I don't see why not. My game had 16 players and 6 of them were investigators. None of them were flawed. Some were limited, but according to DK, that applies here too.


"Effectively no better than random." Seriously? You were copped and found guilty. Your defense is that the SPLOG is broken. As proof you offer up the fact that you said the SPLOG was broken. You say that your mason allies can confirm it because you told them that the SPLOG was broken on Night 1, before you knew that you had been caught.

But isn't that exactly what you would have done in that situation anyway, being a Skrull and a mason? You've admitted that you like to plan for things; planting that kind of doubt in case you or your scummer friends were investigated is exactly the sort of thing you'd do. The SPLOG was built up in the intro to the game as being important. Having it turn out to be broken and useless would be like Chekhov's gun, and I just don't see that happening in a game based on the comic book genre. We have no reason to doubt the sanity of our cop other than what you tell us. Given the circumstances, I don't think we have any reason to trust you.

I must admit I admire your tenacity, but it's time for you to die.