His reads a lot like the first one I wrote after seeing the play on YouTube; the only difference is that I did not specifically say then that Tate had both hands on the ball at the start of the catch, because I thought that was pretty obvious (evidently not.)

This: http://www.readandfindout.com/community/messageboard/262010/
and this: http://www.readandfindout.com/community/messageboard/262017/ read very similarly (not that I am accusing Cannoli of parroting my comments, rather, the logic is very straightforward and reasonable IF one knows the rules.)

Any beefs should be directed at the Competition Committee who created the rule decades ago, not at the refs who correctly applied it Monday.