Active Users:869 Time:10/01/2026 12:31:45 AM
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules
Yes, she did state it. Deadsy Send a noteboard - 06/12/2009 08:57:47 PM
That didn't matter to the binder.

She didn't state that Gitara died without saying anything, she told two people who were there to lie, and which lie to tell.

She could not say that as a statement, but as instructions she could.

Intent and result.



That's the point, that she did state it. Aes Sedai can state things as long as you're not trying to trick someone, according to RJ.

There was a huge argument about this when NS was released

"You will tell no one about this, not for any reason. If necessary, lie. Even to a sister. Gitara died without speaking. Do you understand me?"
Reply to message
Cadsuane lies! darius_sedai - 06/12/2009 06:10:41 PM 2269 Views
Re: Cadsuane lies! joepo - 06/12/2009 06:18:39 PM 1465 Views
Sarcasm is one thing Ryan - 06/12/2009 06:43:12 PM 1181 Views
I disagree darius_sedai - 06/12/2009 06:51:27 PM 1139 Views
RJ has said they're allowed to be sarcastic TheCrownless - 06/12/2009 07:07:32 PM 1086 Views
How does that jive with the Oaths? darius_sedai - 06/12/2009 07:13:21 PM 1149 Views
Good point, but in that same book Tamra said that Gitara didn't say anything before dying *NM* Deadsy - 06/12/2009 07:53:31 PM 528 Views
Re: Good point, but in that same book Tamra said that Gitara didn't say anything before dying DomA - 06/12/2009 08:03:36 PM 1192 Views
Yes, she did state it. Deadsy - 06/12/2009 08:57:47 PM 1100 Views
Re: Yes, she did state it. DomA - 07/12/2009 01:39:07 AM 1090 Views
Re: How does that jive with the Oaths? DomA - 06/12/2009 07:57:10 PM 1066 Views
The Oaths focus on INTENT beetnemesis - 06/12/2009 10:01:27 PM 1130 Views
None of what you describe is an Oath ingrained into your bones. darius_sedai - 07/12/2009 01:52:49 AM 965 Views
It's ENTIRELY about self-rationalization Nameless Ashaman - 07/12/2009 03:59:00 AM 929 Views
^This. *NM* Nate - 07/12/2009 08:23:27 AM 543 Views
Because it isn't a lie DomA - 06/12/2009 07:44:29 PM 1122 Views
I understand this, I'm not arguing that an AS should not be able to be sarcastic darius_sedai - 06/12/2009 08:08:15 PM 1102 Views
Verin didn't say it sarcastically. Darth_Katie - 06/12/2009 08:11:31 PM 916 Views
Really? I never would have known that without you darius_sedai - 06/12/2009 08:39:56 PM 1032 Views
Re: I understand this, I'm not arguing that an AS should not be able to be sarcastic DomA - 06/12/2009 08:35:23 PM 1134 Views
Quote for you darius_sedai - 06/12/2009 08:42:52 PM 1072 Views
Re: Quote for you DomA - 07/12/2009 01:30:57 AM 978 Views
The sarcasm was for him repeating himself to her. The "remember" is the part she's refering to. Onarishma - 07/12/2009 10:15:06 AM 901 Views
That's why I think this example of sarcasm works as opposed to Cadsuane who makes a false statement darius_sedai - 07/12/2009 03:17:52 PM 967 Views
sarcasm is sarcasm. In both instances their is technically a lie. Onarishma - 07/12/2009 11:28:02 PM 911 Views
Not at all the case darius_sedai - 07/12/2009 11:58:42 PM 992 Views
Do you really believe he waited till the last minute to tell Seonid? Onarishma - 14/12/2009 01:32:37 PM 1080 Views
That's the whole point of her being able to say what she did! darius_sedai - 14/12/2009 04:05:24 PM 857 Views
What about the Sheriam thing? Legolas - 07/12/2009 01:49:32 PM 997 Views
Re: What about the Sheriam thing? DomA - 07/12/2009 02:15:25 PM 869 Views
But surely an Aes Sedai can answer a question she hasn't fully heard yet. Legolas - 07/12/2009 03:06:34 PM 1113 Views
I actually don't take it as proof. Nameless Ashaman - 07/12/2009 09:00:58 PM 927 Views
Yeah, I thought about that possibility too... Legolas - 07/12/2009 10:21:16 PM 1220 Views
Sarcasm Sidious - 06/12/2009 07:14:47 PM 1145 Views
It's obviously meant to be sarcasm, I just don't like darius_sedai - 06/12/2009 07:18:40 PM 941 Views
Here is what RJ said about it Etzel - 06/12/2009 07:41:18 PM 1102 Views
Well I have to say I think RJ made the wrong call with this one *NM* darius_sedai - 06/12/2009 07:43:47 PM 471 Views
Like my momma used to say... Mat_Cauthon33 - 06/12/2009 11:27:22 PM 1003 Views
Your momma is a wise woman. RugbyPlayingAshaman - 07/12/2009 03:14:27 PM 903 Views
Agreed. johnnymack - 07/12/2009 01:45:39 AM 900 Views
You can already drive a truck through the oaths. Does this one additional tiny gap really matter? Nameless Ashaman - 07/12/2009 04:07:16 AM 945 Views
Alys (Moiraine alias) *NM* BlackAdder - 07/12/2009 05:13:18 AM 1250 Views
No, no it doesn't. johnnymack - 08/12/2009 03:31:11 PM 895 Views
Re: No, no it doesn't. Nameless Ashaman - 08/12/2009 04:41:42 PM 917 Views
what do you think a RL lie detector would tell in this case? redhand - 07/12/2009 12:27:07 PM 871 Views
in RL you would get warned by the investigator to cooperate AgentOrange - 07/12/2009 01:04:33 PM 905 Views
But how would the machine reading indicate? redhand - 07/12/2009 07:04:22 PM 903 Views
Usually you're s'possed to answer with a yes or no. It's easy to tell when you're evasive AgentOrange - 09/12/2009 10:46:58 PM 949 Views
Where's the problem? Shadowkiller - 09/12/2009 04:18:40 PM 842 Views
It's in the way the Oath is worded darius_sedai - 09/12/2009 05:14:39 PM 910 Views
Re: It's in the way the Oath is worded Shadowkiller - 09/12/2009 05:36:59 PM 912 Views
See the Cadsuane quote, but I'll give you another one darius_sedai - 09/12/2009 06:15:32 PM 1105 Views
PS You misread my original quote darius_sedai - 09/12/2009 11:00:56 PM 839 Views
You're so right. My fault. *NM* Shadowkiller - 10/12/2009 12:57:29 AM 851 Views
No worries! It a discussion forum, we're supposed to discuss darius_sedai - 10/12/2009 12:58:39 AM 967 Views
Re: PS You misread my original quote taura-tierno - 28/12/2009 10:04:51 PM 1034 Views
Lies, untruths, sarcasm, and meaning Shadowkiller - 09/12/2009 07:46:25 PM 986 Views
We are starting understand each other darius_sedai - 09/12/2009 10:09:41 PM 943 Views
Re: We are starting understand each other Shadowkiller - 10/12/2009 01:03:08 AM 874 Views
Completely agree darius_sedai - 10/12/2009 01:23:36 AM 949 Views
Why do you think she *had* noticed the Aiel? *NM* Lord Haart - 14/12/2009 02:02:24 PM 399 Views
because she arrived with Rand and dozens of Maidens, darius_sedai - 15/12/2009 01:02:43 AM 869 Views
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules

Reply to Message

Block Quote Paragraph Quote
Formatting
Smiley Codes