Active Users:819 Time:16/11/2026 09:19:35 PM
Re: Aran'gar fionwe1987 Send a noteboard - 16/12/2015 06:50:27 PM

View original post
It's likely that no Ash'aman is nearly as skilled as any Aes Sedai as the most senior of their member has channeled for less time than any novice. That said, AS don't know squat about saidin and vice versa... it's likely all the circles were completely inefficient at melding the two Powers.

Asha'man practice destruction way more, though. Not saying he is definitely more skilled, but the possibility exists.

It proves nothing, and it's absurd to think that ALL the quotes on this issue are incorrect, especially from people who actually know how strong they all are. We know for a fact that the Companion doesn't know how strong Cadsuane is, and there are several other potential mess ups like Rahvin.

But they don't know how strong the other party is, in these discussions.

Aviendha was fairly unused to the OP, and we don't know for a fact that in tFoH she could correctly say how much any woman could hold. Till Moiraine saw Lanfear, she had never faced a female Forsaken. Egwene had met Lanfear and Moghedien, but had no real clue how much stronger the men were.

The Companion "doesn't know" Cadsuane's strength? No. Terez, who has read the notes, is pretty clear RJ changed his mind on her strength. But that her angreal took her to ++1 didn't change, so far as we know. All that changed is her own strength, and therefore the strength of the angreal.

When RJ wrote the scene in WH, he may or may not have changed his mind on Cadsuane's potential. But that he saw her as ++1 with her angreal is the assumption that requires us to make the fewest leaps.


I would go as far to say that the Companion should not be considered canon on several issues,

That's a load of crap, Sidious. There are certain errors, sure, but the stuff we're talking about are confirmed by Terez. She said she saw Rahvin's strength, IIRC, and also the change in Cadsuane's. And these notes were mostly updated till KoD.
as well as the last few books of the series.

With you on that. But I haven't used any quotes from those books here, I think.
I think it's a very valid point stating that the original author had no part in the verification of these facts, and clearly many of them have been messed up. For instance, Graendal with her angreal fought a few average Aes Sedai and killed one, and yet she managed to hold her own in the Last Battle against an onslought that included Cadsuane AND Talaan, and without her angreal.

But she had a pretty large circle backing her up, remember? She compelled various Aes Sedai and linked with them.
It's completely absurd and BS did less than basic research into the OP before he wrote his part. There are many other OP errors (Taim can't be shielded by will alone, for instance) in the last few books, and his answers to fans have also made me cringe in the past. I'm sorry if it sounds bitter but I suspect you two both agree that RJ's legacy has been handled horribly since his death.

Yes, but the parts of the Companion verified as from the notes don't become invalidated as a result.
Cadsuane's angreal logically makes her a ++1.

That is a fact, not some logical deduction.
She could deflect the power of any attack that hit her, and there were at least two ++2's going for her.

Which scene are you talking about here?
It's likely that two AS fall well short of a ++1 - we have actually seen Rand squash two at the same time like flies while feeling dazed, and with shields no less.

Several things are at issue here, though:

1) Rand had an angreal. We don't know whether or not he used it in this scene. And we don't know its strength.

2) Verin and Alanna were linked, and we don't know exactly how much you lose because of that.

3) More importantly, nothing says someone weaker cannot ever shield someone stronger. Moiraine tried with Merean, which she wouldn't have bothered with if it wasn't possible. We know that even for someone stronger, placing a shield isn't always a hundred percent thing.

4) We don't know what Talent, if any, Rand had with shielding.

All of this, of course, isn't to contradict your point that two random AS probably do fall short of ++1. Remember, Elza says that Cadsuane had to have been using an angreal because she held more than Elza+Merise combined. That means only that Cadsuane's potential of 5(+ was less than Merise+Elza. How much stronger ++1 is than those two we don't know.


Lews Therin himself says that he can handle three women if they aren't too strong, and one must be Forsaken strength to make his life difficult.

First, this would depend on how strong he thinks the average Aes Sedai is, no? He has seen what Moiraine can do, but knows she is the strongest in the Tower. But how accurate his his idea of what strength range most Aes Sedai occupy?

Second, three random linked sisters lose how much? We don't know, for certain. Remember, in KoD Egwene explicitly says that if she could surprise them, she can handle all five of her captors, and none of them are weak. Only when they are all full to the brim with the OP does she say that she would stand no chance. Of course, things like skill come into play here too. Once again, Rand's statement isn't strictly quantitative, like Elza's.

That is highly similar to Egwene's statement that she could not overwhelm a Forsaken linked to Romanda and Lelaine, considering all three of them are weaker than even Moghedien.
Except... we saw 4 channelers, one much much weaker than anyone (Daigian), take down Aran'gar. Forget that, take Verin's circle. Even with her weak angreal, she is likely at best a match for Graendal, and she is definitely not in a stronger circle than Egwene+Romanda+Lelaine.


We also know from Liandrin that it will take about three of them to smother Moghedien.

Smother. Not match, smother. Liandrin knows how skilled Moghedien is, how fast. So she is seeking an overwhelming advantage, and thinks three of them together can do it.
We know that Amys' strength is vague in the series - one quote placing her alongside Moiraine, the other alongside Sheriam. I see nothing ridiculous about Egwene being able to overwhelm the two if she has a strength of 80 and they are at 40-50 each.

We know Melaine is level 17. And per Terez, the notes place Amys at 16. Even if she was at what frankly seems too low a level for her, I don't think Egwene can hold more of the Power than Melaine and Amys combined. But that doesn't mean she can't win in a fight against them!

That is my point. We always took "able to win in a fight" to mean "equal to or stronger in the Power". I'm saying we can't. Elza's statement is one of the only purely quantitative ones we have. She isn't talking about who would win in a fight. She isn't talking about skill. She is talking simply about the amount of Power being held. Thus, it is the only one we can take to evaluate actual volumes of power various characters can draw.

So, when we take Egwene's statement about not being able to face a male Forsaken, we can't just use that to assume Egwene+Lelaine+Romanda will draw less of the OP than Aran'gar. That is just absurd, even by your lowball numbers of Egwene at 80, Amys and Melaine at 40-50. Egwene's reaction is about her lack of knowledge of male Forsaken strength, and what skills they may possess.


We also know that everyone has horribly underestimated the skill of the Forsaken. Alivia is stronger than Cyndane in raw strength alone, and even with a strong angreal and many protective ter'angreal she barely escaped with her life. I have strong doubts whether we can make any conclusions from the Cleansing. We only had a glimpse of it - we know from RJ that Semirhage also fought some of the circles, for instance. It's possible that Semirhage killed Eben or Kumira - it's chaos that we witnessed through a keyhole. We also don't know how powerful these mixed circles are, but it seems like the amplification is substantial.

We know Eben didn't die from facing Semirhage, from Jahar's account given to the Rebel Hall. There's no earthly reason for Daigian to hide the fact that another Forsaken killed Eben from his friend.

As for the Cleansing: I am only making one conclusion about raw strength, and that uses the only quote about raw strength we have. I do not use the individual fights to say anything about the volume of power anyone in those circles can take in.

Reply to message
Sortable, searchable file of Channelers - 28/11/2015 10:01:57 PM 3786 Views
Outstanding job - 29/11/2015 04:15:17 PM 1521 Views
Re: Outstanding job - 29/11/2015 06:53:40 PM 1489 Views
Very impressive. Well done. - 29/11/2015 04:41:52 PM 1653 Views
Re: Very impressive. Well done. - 29/11/2015 06:54:02 PM 1541 Views
Quick Question - 30/11/2015 05:11:17 AM 1693 Views
Nope - 30/11/2015 05:44:04 AM 1762 Views
They do say it - 30/11/2015 10:32:48 AM 1832 Views
I added Rand and Lews Therin to the ++1 Strength - 30/11/2015 03:21:00 PM 1539 Views
Re: I added Rand and Lews Therin to the ++1 Strength - 01/12/2015 08:02:01 AM 1637 Views
Well, it also states that there are gradations within each level too - 01/12/2015 04:26:29 PM 1660 Views
Well maybe - 02/12/2015 06:31:05 AM 1682 Views
Here's how I see it: - 02/12/2015 08:34:54 AM 1655 Views
I agree - 02/12/2015 04:22:52 PM 1702 Views
Re: I agree - 02/12/2015 05:14:50 PM 1862 Views
It's always been confusing - 02/12/2015 06:00:01 PM 1817 Views
Re: It's always been confusing - 02/12/2015 07:27:11 PM 1832 Views
I wholeheartedly agree - 02/12/2015 08:07:39 PM 1606 Views
Re: Here's how I see it: - 02/12/2015 04:46:54 PM 1872 Views
Morgase - 03/12/2015 04:37:47 AM 1722 Views
I agree with you on this - 03/12/2015 03:22:22 PM 1572 Views
Re: Morgase - 03/12/2015 07:46:59 PM 1852 Views
I didn't realize he was being literal in that comment - 03/12/2015 09:29:52 PM 1648 Views
Re: Well maybe - 02/12/2015 03:52:49 PM 1768 Views
Re: Well maybe - 02/12/2015 04:42:37 PM 1819 Views
Probably - 02/12/2015 06:11:42 PM 1592 Views
Re: Probably - 02/12/2015 07:38:50 PM 1699 Views
Indeed - 02/12/2015 08:21:07 PM 1589 Views
Re: Indeed - 03/12/2015 04:08:03 AM 1513 Views
close enough to not debate about it - 03/12/2015 03:47:55 PM 1552 Views
Re: close enough to not debate about it - 03/12/2015 04:14:38 PM 1523 Views
I think you misunderstand what I'm saying - 03/12/2015 04:43:29 PM 1603 Views
Re: I think you misunderstand what I'm saying - 03/12/2015 05:41:17 PM 1607 Views
um, no - 03/12/2015 09:24:31 PM 1518 Views
You two seem like Egwene's interchangeable defenders to me; it's weird to see you fighting. - 04/12/2015 09:21:23 PM 1866 Views
That's on you... - 04/12/2015 09:46:51 PM 1536 Views
We've been arguing on the forums for like 10 years - 06/12/2015 07:36:55 PM 1522 Views
It's Cannoli, Darius - 06/12/2015 08:53:06 PM 1521 Views
LOL *NM* - 07/12/2015 03:26:40 AM 907 Views
Some points - 05/12/2015 11:14:30 AM 1563 Views
Re: close enough to not debate about it - 05/12/2015 11:29:44 AM 1570 Views
Re: I added Rand and Lews Therin to the ++1 Strength - 03/12/2015 07:22:15 AM 1468 Views
Great job - 30/11/2015 05:45:27 AM 1534 Views
Re: Great job - 30/11/2015 03:22:09 PM 1539 Views
Made a few adjustments to add some presumed minimum/maximum levels *NM* - 30/11/2015 04:28:13 PM 991 Views
Some questions - 30/11/2015 05:18:00 PM 1508 Views
Re: Some questions - 30/11/2015 07:26:29 PM 1525 Views
Re: Some questions - 01/12/2015 08:05:01 AM 1723 Views
That's why I added another column to it - 01/12/2015 04:25:04 PM 1607 Views
Some more - 01/12/2015 05:24:40 PM 1626 Views
Re: Some more - 01/12/2015 07:34:20 PM 1672 Views
Re: Some more - 02/12/2015 12:27:40 AM 1662 Views
Re: Some more - 02/12/2015 02:26:53 AM 1583 Views
Re: Some more - 02/12/2015 08:24:49 AM 1634 Views
Re: Some more - 02/12/2015 05:54:49 PM 1658 Views
Re: Some more - 03/12/2015 04:26:45 AM 1437 Views
You said this much better than I did - 03/12/2015 03:53:57 PM 1524 Views
I think the men are much too strong - 02/12/2015 09:01:56 AM 1695 Views
Yes - 02/12/2015 03:06:44 PM 1502 Views
Re: Yes - 02/12/2015 04:45:20 PM 1617 Views
Re: Yes - 02/12/2015 06:39:43 PM 1676 Views
Re: Yes - 03/12/2015 03:56:23 AM 1481 Views
I think when characters quoted information from their world it gets muddled - 03/12/2015 04:19:43 PM 1620 Views
Shielding - 05/12/2015 11:19:40 AM 1465 Views
I feel like there is an RJ quote about this actually - 06/12/2015 06:41:35 PM 1482 Views
Re: I feel like there is an RJ quote about this actually - 07/12/2015 12:39:54 PM 1537 Views
seriously! - 07/12/2015 04:55:43 PM 1524 Views
Who should defer to whom? - 01/12/2015 08:17:22 PM 1667 Views
Interesting... - 02/12/2015 08:44:32 AM 1672 Views
I think there needs to be a pretty significant (5+ levels) difference - 02/12/2015 06:25:35 PM 1702 Views
Good job - 05/12/2015 08:43:09 PM 2025 Views
Some questions - 06/12/2015 12:28:46 AM 1530 Views
Can't offer much - 06/12/2015 12:33:29 AM 1852 Views
Cool. Hopefully Dom will see this... - 06/12/2015 08:58:39 PM 1445 Views
Re: Some questions - 06/12/2015 08:06:56 PM 1482 Views
Then there would be some mention of it, yes/ - 06/12/2015 08:56:10 PM 1463 Views
Not at all ... He clearly had a general sense of how it worked - 07/12/2015 03:28:35 AM 1397 Views
Re: Some questions - 07/12/2015 04:19:43 PM 1811 Views
yet we also know that some things are inherently different for men and women - 07/12/2015 08:15:26 PM 1450 Views
it probably has to do with the fact that the characters in the books are also obsessed with strength - 06/12/2015 07:58:20 PM 1558 Views
Sort of. - 06/12/2015 10:30:36 PM 2027 Views
Makes sense - 07/12/2015 12:38:54 AM 1450 Views
Clearly his strength rankings came in mid-series - 07/12/2015 07:39:59 PM 1674 Views
Re: Clearly his strength rankings came in mid-series - 10/12/2015 05:33:27 AM 1510 Views
Probably something along those lines - 10/12/2015 03:44:48 PM 1390 Views
Lifespan question (Spoiler) - 08/12/2015 05:42:41 PM 1436 Views
Moiraine... - 09/12/2015 02:28:50 AM 1507 Views
That too is possible - 09/12/2015 03:02:12 PM 1459 Views
Some random trends/data points - 08/12/2015 08:39:14 PM 1488 Views
Who is the one Sharan? And I'm surprised so many Seanchan have listed strength levels. *NM* - 09/12/2015 02:42:51 AM 940 Views
Re: Who is the one Sharan? And I'm surprised so many Seanchan have listed strength levels. - 09/12/2015 02:31:18 PM 1544 Views
Not sure she can channel, though - 09/12/2015 03:22:17 PM 1350 Views
Re: Not sure she can channel, though - 09/12/2015 04:54:37 PM 1533 Views
duplicate post ignore *NM* - 09/12/2015 02:31:36 PM 842 Views
duplicate post ignore *NM* - 09/12/2015 02:31:55 PM 872 Views
so.... - 09/12/2015 06:10:41 AM 1537 Views
Nope... - 09/12/2015 03:24:07 PM 1501 Views
Yes - 09/12/2015 03:46:30 PM 1424 Views
Some things to consider - 09/12/2015 04:18:50 PM 1426 Views
Re: Some things to consider - 10/12/2015 05:43:35 AM 1390 Views
Re: Some things to consider - 10/12/2015 06:28:49 AM 1411 Views
Re: Some things to consider - 10/12/2015 11:53:51 AM 1444 Views
Sorilea has always been shown as skilled - 10/12/2015 04:10:37 PM 1516 Views
Re: Some things to consider - 10/12/2015 04:46:29 PM 1448 Views
Re: Some things to consider - 10/12/2015 05:50:17 PM 1425 Views
plenty of weaker ones with notably strong Talents actually - 10/12/2015 06:26:03 PM 1492 Views
This is a flawed list - 11/12/2015 05:14:47 AM 1425 Views
and you are just rationalizing to make your point seem plausible - 11/12/2015 03:10:12 PM 1536 Views
another point about Talents (unrelated to the Strength question) - 11/12/2015 06:06:42 PM 1610 Views
Not really - 11/12/2015 09:09:41 PM 1527 Views
You are trying to force fit thin evidence into a sweeping statement - 11/12/2015 10:13:13 PM 1553 Views
Re: You are trying to force fit thin evidence into a sweeping statement - 12/12/2015 06:46:05 AM 1416 Views
Let's face it a body builder ninja is sort of funny to think about - 12/12/2015 02:55:37 PM 1513 Views
Some quotes - 12/12/2015 01:18:41 AM 1411 Views
Re: Some things to consider - 12/12/2015 03:18:30 AM 1504 Views
Re: Some things to consider - 12/12/2015 06:19:15 AM 1493 Views
Hey ... I have no interest in making you look stupid! - 12/12/2015 03:15:26 PM 1449 Views
Re: Hey ... I have no interest in making you look stupid! - 13/12/2015 11:26:17 AM 1474 Views
Yes, it's a sad thing to realize that this is pretty much the end of the road - 14/12/2015 04:40:50 PM 1420 Views
Re: Yes, it's a sad thing to realize that this is pretty much the end of the road - 15/12/2015 06:01:58 AM 1490 Views
I'm actually perplexed - 15/12/2015 07:19:27 AM 1392 Views
Re: I'm actually perplexed - 17/12/2015 11:36:59 AM 1522 Views
LOL ... Amen! *NM* - 15/12/2015 03:54:55 PM 876 Views
I don't think Elayne was that Strong in TSR - 10/12/2015 04:55:19 PM 1486 Views
Yes and No - 09/12/2015 04:35:48 PM 1399 Views
Re: Yes and No - 09/12/2015 10:41:32 PM 1542 Views
Indeed - 09/12/2015 11:01:03 PM 1477 Views
Ajah Strength Index - 09/12/2015 10:45:29 PM 1476 Views
Greens... - 10/12/2015 12:24:11 AM 1420 Views
Me too honestly - 10/12/2015 03:12:21 AM 1372 Views
Re: Me too honestly - 10/12/2015 04:59:42 AM 1421 Views
Re: Me too honestly - 10/12/2015 04:18:00 PM 1455 Views
Re: Ajah Strength Index - 10/12/2015 05:40:39 AM 1494 Views
I'm not so sure you'd have a chioce - 10/12/2015 04:01:35 PM 1426 Views
Liandrin's 13 - 10/12/2015 09:14:50 PM 1563 Views
Explain - 11/12/2015 05:16:55 AM 1488 Views
Several reasons ... Edited for clarity - 11/12/2015 02:54:58 PM 1605 Views
Bowl of the Winds Circle - 14/12/2015 09:41:33 PM 1529 Views
The Cleansing Circles ... some speculation here - 15/12/2015 05:52:14 PM 1469 Views
If I was Cadsuane I would have done it differently - 15/12/2015 10:01:07 PM 1517 Views
Aran'gar - 16/12/2015 01:11:17 AM 1619 Views
Re: Aran'gar - 16/12/2015 06:54:28 AM 1633 Views
mostly agree - 16/12/2015 06:27:06 PM 1520 Views
Re: Aran'gar - 16/12/2015 06:50:27 PM 1775 Views
Re: Aran'gar - 17/12/2015 10:07:48 AM 1700 Views
We do have some additional clues - 17/12/2015 06:26:20 PM 1649 Views
additional thought - 16/12/2015 06:49:04 PM 1430 Views
Does she know that? - 16/12/2015 06:58:24 PM 1632 Views
I'm speculating of course - 16/12/2015 07:37:10 PM 1503 Views
Strength by National origin - 16/12/2015 09:04:11 PM 1400 Views
Rebels v. Loyalists! - 16/12/2015 10:29:28 PM 1525 Views
Tamra's known hunters - 04/01/2016 06:58:17 PM 1512 Views
Known... - 05/01/2016 01:54:56 AM 1430 Views
Re: Known... - 05/01/2016 02:55:50 AM 1609 Views

Reply to Message