural longevity - 29/06/2015 09:16:21 PM 793 Views
Not when you consider Morgase - 30/06/2015 09:02:35 PM 881 Views
Sorilea has been at it far longer than Morgase - 02/07/2015 12:21:55 AM 884 Views
Re: Sorilea has been at it far longer than Morgase - 08/07/2015 03:26:43 AM 849 Views
Re: Sorilea has been at it far longer than Morgase - 09/07/2015 02:25:58 AM 878 Views
RJ did say... - 09/07/2015 07:13:01 AM 800 Views
Morgase spent nearly 2 years in the Tower - 09/07/2015 03:22:06 PM 1055 Views
And countless hours of frustrated focus to--fleetingly--grasp the source ONCE (i.e. less than twice) - 10/07/2015 02:51:53 AM 961 Views
doesn't make sense as you describe it - 10/07/2015 04:42:31 PM 778 Views
It does not make sense as Jordan describes it either - 10/07/2015 09:00:36 PM 983 Views
I agree with all of this - 10/07/2015 05:21:40 PM 861 Views
You are wise - 10/07/2015 09:06:16 PM 862 Views
66 levels for women + 6 ( ? ) for men - 27/06/2015 10:58:16 AM 1060 Views
This thing is all over the place - 30/06/2015 02:39:01 PM 989 Views
Re: This thing is all over the place - 30/06/2015 09:39:43 PM 923 Views
Some of it is... - 01/07/2015 08:10:00 PM 1051 Views

Reply to Message