Active Users:508 Time:31/10/2026 01:50:58 PM
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules
You can be much weaker than someone, and hold them shielded, if they are already cut off... Shannow Send a noteboard - 10/06/2010 08:19:15 PM
To state again...

Silviana asks both Katarine and Barasine to hold Egwene's shield at night. As time wore on, Egwene would be able to embrace more of the power, so if she was as strong as two Moiraine's neither of them should have questioned the order. Yet, Katarine says that Barasine alone would suffice. To which Silviana replies Egwene is tricky, not that she is too strong.

What is even more strong evidence against your argument is that Egwene thinks that as long as she can reach the source, she can tackle all five of the Aes Sedai in the coach with her. She even says she wasn't given a very strong dose!

Are you now going to argue that a woman who cannot break the shield of someone half her strength or less (according to your calculations) can somehow defeat five Aes Sedai in battle?


Aes Sedai range in strength from Daigian to Moiraine - and this strength range encompasses a tripling of strength.

This means that if you can handle Amys and Melaine combined, you can handle 5 or 6 Daigians.

So, if Ewgene is close to twice as strong as Moiraine, then she is close to 4 times as strong as the average Aes Sedai.


It is stated very clearly in the books that if you are already cut off from the source, a shield can be maintained over you by a MUCH weaker person. As an example, Amys (at just over half Egwene's strength) was able to hold her shielded for a short while.

And Nynaeve states it clearly in the books as well.
Reply to message
Several good MAFOs from Dragonmount Etzel - 10/06/2010 07:07:55 PM 2582 Views
Some good RAFOs here Skeeve the Great - 10/06/2010 07:31:56 PM 1299 Views
Yeah... Etzel - 10/06/2010 07:36:55 PM 1208 Views
Maria's answer to question 20 is ground-breaking! Logain - 10/06/2010 07:36:40 PM 1509 Views
No, it merely means that the Bell Curve does not refer to absolute strength... Shannow - 10/06/2010 07:42:31 PM 1316 Views
See the question again man! fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 07:48:57 PM 1298 Views
That contradicts your assertion that Moiraine is stronger than the average woman... Shannow - 10/06/2010 07:50:11 PM 1371 Views
How? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 07:54:41 PM 1307 Views
I need to re-evaluate nothing! fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 07:46:20 PM 1305 Views
Think logically for a moment... Shannow - 10/06/2010 07:49:10 PM 1131 Views
Who said Egwene is twice as strong as Moiraine? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 07:52:27 PM 1435 Views
Aviendha did in FoH... Shannow - 10/06/2010 07:54:32 PM 1131 Views
Nope! fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 07:55:55 PM 1321 Views
Your quotes are faulty Sidious - 10/06/2010 07:57:18 PM 1304 Views
In what sense though? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 07:59:00 PM 1353 Views
Forkroot Sidious - 10/06/2010 08:04:50 PM 1301 Views
Again... later that night? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:05:39 PM 1136 Views
What do you mean? Sidious - 10/06/2010 08:07:24 PM 1292 Views
See below... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:11:24 PM 1175 Views
Re: See below... Sidious - 10/06/2010 08:12:34 PM 1235 Views
I just did. fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:16:09 PM 1125 Views
Well then we disagree Sidious - 10/06/2010 08:18:10 PM 1280 Views
BUT WHAT ABOUT LATER IN THE NIGHT! fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:20:21 PM 1119 Views
Ah, you mean later later ... Sidious - 10/06/2010 08:29:59 PM 1214 Views
Forkroot wears off, you know? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:45:33 PM 1302 Views
Yes I know Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:05:29 PM 1311 Views
I've explained it before in this thread... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:17:10 PM 1265 Views
Re: I've explained it before in this thread... Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:37:39 PM 1288 Views
Re: I've explained it before in this thread... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:51:40 PM 1211 Views
Re: I've explained it before in this thread... Sidious - 10/06/2010 10:05:37 PM 1272 Views
Are you sure you're feeling fine? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 10:18:44 PM 1299 Views
Re: Are you sure you're feeling fine? Sidious - 10/06/2010 10:29:04 PM 1396 Views
Re: Are you sure you're feeling fine? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 10:47:00 PM 1186 Views
RJ writes that Amys cannot hold Egwene. BS writes that Barasene can. Who are you gonna believe? Shannow - 10/06/2010 08:31:35 PM 1112 Views
It wasn't BS... both were RJ! fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:41:54 PM 1289 Views
In that case, there is no problem... Shannow - 10/06/2010 08:45:05 PM 1363 Views
But that isn't what the text says... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:57:42 PM 1084 Views
How can Egwene be strong enough to overcome Katerine and Silviana together then? Shannow - 10/06/2010 09:07:36 PM 1357 Views
She also says Egwene is Aes Sedai in the same sentence... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:25:16 PM 1354 Views
Yeah, both were RJ Sidious - 10/06/2010 08:49:13 PM 1179 Views
Yeah yeah... RJ lied, Maria lied. Only you make sense. I'm finished with this debate. fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:59:06 PM 1289 Views
Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:07:52 PM 1301 Views
Really? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:29:22 PM 1138 Views
Re: Really? Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:39:21 PM 1277 Views
Re: Really? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:43:41 PM 1137 Views
Re: Really? Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:50:23 PM 1290 Views
I haven't refuted? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:53:17 PM 1342 Views
Here's what is clear: Shannow - 10/06/2010 09:02:41 PM 1174 Views
IMO it's easy to disprove Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:22:23 PM 1149 Views
Dude... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:27:34 PM 1088 Views
At least we agree on one thing Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:29:14 PM 1193 Views
No... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:32:06 PM 1166 Views
Re: No... Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:43:59 PM 1288 Views
fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:57:25 PM 1111 Views
Re: Sidious - 10/06/2010 10:12:29 PM 1201 Views
Re: fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 10:34:28 PM 1243 Views
Thought on this darius_sedai - 13/06/2010 01:09:29 PM 1110 Views
yet 4 women can still hold Rand in LoC ... he can't break the Shield until it's down to 3 darius_sedai - 13/06/2010 12:47:43 PM 1002 Views
Have to agree with Sidious on this point darius_sedai - 11/06/2010 02:49:58 AM 1128 Views
That was kind of my point... fionwe1987 - 11/06/2010 12:19:23 PM 848 Views
of course Katerine would have complained darius_sedai - 12/06/2010 12:53:31 PM 1254 Views
The rate forkroot wears off? Rurouni_Kenshin - 16/06/2010 12:36:38 PM 1278 Views
You missed that she isn't being given Forkroot at night at all! fionwe1987 - 16/06/2010 04:47:59 PM 1126 Views
Typos, screwed up what I meant Rurouni_Kenshin - 17/06/2010 02:31:50 AM 1128 Views
You are... fionwe1987 - 17/06/2010 04:32:47 AM 1364 Views
Maria's other answer adresses this... Shannow - 10/06/2010 08:14:54 PM 1036 Views
Then one Aes Sedai cannot shield her. But one did. fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:16:41 PM 1138 Views
You can be much weaker than someone, and hold them shielded, if they are already cut off... Shannow - 10/06/2010 08:19:15 PM 1156 Views
But, if you are much stronger, you can break that shield... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:22:25 PM 1128 Views
Easy... Shannow - 10/06/2010 08:24:59 PM 1098 Views
What has that got to do with it? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:32:56 PM 1302 Views
Amys is not LESS than half of Egwene's strength. You cannot hold someone if you are LESS than half.. Shannow - 10/06/2010 08:47:41 PM 1215 Views
Amys is as strong as Moiraine, at the most one level lower. Barasine is weaker than Katarine, who... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:00:26 PM 1328 Views
I can agree with that. Shannow - 10/06/2010 09:09:07 PM 1103 Views
How can you agree with it? Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:13:55 PM 1290 Views
I'm thinking Berowin here... Shannow - 10/06/2010 09:16:41 PM 1320 Views
Exactly. fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:18:19 PM 1156 Views
... Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:12:21 PM 1086 Views
Agreed, but... Shannow - 10/06/2010 09:13:59 PM 1253 Views
Re: Agreed, but... Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:16:30 PM 1042 Views
Good point... Shannow - 10/06/2010 09:18:53 PM 1264 Views
Or, you know, you're wrong? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:27:55 PM 1122 Views
Re: Good point... Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:28:02 PM 1372 Views
We've had this discussion before darius_sedai - 13/06/2010 01:59:34 PM 1270 Views
Or, you know, you can have the grace to question your antiquated strength list... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:22:51 PM 1110 Views
The Bell Curve fits perfectly if one simple fact is true... Shannow - 10/06/2010 09:31:31 PM 1120 Views
Or, you know, you can stop misinterpreting Aviendha... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:40:05 PM 1194 Views
I'd be perfectly happy to adjust my list if it made sense Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:32:35 PM 1084 Views
Uhhh? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:41:59 PM 1062 Views
Re: Uhhh? Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:48:58 PM 1065 Views
DUDE! fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:58:59 PM 1100 Views
Re: DUDE! Sidious - 10/06/2010 10:09:11 PM 1057 Views
I explained... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 10:27:44 PM 1077 Views
Re: I explained... Sidious - 10/06/2010 10:45:58 PM 1242 Views
Rand seems to shield Egwene and Elayne TOGETHER, pretty easily... Shannow - 10/06/2010 09:54:03 PM 1728 Views
That's fairly simple, actually... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 10:08:53 PM 1326 Views
Nope. Rand was also cut off from the Source when he broke a shield held by 3 Aes Sedai... Shannow - 10/06/2010 11:18:41 PM 1288 Views
Because that channeler is much stronger? I'm not getting your confusion here. *NM* fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 11:27:31 PM 611 Views
Your Aes Sedai are close to the average woman in strength, right... Shannow - 10/06/2010 11:42:01 PM 1371 Views
You are making a couple of mistakes darius_sedai - 13/06/2010 02:28:41 PM 1201 Views
You're missing an important point... fionwe1987 - 14/06/2010 11:10:55 PM 1167 Views
Yes, what do you mean? You are actually proving our point... Shannow - 10/06/2010 08:10:50 PM 1031 Views
No, here's the quote: I hate having to pull out my books with their yellowed pages... Shannow - 10/06/2010 08:01:54 PM 1110 Views
Why would she need surprise against two? That was against five of them... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:04:57 PM 1125 Views
That makes no sense whatsoever... Shannow - 10/06/2010 08:06:53 PM 1101 Views
Simply this... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:13:42 PM 1116 Views
Very poor evidence Sidious - 10/06/2010 08:11:26 PM 1287 Views
No it isn't... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:18:09 PM 1247 Views
Re: No it isn't... Sidious - 10/06/2010 08:32:17 PM 1282 Views
no she said Egwene is stronger than Amys and Melaine combined darius_sedai - 11/06/2010 12:46:29 AM 1193 Views
The actual quote says Amys and Melaine combined... Shannow - 11/06/2010 12:25:07 PM 1250 Views
Here's the problem with that... fionwe1987 - 11/06/2010 12:42:41 PM 1106 Views
Linked circles are more effective than individual channelers... Shannow - 11/06/2010 01:57:43 PM 1213 Views
That much stronger? fionwe1987 - 14/06/2010 11:06:18 PM 1261 Views
On this we agree. darius_sedai - 13/06/2010 02:34:45 PM 1071 Views
I think you are misreading her. Skeeve the Great - 10/06/2010 07:47:06 PM 1078 Views
Bingo *NM* Sidious - 10/06/2010 07:51:29 PM 707 Views
Please explain what you mean by "channeler" and "power" distribution. *NM* Logain - 10/06/2010 09:23:36 PM 668 Views
Re: Please explain what you mean by "channeler" and "power" distribution. Skeeve the Great - 10/06/2010 10:11:23 PM 1279 Views
Yes. You can't extrapolate a generalized macro level scale to micro level individuals. RugbyPlayingAshaman - 11/06/2010 12:16:24 AM 1154 Views
I don't agree Sidious - 10/06/2010 07:49:41 PM 1144 Views
BAH! Its infuriating how you have so many blinders... Eerily Aes Sedai of you. fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 07:54:23 PM 1349 Views
Hmm... Sidious - 10/06/2010 07:55:59 PM 1081 Views
Because of the question to which she responded... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 07:57:55 PM 1052 Views
Re: Because of the question to which she responded... Sidious - 10/06/2010 08:06:16 PM 1209 Views
Without contradicting the latter... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:15:11 PM 1122 Views
Ah well Sidious - 10/06/2010 08:20:32 PM 1095 Views
Which is even more evidence... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:23:28 PM 1232 Views
Dude Sidious - 10/06/2010 08:30:57 PM 1281 Views
It isn't omission fionwe1987 - 14/06/2010 10:54:47 PM 1221 Views
omg not this again *NM* BlackAdder - 10/06/2010 07:52:26 PM 1218 Views
Great! Two of my OP strength ideas have been solidified! fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 07:39:53 PM 1313 Views
Nope... Shannow - 10/06/2010 07:46:31 PM 1182 Views
Who said Cadsuane was 50? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 07:51:14 PM 1217 Views
So how can Egwene be twice as strong as Moiraine, if Moiraine is at 55? Shannow - 10/06/2010 07:53:11 PM 1095 Views
She cannot be because she isn't. Silviana can shield Egwene alone, for God's sake. So can Amys! fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 07:56:26 PM 1018 Views
Amys can't hold her properly Sidious - 10/06/2010 07:59:47 PM 1043 Views
What about later that night? fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 08:02:16 PM 1082 Views
No she didn't darius_sedai - 16/06/2010 03:02:21 PM 1187 Views
No she didn't what? fionwe1987 - 16/06/2010 04:46:05 PM 1317 Views
Re: No she didn't what? darius_sedai - 17/06/2010 06:16:16 AM 1081 Views
Re: No she didn't what? fionwe1987 - 17/06/2010 06:02:57 PM 1208 Views
you are arguing in a circle darius_sedai - 17/06/2010 06:31:19 PM 1595 Views
Why do you think it's a linear scale? Rurouni_Kenshin - 16/06/2010 05:25:56 AM 1206 Views
That's simple... fionwe1987 - 16/06/2010 06:36:44 AM 1187 Views
Re: That's simple... Rurouni_Kenshin - 16/06/2010 12:27:07 PM 1147 Views
Your concept is not mathematically right. So yeah, forget discussing it. fionwe1987 - 16/06/2010 04:41:13 PM 1295 Views
Dang, Cyndane isn't using Cabriana's body. Gher - 10/06/2010 08:25:20 PM 1176 Views
But they didn't look alike anyway. *NM* Etzel - 10/06/2010 08:59:35 PM 699 Views
Eh, yeah. Gher - 12/06/2010 08:24:10 PM 1085 Views
The blue flash RAFO irritates me- I can't see how that will be relevant. The Min thing was new beetnemesis - 10/06/2010 08:50:52 PM 1245 Views
RJ already RAFOed the incident with Thom's knives/daggers before Etzel - 10/06/2010 08:57:52 PM 1328 Views
They RAFO way too much. Tom - 11/06/2010 12:25:56 AM 1063 Views
It isn't, unless she's implying the Creator helped him out or some other such thing RugbyPlayingAshaman - 11/06/2010 12:56:49 AM 1089 Views
Just to make things clear on the strength thing... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:08:02 PM 1347 Views
It is possible Maria was answering the first question and ignoring the second... Logain - 10/06/2010 09:29:59 PM 1104 Views
That still proves my point... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 09:33:10 PM 1284 Views
Re: That still proves my point... Sidious - 10/06/2010 09:45:39 PM 1137 Views
Then why... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 10:00:00 PM 1252 Views
Re: Then why... Sidious - 10/06/2010 10:07:56 PM 1121 Views
God, what stupidity! fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 10:10:32 PM 1071 Views
Re: God, what stupidity! Sidious - 10/06/2010 10:16:38 PM 1170 Views
It doesn't have to be 1-100. fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 10:32:17 PM 1113 Views
Re: It doesn't have to be 1-100. Sidious - 10/06/2010 10:41:02 PM 1441 Views
That's a mathematical impossibility... fionwe1987 - 10/06/2010 11:26:23 PM 1248 Views
Just popping in. I think you're arguing over non-existent delineations. RugbyPlayingAshaman - 11/06/2010 12:44:40 AM 1184 Views
You're pretty much agreeing with me, you know? fionwe1987 - 11/06/2010 12:32:44 PM 1175 Views
Yes. RugbyPlayingAshaman - 14/06/2010 10:31:00 PM 1267 Views
Re: Just to make things clear on the strength thing... Bored - 14/06/2010 11:21:31 PM 1458 Views
Huh? fionwe1987 - 14/06/2010 11:48:43 PM 1049 Views
Also interesting... Etzel - 10/06/2010 09:38:27 PM 1241 Views
I'm even more confused (parallel worlds and the Pattern) entyti - 10/06/2010 09:48:17 PM 1199 Views
Nah,... DomA - 11/06/2010 11:38:20 AM 1153 Views
Fascinating! entyti - 13/06/2010 02:30:42 AM 1276 Views
You know, these things always end up pissing me off. Tom - 11/06/2010 12:25:05 AM 1194 Views
I think she's saving that info for her WoT Encyclopedia. RugbyPlayingAshaman - 11/06/2010 12:54:38 AM 1252 Views
Re: You know, these things always end up pissing me off. TaskmasterJack - 11/06/2010 03:22:53 AM 1266 Views
Re: You know, these things always end up pissing me off. DomA - 11/06/2010 12:29:37 PM 1235 Views
I agree Etzel - 11/06/2010 01:14:36 PM 1329 Views
Re: I agree TaskmasterJack - 12/06/2010 03:02:32 PM 1099 Views
BS didn't answer with "Read and find out" Etzel - 12/06/2010 03:28:05 PM 1148 Views
We were speaking about Maria giving a RAFO on the topic, not Sanderson. *NM* TaskmasterJack - 13/06/2010 12:05:17 AM 629 Views
Actually she said "No"... *NM* Etzel - 13/06/2010 01:06:18 AM 735 Views
I'll rephrase then. It was about Maria saying that she considered giving a RAFO on the question. TaskmasterJack - 13/06/2010 01:44:19 AM 1135 Views
Yeah, sorry for the rolly-eyed smiley! Was a bit mean... Etzel - 13/06/2010 09:19:13 AM 1163 Views
I agree with Jack and Sidious and not with you. Tom - 11/06/2010 03:20:30 PM 1254 Views
Well, on the Thom question... Etzel - 11/06/2010 08:25:09 AM 1109 Views
Yeah Sidious - 11/06/2010 08:26:33 AM 1222 Views
Re: Yeah darius_sedai - 15/06/2010 12:25:21 AM 1075 Views
Eh, practically useless. callandor1000 - 14/06/2010 11:50:06 PM 1078 Views
I agree. I think she is saving the good stuff for the encyclopedia. *NM* RugbyPlayingAshaman - 15/06/2010 04:17:07 PM 594 Views
Yeah. I do think she's taking advantage of these poor saps, though. callandor1000 - 17/06/2010 03:52:33 PM 1666 Views
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules

Reply to Message

Block Quote Paragraph Quote
Formatting
Smiley Codes